top of page

United Airlines Outage: What Passengers Can Claim Under International Law

59 minutes ago
23 min read

Introduction


The United Airlines outage on November 16, 2026, disrupted departing flights after a technology failure interfered with systems used by flight crews. The incident raised an immediate legal question: can passengers claim compensation when an airline's computer systems fail? The answer depends on the journey, the applicable legal regime, the consequences of the disruption, and the circumstances surrounding the failure.


Passengers do not automatically receive compensation because an airline experiences a system outage. International travelers may have rights under the Montreal Convention of 1999, which governs liability for damage caused by delay in international air carriage. Certain flights departing the European Union may qualify for fixed compensation under Regulation (EC) No 261/2004, commonly known as EU261. Flights involving the United States may also give rise to federal refund rights and assistance under United's published customer-service commitments.


These protections operate differently. The Montreal Convention generally requires proof of legally recoverable damage, whereas EU261 provides standardized compensation when its conditions are satisfied. U.S. federal rules distinguish refunds for transportation that a passenger declines after a qualifying disruption from compensation for the inconvenience of traveling late.


The November 16 incident also presents unresolved factual questions. Public reporting has not established the precise technical cause, the complete list of affected flights, or the final arrival delays experienced by individual passengers. Those details are essential when assessing whether United Airlines must provide compensation, reimbursement, or other assistance.


1. What Happened During the United Airlines Outage?


On November 16, 2026, United Airlines experienced a disruption to operational technology that delayed the departure of certain flights. Pilots reported difficulties obtaining information necessary for aircraft performance calculations, particularly data associated with an aircraft's final weight before takeoff.


The Associated Press reported that the disruption lasted more than 90 minutes and that the problem was resolved approximately one hour and 40 minutes after pilots began reporting difficulties to air traffic controllers. CNN separately attributed an outage duration of approximately 30 minutes to United spokesperson Leslie Scott. The reports may describe different intervals of technical unavailability and operational disruption, but they do not establish a single agreed duration.


Weight and balance calculations are central to safe flight operations. Before departure, crews must establish whether an aircraft can operate within applicable performance limits, considering its load, fuel, runway conditions, and other relevant factors. A failure affecting access to necessary data can prevent a safe departure even when the aircraft itself has no mechanical defect.


Reports also indicated that the disruption affected access to other applications used by flight crews. Reuters described a company-wide web-based problem involving multiple applications, including crew communications. These accounts establish the operational significance of the incident without conclusively identifying the software or infrastructure component responsible.


United stated that flights already airborne and services operated by its United Express regional network were unaffected. The airline also reported that there was no indication of a cybersecurity-related incident. That statement should be distinguished from an independently established technical finding about the outage's ultimate cause.


The number of flights directly delayed by the failure remains uncertain. United reportedly identified fewer than 150 affected flights, while broader flight-tracking figures showed hundreds of United delays during the day. Airline-wide delay statistics cannot automatically be attributed to a particular technical incident.


The outage occurred shortly after a separate nationwide disruption involving Federal Aviation Administration equipment. The two events should not be conflated. The November 16 problem was described as originating within United's operations, whereas the earlier incident concerned federal air traffic control infrastructure. Their different causes and responsible institutions are relevant to the legal obligations associated with an FAA ground stop.


An interruption lasting less than two hours at the systems level can produce a longer delay for a particular passenger. Aircraft may lose departure slots, crews may approach duty-time limits, and connections may become impossible to maintain. Conversely, a passenger whose flight departed shortly after systems were restored may have experienced no legally significant delay.


For compensation purposes, the decisive evidence concerns the affected flight and the consequences for the individual traveler. The duration of the technology failure alone does not establish an entitlement to payment.


2. What Compensation Can Affected Passengers Claim?


Passengers affected by the United Airlines outage may qualify for different remedies depending on their itinerary. The main possibilities are compensation for proven damage under the Montreal Convention, fixed compensation and assistance under EU261, and refunds or customer-service benefits under U.S. rules.


These remedies address different interests. A refund returns the price paid for transportation that the passenger does not use in qualifying circumstances. Fixed compensation under EU261 addresses specified travel disruption without requiring proof of an equivalent financial loss. Damages under the Montreal Convention concern legally recoverable harm caused by delay.


Consider a passenger traveling on a standalone domestic flight between Chicago and Denver. EU261 would ordinarily be irrelevant, and the Montreal Convention's international-carriage rules would generally not apply. That passenger might nevertheless qualify for a refund after a cancellation or sufficiently significant change if alternative transportation is declined. United's commitments concerning meals or accommodation may also become relevant.


A passenger traveling from Dublin to Newark on a United-operated flight presents a different legal position. The itinerary is international carriage potentially governed by the Montreal Convention. Because the flight departs from an EU airport, EU261 may also apply even though United is an American airline.


For a United-operated flight traveling from Newark to Dublin, the Montreal Convention may govern delay-related damage. EU261, however, generally does not apply to a flight arriving in the EU from a non-EU country when the operating carrier is not an EU carrier.


Additional regional protections may apply elsewhere. Flights departing the United Kingdom can fall under the separate UK passenger-rights regime, while flights involving Canada may engage the Canadian Air Passenger Protection Regulations. Their application depends on the itinerary and the conditions established by the relevant national rules.


None of these examples proves that the corresponding route was disrupted on November 16. The available incident reporting does not identify every affected international service, and compensation cannot be determined from route eligibility alone.


3. Montreal Convention: Liability for International Delays


The Montreal Convention of 1999 establishes a treaty-based system governing several forms of liability arising from international air carriage. Its full title is the Convention for the Unification of Certain Rules for International Carriage by Air, adopted on May 28, 1999, and in force since November 4, 2003.


Article 19 addresses damage caused by delay in the carriage of passengers, baggage, or cargo. The Convention does not prescribe a fixed sum payable whenever an international flight is late. It requires consideration of the damage suffered, its causal relationship with the delay, the applicable liability limits, and the carrier's defenses.


The Convention provides a common legal framework for international claims, but it does not resolve every question concerning the recovery of particular losses. Courts must apply the treaty while addressing relevant questions of proof, causation, procedural law, and judicial interpretation.


3.1 International Carriage and Connecting Flights


Under Article 1, the Montreal Convention generally applies when the agreed places of departure and destination are situated in two states parties. It also covers certain journeys beginning and ending in one state party where an agreed stopping place is situated in another state.


A United flight between Newark and Dublin ordinarily constitutes international carriage within the Convention's scope. The passenger's nationality is not decisive. What matters is the carriage agreed under the relevant contract and the treaty's territorial requirements.


Connecting flights require closer examination. Article 1(3) addresses successive carriage that the parties regard as a single undivided operation. A domestic segment can consequently form part of international carriage when it belongs to an agreed international itinerary.


For example, a passenger booked from Houston to Frankfurt through Chicago may have a Montreal Convention claim arising from a delay on the domestic portion of that journey. The position is different where the traveler independently purchases unrelated domestic and international tickets.


The distinction affects the treatment of missed connections. A delay on the first leg may cause damage extending beyond the immediate flight, but the passenger must still demonstrate the relevant contractual arrangement, causation, and recoverability of the claimed loss.


Codeshare arrangements create another potential complication. The airline selling the ticket may differ from the airline operating the aircraft. Articles 39–46 contain rules concerning contracting and actual carriers, while Article 36 addresses certain responsibilities in successive carriage.


The correct defendant and the scope of each carrier's responsibility cannot always be determined simply by identifying the airline whose name appears most prominently on the booking confirmation.


3.2 Article 19 and the Requirement to Prove Damage


Article 19 makes a carrier liable for damage occasioned by delay in international carriage. It also provides a defense where the carrier proves that it and its servants and agents took all measures that could reasonably be required to avoid the damage, or that taking such measures was impossible.


This defense places significant weight on the circumstances of the disruption. Suspending departures when essential aircraft performance information is unavailable may be necessary for safety. That operational decision, however, does not independently establish that every reasonable measure had been taken before and during the failure.


A passenger may argue that an airline should maintain appropriate redundancy, recovery procedures, and contingency arrangements for essential operational systems. The airline may respond that the failure could not reasonably have been prevented or that additional measures would not have avoided the resulting damage.


Both positions require evidence. The public reporting concerning November 16 does not establish United's technical safeguards, the precise cause of the interruption, or the effectiveness of alternative procedures available to flight crews.


The passenger must also establish legally recoverable damage. Potential examples include reasonable accommodation expenses, replacement transportation costs, necessary meals, and certain losses arising from missed connections or forfeited reservations. An expense is not automatically recoverable merely because it occurred on the date of the disruption.


Causation is particularly important. A traveler seeking reimbursement for an additional hotel night would need to establish that the relevant delay caused the expense and that the amount claimed is legally recoverable. Documentation showing reasonable efforts to reduce the loss may strengthen that position.


The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit addressed a related question in Campbell v. Air Jamaica Ltd. (2014). The court allowed an Article 19 claim concerning an alleged $150 flight-change fee to proceed because the plaintiff had adequately pleaded an economic loss connected with the delay. The judgment did not award damages or establish that every delay-related expense must be reimbursed.


Claims for distress, inconvenience, or other non-economic harm raise additional questions. Judicial approaches have not been uniform in every context, and the Convention should not be described as creating a general entitlement to compensation for frustration or lost time.


3.3 Liability Limits and the Reasonable-Measures Defense


Article 22(1) establishes a monetary ceiling for liability arising from delay in the carriage of passengers. Following the revision announced by the International Civil Aviation Organization, the applicable limit increased to 6,303 Special Drawing Rights per passenger on December 28, 2024.


Special Drawing Rights are an international reserve asset administered by the International Monetary Fund. Their value in dollars or euros varies with exchange rates. The 6,303 SDR figure is consequently a treaty-denominated ceiling rather than a permanently fixed amount in either currency.


The ceiling must not be confused with an automatic award. A passenger who establishes recoverable losses substantially below 6,303 SDR does not become entitled to the full amount merely because the treaty permits liability up to that level.


Article 20 may reduce or exclude liability where the claimant's negligence or other wrongful act or omission caused or contributed to the damage. The Convention also contains provisions concerning liability limits in cases involving specified intentional or reckless conduct, but those exceptions require satisfaction of demanding legal conditions.


Article 29 governs damages actions within the Convention's scope and excludes punitive, exemplary, and other non-compensatory damages. These rules reinforce the distinction between compensation for legally recognized harm and a penalty imposed simply because an airline's operations were disrupted.


Passenger-delay liability should also be distinguished from the separate rules concerning baggage. The revised Article 22(2) limit for baggage-related claims is 1,519 SDR per passenger. The circumstances in which that limit applies are addressed separately in the Montreal Convention rules on lost luggage compensation.


For the November 16 outage, the principal unresolved issue is not the existence of the Convention's liability ceiling. It is whether particular passengers sustained recoverable damage and whether United could establish a defense under Article 19.


4. EU261: Compensation for Delayed United Flights


Regulation (EC) No 261/2004 establishes standardized rights concerning denied boarding, cancellations, and long delays on qualifying flights. It applies according to the regulation's territorial and operational criteria, not the nationality or residence of the passenger.


For qualifying long arrival delays, EU261 can provide fixed compensation even where the passenger cannot demonstrate financial loss equivalent to the statutory payment. The rules also establish separate rights to care, reimbursement, and rerouting in specified circumstances.


An important temporal distinction applies to the November 2026 incident. The European Union adopted Regulation (EU) 2026/2202 in September 2026, but its amendments generally apply only from October 23, 2027. The existing framework and relevant judicial interpretation govern the November 16 outage. The 2026 reform of EU flight delay compensation does not retrospectively replace those rules.


4.1 Which United Flights Are Covered by EU261?


Article 3(1)(a) generally covers passengers departing from an airport within the European Union, regardless of whether the flight is operated by an EU airline. A United-operated flight departing Dublin for Newark can consequently fall within EU261.


The position changes for flights arriving in the EU from a non-EU country. Article 3(1)(b) generally requires the relevant service to be operated by a Community carrier, subject to the provision's other conditions. A United-operated Newark–Dublin flight does not become covered merely because its destination is in Ireland.


The operating airline is legally significant. A flight marketed under an EU airline's code may still be operated by United, while another service sold through United may be operated by a different carrier. The identity of the operating carrier must be established rather than inferred from the booking website or flight number alone.


Connecting itineraries can make the territorial analysis more demanding. The structure of the booking, the place of initial departure, the final destination, and the operating carrier or carriers may affect whether the regulation applies and which entity is responsible.


Passenger nationality does not alter these territorial rules. An American passenger departing Paris may receive EU261 protection, while an EU citizen traveling on a standalone United-operated flight from Chicago to Dublin generally cannot rely on EU261 solely because of citizenship.


The United Kingdom maintains a separate passenger-rights regime following its withdrawal from the EU. Flights departing London must be considered under the applicable UK rules rather than automatically treated as departures from an EU member state.


4.2 Three-Hour Arrival Delays and Fixed Compensation


Under EU261 as interpreted by the Court of Justice of the European Union, passengers reaching their final destination at least three hours late may qualify for fixed compensation, subject to the applicable conditions and defenses.


The principal amounts under Article 7 are €250 for journeys of 1,500 kilometers or less; €400 for intra-EU journeys exceeding 1,500 kilometers and other journeys between 1,500 and 3,500 kilometers; and €600 for journeys outside those categories, including qualifying long-haul routes.


For certain long-haul delays of at least three but less than four hours, the compensation may be reduced by 50%, producing a €300 payment instead of €600. A qualifying arrival delay of four hours or more on such a journey generally engages the full €600 amount.


The Court established the long-delay compensation principle in Sturgeon and Others (2009) and subsequently confirmed its compatibility with the broader legal framework in Nelson and Others (2012). The entitlement concerns the loss of time resulting from qualifying disruption, assessed under the regulation rather than through an individualized calculation of financial damages.


Arrival at the final destination is especially important for connecting journeys. In Air France v. Folkerts (2013), the Court recognized that a passenger's entitlement may depend on the delay at the final destination even where the initial departure delay was shorter than the thresholds ordinarily associated with departure assistance.


The legally relevant arrival time is also more precise than an aircraft's landing time. In Germanwings v. Henning (2014), the Court linked arrival to the opening of at least one aircraft door when passengers are permitted to leave.


A United flight departing Dublin 90 minutes late would not automatically generate €600 in compensation. If the passenger ultimately arrived in Newark more than four hours late on a qualifying journey, the legal assessment could be different. The cause of the delay and any applicable extraordinary-circumstances defense would still need consideration.


The November 16 reporting does not establish that a particular EU-departing United flight reached its final destination three or more hours late because of the outage. The compensation amounts are legally available possibilities, not confirmed payments arising from this incident.


4.3 Assistance, Rebooking, and Refund Rights


EU261 separates fixed compensation from the airline's obligation to assist passengers during significant departure delays. Articles 6 and 9 establish care requirements based on the expected delay and the flight's distance category.


For flights of 1,500 kilometers or less, the relevant departure-delay threshold is generally two hours. The threshold is three hours for intra-EU flights over 1,500 kilometers and other flights between 1,500 and 3,500 kilometers. Other flights, including many long-haul services, generally reach the care threshold after four hours.


Care can include meals and refreshments appropriate to the waiting time and access to communications. When an overnight stay becomes necessary, accommodation and transport between the airport and the place of accommodation may also be required.


These duties must be considered independently from fixed compensation. A passenger may qualify for food or accommodation without reaching the three-hour final-arrival threshold. Equally, the airline's provision of meals does not extinguish a separate compensation entitlement.


A departure delay of at least five hours can engage the reimbursement option under Articles 6 and 8, subject to the regulation's conditions. If a passenger declines to continue a journey that no longer serves its purpose, the relevant reimbursement and, where applicable, return-flight provisions may become important.


Cancellation creates a different set of obligations. Articles 5 and 8 address reimbursement and rerouting choices, while Article 9 governs care. The passenger's available options depend on the nature of the disruption and the circumstances of the proposed alternative transportation.


An airline cannot generally avoid care obligations merely by invoking extraordinary circumstances that may excuse fixed compensation. The Court's approach to those obligations reflects the regulatory distinction between assistance during disruption and monetary compensation for qualifying delays.


4.4 Internal IT Failures and Extraordinary Circumstances


Article 5(3) permits an operating carrier to avoid fixed compensation when it establishes that extraordinary circumstances caused the relevant disruption and could not have been avoided even if all reasonable measures had been taken.


The Court of Justice has developed a demanding approach to this defense. The assessment considers whether the event is inherent in the normal exercise of the airline's activity and whether it lies beyond the airline's actual control.


In Wallentin-Hermann v. Alitalia (2008), the Court addressed the distinction between ordinary technical problems and extraordinary circumstances. In van der Lans v. KLM (2015), it confirmed that the unexpected nature of an aircraft technical problem does not, by itself, make the event extraordinary.


These judgments concerned aircraft technical defects rather than the particular operational software disruption experienced by United in November 2026. Their reasoning is relevant by analogy, but they should not be presented as judgments determining United's liability.


An internal system failure affecting flight planning, aircraft loading, or crew applications may be closely connected with the ordinary operation of an airline. Its internal character could weigh against an extraordinary-circumstances defense. A different conclusion might be possible if the underlying cause were genuinely external and satisfied the applicable legal test.


The classification requires attention to the cause, not merely the operational consequences. A safety-critical interruption may justify delaying takeoff while leaving unresolved whether the event itself was extraordinary. Passenger safety obligations and compensation liability answer distinct questions.


The Court's October 2026 judgment in D (Air Traffic Management Decision) further illustrates the need to identify the event underlying an operational restriction. An air traffic management decision is not automatically extraordinary simply because it originates outside the airline. The circumstances prompting the decision and their relationship to the resulting delay must be assessed.


The same concern with causation appears in disputes involving airport strikes and EU261 compensation. The source of a disruption, the carrier's degree of control, and the reasonable measures available can be more significant than a broad description of the event as a strike or technical failure.


United could seek to show that the November outage was unavoidable despite appropriate safeguards and contingency measures. A passenger could challenge that defense if the failure arose from ordinary operational risks or if reasonable alternatives could have reduced the delay.


Neither argument can be conclusively resolved from the currently established facts. The precise technical cause and the measures United took to prevent or mitigate the disruption remain central to any incident-specific legal determination.


5. U.S. Refund Rights and United's Service Commitments


U.S. federal aviation consumer-protection law does not establish a universal fixed cash payment whenever an ordinary domestic flight is delayed. This differs from the standardized compensation regime applicable to certain European flights.


Passengers nevertheless have important rights under U.S. law. The Department of Transportation regulates refunds in specified circumstances, while airline customer-service commitments may provide meals, accommodation, transportation, or rebooking when a disruption is within the carrier's control.


The FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024 and the Department of Transportation's refund regulations strengthened and clarified several consumer protections. The resulting rules must be distinguished from voluntary assistance arrangements and from damages potentially available under the Montreal Convention.


5.1 When U.S. Law Requires a Refund


A passenger generally becomes entitled to a refund when an airline cancels a flight or makes a qualifying significant change and the passenger does not accept the alternative transportation or other substitute offered in place of a refund.


The Department of Transportation's significant-change criteria include scheduled arrival at the destination at least three hours later for a domestic itinerary or at least six hours later for an international itinerary. Certain changes to airports, connections, or other specified aspects of transportation can also qualify.


A cancellation can trigger refund rights without requiring the passenger to establish that the replacement journey would have arrived three or six hours late. The legal trigger is the cancellation and the passenger's decision concerning the offered alternative.


A refund is not a payment for inconvenience. It returns money paid for transportation that the passenger declines following a qualifying disruption. Someone who chooses to complete the journey on the original or an accepted replacement flight ordinarily cannot demand the full fare back solely because the arrival was late.


Qualifying refunds generally must be made to the original form of payment. The applicable deadlines are seven business days for credit-card purchases and 20 calendar days for other forms of payment, measured under the governing refund rules.


Where a ticket was purchased through a travel agency or online intermediary, identifying the merchant of record matters. Depending on the transaction, responsibility for issuing the airfare refund may rest with the airline or the ticket agent.


For the November 16 outage, a delayed departure alone does not establish that every passenger satisfied the refund criteria. The relevant questions include whether the flight was canceled or significantly changed, whether alternative travel was offered, and whether the passenger accepted it.


5.2 Meals, Accommodation, and Rebooking Commitments


The Department of Transportation's Airline Cancellation and Delay Dashboard records service commitments made by U.S. carriers for disruptions within their control. The dashboard also explains that airlines are expected to honor the promises contained in their customer-service plans.


For controllable significant delays, United publishes commitments concerning rebooking on its own services and, where applicable, on partner or agreed airlines without additional cost. These arrangements can help passengers reach their destinations when the originally scheduled service becomes impractical.


United also commits to providing meals or meal vouchers when a controllable delay results in a wait of at least three hours. For qualifying overnight disruptions, its commitments include hotel accommodation and transportation between the airport and the accommodation.


The dashboard does not identify a general United commitment to provide cash compensation merely because a passenger waits three hours or longer. An airline may choose to offer additional benefits in individual circumstances, but discretionary payments should not be presented as universal legal entitlements.


The distinction between controllable and uncontrollable disruptions matters. Maintenance and crew problems are examples commonly associated with airline control. A failure involving an airline's own operational systems may support a controllable-delay assessment, but the precise classification of the November 16 disruption must be established from the circumstances of the affected flight.


The FAA's description of the incident as an airline-side problem is relevant without being conclusive. It does not establish how long each passenger waited, whether an overnight stay became necessary, or whether United failed to provide assistance promised under its policies.


Separate federal protections apply to extended tarmac delays. Under 14 CFR § 259.4, covered carriers generally must provide food and potable water within two hours in qualifying circumstances and observe requirements concerning lavatories, medical assistance, and opportunities to deplane.


The general deplaning limits are three hours for domestic flights and four hours for international flights, subject to specified safety, security, and air traffic control exceptions. These rules concern passengers on aircraft during qualifying tarmac delays, not everyone waiting inside an airport terminal.


The available reporting does not establish a specific violation of the tarmac-delay rules during the United outage. A passenger alleging such a violation would need evidence concerning the aircraft's time on the ground and the conditions experienced on board.


6. How Passengers Can Establish and Pursue a Claim


An effective claim begins with identifying the legal basis for the requested remedy. Describing every demand as flight delay compensation can obscure the difference between a statutory refund, a standardized EU261 payment, a contractual service commitment, and damages under the Montreal Convention.


The relevant evidence also changes with the claim. EU261 compensation generally turns on the qualifying itinerary, final-arrival delay, and the airline's ability to establish a valid defense. Montreal damages require evidence of legally recoverable harm. U.S. refund claims depend heavily on the change to the transportation arrangement and the passenger's response.


A traveler may have more than one potentially applicable remedy. The existence of overlapping regimes, however, does not authorize recovery of the same loss twice or remove the procedural requirements governing each claim.


6.1 Evidence of Delay, Cancellation, and Financial Loss


Passengers should preserve their booking confirmations, ticket numbers, boarding passes, flight numbers, and correspondence with United. Records identifying each operating carrier are especially important when the itinerary includes connections or codeshare services.


Scheduled and actual departure and arrival times should be recorded separately. For EU261 purposes, the final arrival time may determine whether the compensation threshold is met. A departure delay of limited duration may have substantially different consequences when it causes a missed connection.


Communications announcing a cancellation, rebooking, or significant change should also be retained. These records can establish what alternatives were offered, when the passenger received notice, and whether the traveler accepted or rejected the revised arrangements.


For Montreal Convention claims, financial records are particularly significant. Itemized receipts, replacement-ticket invoices, hotel bills, ground-transport expenses, and evidence of forfeited reservations can help demonstrate the amount and nature of a claimed loss.


The existence of a receipt does not settle the legal question. The passenger may need to establish that the expenditure resulted from the delay, was reasonable in the circumstances, and falls within a recoverable category.


Evidence of mitigation can also matter. Communications showing attempts to obtain assistance, secure reasonable alternative transportation, or avoid unnecessary expenses may help explain why a particular cost was incurred.


A passenger need not personally identify the failed server or software application to document the consequences of a delayed flight. Technical evidence may nevertheless become important if liability turns on United's reasonable-measures defense or on whether an extraordinary event caused the disruption.


6.2 Claims Procedures, Time Limits, and Concurrent Remedies


Passengers ordinarily begin by submitting a claim directly to United, identifying the flight, the disruption, and the specific remedy requested. A request for EU261 compensation should distinguish the statutory fixed payment from reimbursement of documented expenses or the return of an unused fare.


Montreal Convention damages actions are subject to Article 33, which identifies courts in which qualifying claims may be brought. The available forums include specified locations connected with the carrier's domicile, principal place of business, contract formation, or the destination.


The additional jurisdictional basis under Article 33(2), concerning a passenger's principal and permanent residence in specified circumstances, applies to claims arising from death or bodily injury. It should not be treated as a general fifth forum for ordinary passenger-delay damages.


Article 35 establishes a two-year period for bringing a Convention damages action, calculated according to the treaty's prescribed starting events and the applicable method of calculation. The right to damages is extinguished if an action is not brought within the required period.


The treaty's written-complaint rules concerning delayed baggage should not be confused with the deadline for passenger-delay damages. Article 31 contains a 21-day complaint period relevant to delayed baggage, not a general requirement that every Article 19 passenger-delay claim be submitted within 21 days.


EU261 claims require separate procedural analysis. In Cuadrench Moré v. KLM (2012), the Court of Justice held that the time limit for bringing a claim under EU261 is determined by the applicable national rules rather than automatically by the Montreal Convention's two-year period.


The 2026 EU261 reform introduces new procedural requirements, including a compensation-request deadline, but those amendments generally do not apply until October 23, 2027. They should not be imposed retrospectively on passengers affected in November 2026.


Passengers unable to resolve a U.S. refund dispute may submit a complaint to the Department of Transportation's Aviation Consumer Protection Division. Within the European system, complaints may also engage the competent national enforcement body, although its powers to resolve individual payment disputes depend on the relevant legal arrangements.


Overlapping claims require particular care. Article 12 of EU261 addresses the possibility of further compensation and permits relevant deductions. The Court's decision in Nelson and Others recognized the compatibility of standardized EU261 compensation with the Montreal framework, but compatibility does not mean unrestricted duplication of damages.


A traveler may consequently have grounds to seek an EU261 fixed payment and pursue distinct proven financial losses under the Montreal Convention. Whether both remedies are available, and how any amounts should be treated, depends on the applicable conditions and the losses concerned.


Procedural questions are not secondary technicalities. Selecting the correct legal basis, defendant, and court can determine whether an otherwise supportable claim is enforceable. The distinction between substantive rights and adjudicatory jurisdiction in international law is especially relevant when international carriage involves several states.


Conclusion


The United Airlines outage of November 16, 2026, established that an internal technology disruption can interrupt flight operations even when aircraft remain mechanically capable of flying. It did not establish that every delayed passenger acquired a right to cash compensation.


The Montreal Convention may provide damages for legally recoverable losses caused by delay in international carriage, subject to the carrier's defenses and the applicable liability limit of 6,303 SDR per passenger. EU261 offers a different remedy: fixed compensation for qualifying disruptions, together with separate duties concerning care, reimbursement, and rerouting.


U.S. federal law generally does not award standardized cash compensation for ordinary delays, but qualifying cancellations and significant itinerary changes can trigger refund rights. United's published commitments may provide additional assistance where a disruption falls within the carrier's control.


The distinction between operational safety and legal liability remains decisive. Delaying an aircraft because essential performance information is unavailable may be necessary. That decision does not, by itself, establish either liability or a complete defense under the relevant legal regime.


For passengers affected by the outage, the strongest claims will depend on identifiable flights, documented arrival times, the terms of the journey, the losses actually sustained, and the measures available to the airline. Until those facts are established for individual cases, neither a universal compensation entitlement nor a general exemption from liability can be justified.


References


Air Passenger Protection Regulations (2019) SOR/2019-150, Canada, as amended [online]. Available at: https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/regulations/SOR-2019-150/ (Accessed: 17 November 2026).


Code of Federal Regulations (2026) Title 14, § 259.4, ‘Contingency Plan for Lengthy Tarmac Delays’ [online]. Available at: https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-14/chapter-II/subchapter-A/part-259/section-259.4 (Accessed: 17 November 2026).


Convention for the Unification of Certain Rules for International Carriage by Air (Montreal Convention) (1999) Adopted at Montreal on 28 May 1999; entered into force on 4 November 2003 [online]. Available at: https://www.icao.int/sites/default/files/inline-files/mtl99_en.pdf (Accessed: 17 November 2026).


Court of Justice of the European Union (2008) Wallentin-Hermann v Alitalia – Linee Aeree Italiane SpA, Case C-549/07, judgment, 22 December, ECLI:EU:C:2008:771 [online]. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:62007CJ0549 (Accessed: 17 November 2026).


Court of Justice of the European Union (2009) Sturgeon and Others v Condor Flugdienst GmbH; Böck and Lepuschitz v Air France SA, Joined Cases C-402/07 and C-432/07, judgment, 19 November, ECLI:EU:C:2009:716 [online]. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:62007CJ0402 (Accessed: 17 November 2026).


Court of Justice of the European Union (2012a) Cuadrench Moré v Koninklijke Luchtvaart Maatschappij NV, Case C-139/11, judgment, 22 November, ECLI:EU:C:2012:741 [online]. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:62011CJ0139 (Accessed: 17 November 2026).


Court of Justice of the European Union (2012b) Nelson and Others v Deutsche Lufthansa AG; TUI Travel plc and Others v Civil Aviation Authority, Joined Cases C-581/10 and C-629/10, judgment, 23 October, ECLI:EU:C:2012:657 [online]. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:62010CJ0581 (Accessed: 17 November 2026).


Court of Justice of the European Union (2013) Air France v Folkerts, Case C-11/11, judgment, 26 February, ECLI:EU:C:2013:106 [online]. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:62011CJ0011 (Accessed: 17 November 2026).


Court of Justice of the European Union (2014) Germanwings GmbH v Henning, Case C-452/13, judgment, 4 September, ECLI:EU:C:2014:2141 [online]. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:62013CJ0452 (Accessed: 17 November 2026).


Court of Justice of the European Union (2015) van der Lans v Koninklijke Luchtvaart Maatschappij NV, Case C-257/14, judgment, 17 September, ECLI:EU:C:2015:618 [online]. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:62014CJ0257 (Accessed: 17 November 2026).


Court of Justice of the European Union (2026) D (Air traffic management decision), Case C-108/26 RX, judgment, 8 October [online]. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELEX:62026CJ0108 (Accessed: 17 November 2026).


FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024 (2024) Public Law 118-63, 16 May, 138 Stat. 1025 [online]. Available at: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/PLAW-118publ63/html/PLAW-118publ63.htm (Accessed: 17 November 2026).


Funk, J. (2026) ‘1.5-hour-long system outage forces United Airlines to delay departing flights’, Associated Press, 16 November [online]. Available at: https://apnews.com/article/united-airlines-outage-5a5e5f75bb07f11ffb8750901f0076ff (Accessed: 17 November 2026).


Gainor, D., Muntean, P. and Skores, A. (2026) ‘United Airlines says it resolved system outage that delayed flights’, CNN, 16 November [online]. Available at: https://krdo.com/news/2026/11/16/united-airlines-experiencing-a-widespread-system-outage-airline-says/ (Accessed: 17 November 2026).


International Civil Aviation Organization (2024) 2024 Revised Limits of Liability Under the Montreal Convention of 1999 [online]. Available at: https://www.icao.int/secretariat/legal/LEB%20Treaty%20Collection%20Documents/2024_Revised_Limits_of_Liability_Under_the_Montreal_Convention_of_1999_en.pdf (Accessed: 17 November 2026).


International Monetary Fund (2023) ‘What is the SDR?’ [online]. Available at: https://www.imf.org/en/about/factsheets/sheets/2023/special-drawing-rights-sdr (Accessed: 17 November 2026).


Regulation (EC) No 261/2004 (2004) Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council of 11 February 2004 establishing common rules on compensation and assistance to passengers in the event of denied boarding and of cancellation or long delay of flights, and repealing Regulation (EEC) No 295/91. Official Journal of the European Union, L46, 17 February, pp. 1–8 [online]. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng (Accessed: 17 November 2026).


Regulation (EU) 2026/2202 (2026) Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council of 16 September 2026 amending Regulation (EC) No 261/2004 and Council Regulation (EC) No 2027/97 on air carrier liability in respect of the carriage of passengers and their baggage by air. Official Journal of the European Union, L, 2026/2202, 2 October [online]. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:32026R2202 (Accessed: 17 November 2026).


Singh, R.K. and Shepardson, D. (2026) ‘United Airlines says technology outage that delayed departures has been resolved’, Reuters, 16 November [online]. Available at: https://www.reuters.com/world/us/united-airlines-says-technology-issue-affecting-departing-flights-2026-11-16/ (Accessed: 17 November 2026).


UK Civil Aviation Authority (n.d.) ‘Delays’ [online]. Available at: https://www.caa.co.uk/air-passengers/travel-problems-and-rights/flight-delays-and-cancellations/delays/ (Accessed: 17 November 2026).


United States Code (2024) Title 49, § 42305, ‘Refunds for cancelled or significantly delayed or changed flights’ [online]. Available at: https://uscode.house.gov/us/usc/t49/s42305/ (Accessed: 17 November 2026).


United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit (2014) Campbell v Air Jamaica Ltd., 760 F.3d 1165, judgment, 8 July [online]. Available at: https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/ca11/12-14860/12-14860-2014-07-08.html (Accessed: 17 November 2026).


United States Department of Transportation (2024) ‘Refunds and Other Consumer Protections’, final rule, Federal Register, 89(82), pp. 32760–32839, 26 April [online]. Available at: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2024-04-26/html/2024-07177.htm (Accessed: 17 November 2026).


United States Department of Transportation (n.d.-a) ‘Airline Cancellation and Delay Dashboard’ [online]. Available at: https://www.transportation.gov/airconsumer/airline-cancellation-delay-dashboard (Accessed: 17 November 2026).


United States Department of Transportation (n.d.-b) ‘Refunds’ [online]. Available at: https://www.transportation.gov/individuals/aviation-consumer-protection/refunds (Accessed: 17 November 2026).

bottom of page