top of page

Lost Luggage Compensation: What Airlines Owe Under the Montreal Convention

7 days ago
32 min read

Introduction


Under the Montreal Convention of 1999, the ordinary limit for lost luggage compensation is 1,519 Special Drawing Rights (SDRs) per passenger. This limit has applied since December 28, 2024, replacing the previous ceiling of 1,288 SDRs. The revised amount was equivalent to approximately US$2,000 when the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) announced the change. It covers liability for baggage that is lost, destroyed, damaged, or delayed during qualifying international air transportation. However, 1,519 SDRs is a maximum liability limit, not a payment that every passenger automatically receives (ICAO, 2024).


Passengers whose checked baggage fails to arrive should report the incident to the airline promptly, obtain a baggage incident reference, preserve their baggage identification tags, and retain evidence of their belongings and necessary replacement purchases. The Convention establishes specific complaint periods: seven days after receipt for damaged checked baggage and 21 days after baggage becomes available for claims involving delay. A separate 21-day provision permits passengers to enforce contractual rights when baggage remains undelivered, while Article 35 establishes a two-year period for commencing legal proceedings.


These rights arise from the Convention for the Unification of Certain Rules for International Carriage by Air, adopted in Montreal on May 28, 1999, and in force since November 4, 2003. The treaty modernized the earlier Warsaw Convention system and introduced common rules governing airline liability for passengers, baggage, cargo, and delay. Its protection depends on the applicable journey and the conditions of liability, while enforcement generally takes place through national courts and domestic legal procedures.


1. The 1,519 SDR Limit on Lost Luggage Compensation


Article 22(2) of the Montreal Convention establishes the ordinary monetary ceiling for airline liability concerning baggage. Since December 28, 2024, that ceiling has been 1,519 SDRs per passenger, following an increase from 1,288 SDRs. The revision was adopted through the inflation-adjustment mechanism established by Article 24 rather than through a renegotiation of the Convention's substantive liability provisions (ICAO, 2024).


The limit applies to the destruction, loss, damage, or delay of baggage, subject to the conditions and exceptions prescribed by the Convention. It must not be confused with the separate limit governing damage caused by delay in transporting a passenger. That ceiling increased to 6,303 SDRs in December 2024 under Article 22(1). Delayed baggage remains governed by Article 22(2), even when the inconvenience affects the passenger's activities after arrival.


The amount recoverable depends on the damage established. A passenger whose missing belongings are worth substantially less than 1,519 SDRs does not automatically receive the maximum amount. Conversely, a passenger who proves a greater loss ordinarily remains subject to the ceiling unless an exception applies. The distinction between establishing the airline's responsibility and calculating the compensation payable is central to the Convention's operation.


1.1 Compensation per Passenger, Not per Suitcase


The Montreal Convention establishes its ordinary baggage liability limit per passenger rather than per suitcase. A traveler who checks three bags cannot ordinarily claim three separate maximum payments simply because all three disappear. The total recoverable damage remains subject to the passenger's applicable 1,519 SDR ceiling, regardless of how many pieces of baggage were affected.


The position becomes more complicated when several passengers place their belongings in one suitcase. Article 3(3) requires the carrier to issue a baggage identification tag for each piece of checked baggage, but the name associated with that tag does not necessarily establish ownership of everything inside it. A passenger may have personal belongings in baggage checked under another traveler's name.


The Court of Justice of the European Union addressed this question in Espada Sánchez and Others v Iberia Líneas Aéreas de España SA, Case C-410/11, decided on November 22, 2012. The Court held that Article 22(2), read together with Article 3(3), permits a passenger to claim compensation for belongings contained in baggage checked under another passenger's name, provided the lost baggage actually contained the claimant's property (CJEU, 2012).


The judgment recognizes individual compensation rights in shared-baggage arrangements without dispensing with the requirement to prove the loss. National courts may consider circumstances such as a shared booking, family relationship, and simultaneous check-in when evaluating ownership. These factors can support a claim, but they do not automatically establish the contents of the suitcase or entitle every traveler to the maximum award.


1.2 How Baggage Loss Is Valued


Compensation for lost baggage is assessed by reference to the damage established, including the value of missing belongings and other legally recoverable losses. Relevant property may include the suitcase, clothing, personal effects, and items accepted for transportation. Purchase records may help establish value, but the original retail price is not necessarily the correct measure of damage when property has been used for several years.


The Montreal Convention does not prescribe a universal formula for depreciating personal belongings. The age, condition, purchase price, and reasonable replacement value of an item may be relevant under the applicable law. An airline's internal depreciation schedule should not automatically be equated with the measure of compensation required by the Convention.


In SL v Vueling Airlines SA, Case C-86/19, decided on July 9, 2020, the Court of Justice confirmed that the maximum compensation amount under Article 22(2) does not accrue automatically when checked baggage is lost. National courts determine the appropriate amount according to the evidence and applicable procedural rules. In EU-law proceedings, those rules must respect the principles of equivalence and effectiveness, including the requirement that exercising Convention rights must not be made practically impossible or excessively difficult (CJEU, 2020).


The Convention's concept of damage is not confined to the physical value of missing belongings. In Walz v Clickair SA, Case C-63/09, decided on May 6, 2010, the Court of Justice interpreted Article 22(2) as encompassing both material and non-material damage. The ruling does not establish an automatic payment for distress or inconvenience. Both categories remain subject to the same ordinary ceiling, while the existence and amount of compensable damage must be established under the applicable legal rules (CJEU, 2010).


1.3 What 1,519 SDRs Means in National Currency


The Special Drawing Right is an international reserve asset created by the International Monetary Fund. It also functions as a unit of account in international legal instruments, including the Montreal Convention. Its value is determined through a basket of five currencies: the US dollar, euro, Chinese renminbi, Japanese yen, and British pound.


Because the SDR's currency value fluctuates, the equivalent of 1,519 SDRs in dollars, euros, or pounds changes over time. ICAO described the revised baggage limit as approximately US$2,000 when announcing it in October 2024, but that approximation is not a permanent dollar-denominated limit. A national-currency amount published at an earlier date may no longer represent the current value of the treaty ceiling.


Article 23(1) establishes the conversion rule for judicial proceedings, providing for conversion into national currency according to the relevant SDR value at the date of judgment. Different arrangements may govern the conversion used in a negotiated settlement, subject to applicable law. The SDR figure remains the legally relevant reference point, and the national-currency calculation must be distinguished from the assessment of the passenger's actual damage.


2. Baggage Claim Deadlines and the 21-Day Rule


The Montreal Convention establishes several periods governing baggage claims, but their legal purposes differ. Article 17(3) concerns the enforcement of contractual rights when checked baggage remains undelivered. Article 31 establishes written complaint requirements for damage and delay, while Article 35 prescribes the period for bringing an action for damages. Compliance with one provision does not automatically satisfy the others.


Two separate provisions refer to 21 days. One concerns baggage that has not arrived within 21 days after its expected arrival. The other establishes a deadline for complaining about delayed baggage after it becomes available. Confusing their starting points can lead passengers to misunderstand when rights arise and when a complaint must be submitted.


Article 52 provides that references to days in the Convention mean calendar days rather than working days. The seven- and 21-day complaint periods must consequently be understood according to their stated calendar-day requirements. Passengers should preserve records establishing when baggage was received, when it became available, and when a written complaint was submitted.


2.1 When Missing Baggage Can Be Treated as Lost


Article 17(3) permits a passenger to enforce the rights arising from the contract of carriage when the airline admits that checked baggage has been lost or when it has not arrived within 21 days after the date on which it should have arrived. The provision allows the passenger to pursue contractual rights without waiting indefinitely for the carrier to conclude its baggage investigation.


An admission of loss may establish the relevant entitlement before the 21-day period expires. Where the carrier makes no such admission, continued nondelivery for the prescribed period provides an alternative basis for enforcement. The provision does not require the passenger to prove precisely where the suitcase disappeared or whether the airline has permanently abandoned its search.


The 21-day baggage rule does not prevent passengers from reporting missing luggage immediately after arrival. An incident report, baggage identification record, and documentation of necessary purchases can all be obtained during the first days of nondelivery. Airlines may also use administrative procedures for declaring baggage lost at an earlier stage, but those practices are distinct from the legal conditions established by Article 17(3).


2.2 The Seven-Day Deadline for Damaged Baggage


Article 31(2) requires a complaint concerning damaged checked baggage to be made promptly after discovery and no later than seven days after receipt. The period concerns baggage that has been delivered but is alleged to have sustained damage. It differs from the position of baggage that has never been returned.


Article 31(1) provides that receipt of checked baggage without complaint constitutes prima facie evidence of delivery in good condition and in accordance with the carriage record. This creates an evidentiary presumption rather than an absolute declaration that concealed damage could never be established. Nevertheless, discovering damage and failing to submit the required complaint within the prescribed period can have consequences beyond an evidentiary disadvantage.


Article 31(3) requires the complaint to be made in writing and given or dispatched within the relevant period. Article 31(4) provides that no action shall lie against the carrier when the prescribed complaint has not been made, except in the case of fraud by the carrier. Compliance with the written-form requirement is consequently essential when damage to checked baggage is discovered.


The Court of Justice clarified the meaning of a written complaint in Finnair Oyj v Keskinäinen Vakuutusyhtiö Fennia, Case C-258/16, decided on April 12, 2018. The Court held that an electronically recorded complaint can satisfy Article 31(3). It also recognized that an airline representative may record the passenger's complaint on the passenger's behalf, provided the passenger can check its accuracy and amend, supplement, or replace it before the relevant deadline. Article 31 does not impose additional substantive requirements beyond notifying the carrier of the damage sustained (CJEU, 2018).


2.3 The 21-Day Deadline for Delayed Baggage


The second 21-day period appears in Article 31(2) and concerns damage caused by baggage delay. A written complaint must be made no later than 21 days after the baggage has been placed at the passenger's disposal. The starting point is the availability of the baggage, not the date on which the passenger originally arrived.


A suitcase delivered several days after a passenger reaches the destination may generate a claim for expenses incurred during the delay. Necessary purchases made before delivery can remain relevant even though the belongings are eventually recovered. The passenger must establish the claimed damage and observe the written complaint period calculated from the baggage's availability.


The requirement to complain in writing follows Article 31(3), as interpreted in Finnair. An electronic complaint or a record made by airline personnel may satisfy that requirement under the conditions identified by the Court of Justice. Passengers should nevertheless retain the complaint text and evidence of timely submission, since the legal sufficiency of a particular communication depends on what was recorded and how it was transmitted.


Article 31 does not prescribe an equivalent seven- or 21-day written complaint period for baggage that remains permanently lost. That distinction follows from its express provisions concerning damage and delay. It does not justify postponing notification or evidence collection, particularly when the loss is disputed or the limitation period for legal proceedings is approaching.


2.4 The Two-Year Deadline for Court Proceedings


Article 35 establishes a separate period for bringing an action for damages. The right to damages is extinguished if proceedings are not brought within two years, calculated from the date of arrival at the destination, the date on which the aircraft should have arrived, or the date on which carriage stopped, as applicable.


This rule is distinct from the time allowed for submitting a written complaint to the airline. A passenger may have reported the incident promptly and exchanged extensive correspondence with the carrier but still face the extinction of the right to damages if proceedings are not commenced within the applicable period.


Article 35(2) provides that the method of calculating the period is determined by the law of the court hearing the case. An ongoing baggage investigation or settlement discussion should not be assumed to suspend the treaty period. Where negotiations remain unresolved, the relevant judicial deadline must be assessed independently of the airline's administrative timetable.


3. How to File a Lost Luggage Compensation Claim


A baggage claim begins with establishing what happened to the property entrusted to the airline. The passenger should report nondelivery promptly, retain the baggage identification tag and booking records, and obtain a record of the incident. These documents connect the missing suitcase to the relevant carriage contract and provide an evidentiary basis for subsequent communications.


A compensation demand serves a different purpose from baggage tracing. The initial report informs the carrier that the suitcase has not arrived and enables an investigation. A claim for damages identifies the losses for which payment is requested and supplies a basis for assessing them. Depending on the circumstances, the communications may overlap, but their different functions should remain clear.


The Montreal Convention does not establish one mandatory international baggage claim form. Airlines commonly operate their own reporting systems and request supporting documentation. Such administrative arrangements must be distinguished from the treaty's written complaint requirements, which were interpreted by the Court of Justice in Finnair.


3.1 Reporting Missing Baggage at the Airport


When checked baggage does not arrive, the passenger should contact the airline or its authorized baggage-handling representative as soon as practicable. Airport baggage offices commonly issue a Property Irregularity Report, which records the incident and assigns a reference number. This assists subsequent tracing and establishes a record of the passenger's notification.


The report generally identifies the flight, journey, passenger, baggage tag, and physical characteristics of the missing suitcase. Retaining the original baggage identification details is especially useful where several airlines participate in the journey. The records can help establish that the carrier accepted the baggage and the destination to which it was checked.


A Property Irregularity Report is not expressly required by the Montreal Convention as a universal condition of compensation. Its legal significance depends on the circumstances and the information recorded. In Finnair, the Court of Justice recognized that an airline employee's electronic record of a passenger's complaint may satisfy Article 31 where the passenger can review and correct the written record within the applicable period.


The practical implication is that an airport report should be checked for accuracy rather than treated as conclusive merely because a reference number has been issued. A passenger should retain the report, any confirmation of submission, and subsequent written communications. Where a complaint concerning damage or delay is required, the communication must satisfy Article 31 within the relevant period.


3.2 Submitting the Written Claim and Evidence


A written claim should identify the passenger, flight, baggage, incident, and compensation requested. Where the suitcase remains missing, an itemized account of its contents helps establish the nature and value of the loss. The claim should distinguish the suitcase itself from the belongings it contained and from any additional expenses attributed to the nondelivery.


Receipts may establish the original purchase price of an item, but other evidence can also be relevant. Photographs, bank statements, electronic purchase confirmations, warranty records, and comparable product information may help establish ownership or value. The weight attributed to such evidence depends on the applicable rules and the circumstances of the dispute.


The judgment in SL v Vueling Airlines confirms that compensation must be assessed rather than automatically fixed at the treaty maximum. The Court also recognized the role of national procedural law in determining proof, subject to the EU principles of equivalence and effectiveness. Missing receipts do not necessarily make a claim impossible, but the passenger remains responsible for establishing the damage to the required legal standard.


Valuation requires particular care where the claim includes used clothing, older equipment, or goods purchased long before the journey. An estimate based entirely on the price of new replacements may not accurately reflect the value of the lost property. The claim can explain why a particular valuation is reasonable, taking account of the item's condition, age, and available evidence.


A complete documentary record also helps distinguish a disagreement about valuation from a disagreement about liability. The airline may accept that a suitcase was lost while disputing its contents or the amount claimed. Preserving the original inventory, supporting documents, and written responses allows those questions to be examined separately.


3.3 Claiming Expenses and Baggage-Fee Refunds


Where baggage is delayed, Article 19 may provide compensation for damage caused by the delay. Reasonable purchases of essential clothing, toiletries, and other necessities can be relevant where the passenger lacked access to the missing belongings. The expenditure must be connected to the delay and established through adequate evidence.


The Convention does not prescribe a universal daily allowance for delayed baggage. The amount recoverable depends on the circumstances, including the duration of nondelivery and the necessity and reasonableness of the purchases. An airline's internal reimbursement policy does not necessarily determine the full extent of its treaty liability.


Baggage-fee refunds require a separate analysis. Article 22(2) limits liability for baggage-related damage, but the Convention does not itself establish the detailed refund obligations found in some national consumer-protection systems. A passenger may consequently have a right to reimbursement of a baggage fee under national regulation alongside a distinct claim for compensable loss.


Under US Department of Transportation rules, passengers may qualify for refunds of checked baggage fees when luggage is lost or significantly delayed. For covered international itineraries, the significant-delay threshold is 15 hours where the qualifying nonstop flight segment to or from the United States lasts no more than 12 hours, and 30 hours where such a segment exceeds 12 hours. The relevant period is measured from the flight's arrival under the regulatory rules, rather than simply from the total duration of a journey involving connections (US Department of Transportation, 2024).


A refund for significantly delayed baggage also requires a mishandled-baggage report, and regulatory exceptions may affect eligibility. Once the applicable conditions are satisfied, the rules provide for automatic reimbursement of the baggage fee. These protections must be distinguished from the Montreal Convention's rules governing compensation for the contents of a lost suitcase or reasonable expenses caused by baggage delay.


3.4 When an Airline Rejects or Reduces a Claim


Airlines may reject or reduce baggage claims for different reasons. A carrier may dispute the value of missing belongings, question whether particular property was transported, invoke a treaty defense, or assert that a written complaint was submitted too late. Each explanation requires examination of the legal rule and evidence on which it relies.


Contractual exclusions must be distinguished from lawful limitations on liability. Article 26 invalidates contractual provisions that seek to relieve a carrier of liability or establish a lower limit than the Convention permits. Article 27 allows carriers to establish contractual conditions that do not conflict with the treaty. The existence of a restriction in the airline's conditions of carriage does not, by itself, establish that the restriction is legally effective against a Convention claim.


A refusal may nevertheless be justified where the passenger fails to establish compensable damage or the carrier proves an applicable defense. The distinction between a lawful objection and an impermissible contractual restriction is essential. An airline's obligation to compensate under Article 17 or Article 19 depends on the conditions established by those provisions.


The available routes for challenging a refusal vary by jurisdiction. In Canada, the Canadian Transportation Agency administers a passenger complaint system. In Ireland, the Irish Aviation Authority states that no designated national enforcement body exists for the Montreal Convention and directs baggage complainants initially to their airlines. Regulatory complaint procedures and civil proceedings may consequently perform different functions, and an administrative complaint should not automatically be treated as a substitute for a court action.


4. What Airlines Must Compensate Under the Convention


The Montreal Convention distinguishes destruction, loss, and physical damage to baggage from damage caused by delay. Article 17(2) governs the former categories, while Article 19 addresses delay-related damage. Although both fall within the ordinary baggage ceiling established by Article 22(2), the conditions giving rise to carrier liability are different.


The distinction affects the evidence required from the passenger. In cases of checked baggage lost while in the carrier's charge, Article 17(2) does not ordinarily require proof of a particular negligent act. Claims arising from delay require proof of damage caused by the delay and remain subject to Article 19's specific defense.


Checked and unchecked baggage also receive different treatment. The airline exercises substantial control over checked luggage after accepting it for transportation, whereas personal items carried in the cabin ordinarily remain with the passenger. Article 17(2) reflects this difference by establishing a separate fault requirement for unchecked baggage.


4.1 Lost Checked Baggage and Strict Liability


Article 17(2) makes the airline liable for damage sustained through the destruction, loss, or damage of checked baggage when the event causing the damage occurred aboard the aircraft or during a period in which the baggage was in the carrier's charge. The passenger ordinarily does not need to establish precisely which employee made an error or identify the specific handling failure responsible for the incident.


This form of strict liability is especially relevant to international journeys involving multiple airports and baggage-transfer operations. A suitcase may move through sorting facilities, loading systems, temporary storage, and aircraft holds before delivery. The relevant inquiry concerns whether the loss-producing event occurred within the period defined by Article 17(2).


The provision contains an exception for damage resulting from the inherent defect, quality, or vice of the baggage. Its application depends on the cause of the damage, not simply on an airline's assertion that a suitcase was insufficiently durable. Damage attributable to the baggage's own condition must be distinguished from damage caused by events occurring during carriage.


Article 20 also permits complete or partial exoneration where the carrier proves that the claimant's negligence or other wrongful conduct caused or contributed to the damage. The extent of any reduction depends on the causal contribution established. The provision does not authorize a general reduction merely because the passenger failed to anticipate every possible difficulty associated with baggage transportation.


4.2 Delayed Baggage and Necessary Purchases


Article 19 establishes liability for damage occasioned by delay in the carriage of passengers, baggage, or cargo. For delayed luggage, compensable damage may include reasonable expenditure incurred because essential belongings were unavailable at the destination. The eventual return of the suitcase does not necessarily eliminate a claim for losses already sustained during the period of nondelivery.


The reasonableness of a purchase depends on the passenger's circumstances. A traveler arriving without clothing for a scheduled business engagement may have different immediate needs from someone returning home with access to alternative belongings. The legal question concerns whether the expense resulted from the delay and whether its amount is justified.


Receipts can establish that money was spent, but they do not independently prove that every purchase was necessary or compensable. A claim may require consideration of the trip's purpose, the time taken to return the luggage, and the availability of existing possessions. Equally, a carrier should not assume that a fixed internal daily allowance necessarily represents the maximum damage recoverable under Article 19.


Article 19 provides a defense where the carrier proves that it and its servants and agents took all measures reasonably required to avoid the damage or that taking such measures was impossible. This differs from the liability structure for lost checked baggage under Article 17(2). The defense requires an assessment of preventive measures rather than a general statement that baggage delays are unavoidable.


The Convention's individualized approach also differs from standardized passenger remedies under European law. That distinction can arise during the same disruption, as illustrated by the treatment of EU passenger rights and Montreal Convention delay damages in the analysis of the Brussels Airport strike and flight compensation. The ordinary baggage-delay ceiling remains 1,519 SDRs under Article 22(2), rather than the separate 6,303 SDR ceiling governing delay in transporting passengers.


4.3 Damaged Suitcases, Contents, and Cabin Baggage


Damage to checked luggage may affect the suitcase itself or belongings inside it. Broken components, damaged fabric, missing contents, and other physical deterioration may give rise to compensation where the legal conditions of Article 17(2) are satisfied. The amount recoverable depends on the damage established and an appropriate valuation under the applicable rules.


Repair costs may provide a reasonable measure where the suitcase can be restored. Replacement value may be relevant where repair is impractical, although depreciation and the item's previous condition can affect the assessment. The Montreal Convention does not prescribe a separate compensation tariff for damaged wheels, handles, or other suitcase components.


Ordinary wear must be distinguished from damage for which the carrier is legally responsible. The Convention does not establish a general exclusion based solely on an airline's description of damage as cosmetic. The relevant questions concern the cause of the deterioration, whether the damage falls within Article 17(2), and whether an applicable defense has been established.


Unchecked baggage is governed by a different liability rule. Article 17(2) provides that the carrier is liable for damage to unchecked baggage, including personal items, where the damage resulted from its fault or that of its servants or agents. The passenger must consequently establish the circumstances necessary to support fault-based liability rather than relying solely on the checked-baggage rule.


The distinction can become significant when a passenger's cabin bag is transferred to the aircraft hold. Its legal treatment depends on the circumstances in which the carrier accepted custody and the applicable baggage arrangements. Airline restrictions concerning fragile objects, electronics, or valuables must also be assessed against Articles 26 and 27; contractual terms cannot automatically displace the mandatory liability protections established by the Convention.


5. When Compensation Can Exceed the Ordinary Limit


The 1,519 SDR ceiling may be insufficient where checked baggage contains valuable professional equipment, expensive personal possessions, or other property whose value substantially exceeds the ordinary limit. The Montreal Convention recognizes that possibility by permitting a special declaration of interest in delivery and allowing carriers to accept greater liability.


The Convention also restricts the availability of its ordinary monetary limits in cases involving specified intentional or reckless misconduct. These provisions serve different purposes. A special declaration is connected to the contractual arrangements made when baggage is entrusted to the carrier, while Article 22(5) addresses conduct that meets a demanding legal standard.


Neither exception guarantees an award equal to the amount demanded. The passenger must still establish compensable damage, and the applicable requirements of the relevant provision must be satisfied. The removal or increase of a liability ceiling affects the potential maximum recovery rather than dispensing with proof of loss.


5.1 A Special Declaration of Interest in Delivery


Article 22(2) allows a passenger to make a special declaration of interest in delivery at the destination when handing checked baggage over to the carrier. A supplementary charge may be payable. Where the declaration is valid, the carrier may be liable up to the declared sum rather than the ordinary baggage limit.


The timing of the declaration is essential. It is connected to the transfer of checked baggage to the carrier, not to a valuation submitted after the suitcase has disappeared. A passenger who discovers that lost belongings exceed the ordinary ceiling cannot retrospectively obtain the same protection simply by providing evidence of their original cost.


The declared sum does not automatically become payable upon loss. Article 22(2) permits the carrier to establish that the declared amount exceeds the passenger's actual interest in delivery. The mechanism consequently preserves a connection between compensation and the value of the interest affected.


Article 25 separately permits carriers to stipulate higher liability limits or unlimited liability. Such an undertaking must be distinguished from travel-insurance coverage, which may provide separate contractual benefits without altering the carrier's obligations under the Convention. The existence of a more generous airline arrangement must be established from the applicable contractual terms.


5.2 Intentional or Reckless Carrier Misconduct


Article 22(5) provides that the ordinary limits established in Article 22(1) and Article 22(2) do not apply where the damage resulted from an act or omission committed with intent to cause damage, or recklessly and with knowledge that damage would probably result. The provision addresses conduct more serious than ordinary operational negligence.


Where the relevant conduct was committed by a servant or agent, the claimant must also establish that the person acted within the scope of employment. The mental element remains essential. A baggage-handling mistake, negligent transfer, or prolonged failure to locate a suitcase does not automatically demonstrate the knowledge required by Article 22(5).


The exception can consequently be difficult to establish in an ordinary lost-baggage dispute. The claimant must prove the specified misconduct and its connection with the damage. If the conditions are satisfied, the carrier cannot rely on the ordinary Article 22(2) monetary ceiling, but compensation remains subject to the other applicable requirements governing recoverable damage.


6. Which Flights and Airlines Are Covered?


The Montreal Convention does not apply to every flight simply because an airline operates internationally. Its territorial scope depends principally on the agreed places of departure and destination, the treaty participation of the states concerned, and the contractual arrangements governing the journey. A flight described commercially as international may raise different legal questions from a domestic segment forming part of a qualifying international itinerary.


The nationality of the airline is not, by itself, the decisive consideration. A carrier established in one country may transport passengers between two others, while a single journey may involve several airlines operating under different commercial arrangements. The Convention contains specific provisions addressing these circumstances and allocating liability among successive, contracting, and actual carriers.


These distinctions become particularly significant when baggage disappears during a connection. The passenger may have purchased the ticket from one airline, checked the suitcase with another, and completed the final segment aboard a third. Identifying the applicable carriage arrangement determines which provisions govern the claim and which carriers may be held responsible.


6.1 International Carriage and Domestic Connections


Article 1(2) defines international carriage by reference to the agreement between the parties. The Convention applies where the agreed places of departure and destination are situated in the territories of two states parties. It also covers carriage beginning and ending in the territory of one state party where the agreed itinerary includes a stopping place in another state, even if that other state is not a contracting party.


A flight between Dublin and New York falls within the Convention's ordinary definition of international carriage because Ireland and the United States are parties. The analysis becomes more complicated when the itinerary includes domestic connections, separate tickets, or multiple carriers. The contractual arrangements and agreed journey must be examined rather than treating every individual flight segment in isolation.


Article 1(3) provides that carriage performed by successive carriers is regarded as a single undivided operation where the parties have considered it a single operation. A domestic connection may consequently remain part of international carriage governed by the Convention. Its legal status does not change merely because one aircraft operates entirely within the territory of a single country.


Treaty participation is also essential. Signature alone does not necessarily establish that a state is bound by the Montreal Convention. The relevant acts of ratification, acceptance, approval, or accession, together with the Convention's entry-into-force provisions, determine participation. These distinctions belong to the broader legal rules governing treaty obligations, examined in the site's article on the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties.


Where the Montreal Convention does not apply, the applicable legal regime must be identified separately. The earlier Warsaw Convention system may remain relevant in certain circumstances, while domestic legislation or contractual rules may govern other journeys. Article 55 addresses the relationship between Montreal and specified Warsaw Convention instruments, but it does not make the Montreal Convention universally applicable to all international flights.


6.2 Successive Airlines and Connecting Flights


Article 36 regulates liability where international carriage is performed by successive carriers within the meaning of Article 1(3). Such arrangements commonly arise when one airline operates the first segment of a journey and another performs a subsequent connection. Baggage may pass between different operators without the passenger directly participating in each transfer.


For baggage claims, Article 36(3) grants the passenger or consignor a right of action against the first carrier, and the passenger or consignee entitled to delivery a right of action against the last carrier. Each may also proceed against the carrier performing the transportation during which the destruction, loss, damage, or delay occurred. The carriers identified under the provision are jointly and severally liable to the qualifying claimant.


Joint and several liability is particularly useful where the passenger cannot determine during which segment the suitcase disappeared. A bag may be accepted at the departure airport, transferred through an intermediate hub, and never delivered at the final destination. The inability to reconstruct the precise sequence of handling does not automatically prevent a claim against a carrier identified by Article 36(3).


The provision does not authorize multiple recoveries for the same loss. Its function is to identify the carriers that may be responsible rather than multiply the amount of compensable damage. Questions concerning how liability is distributed among the airlines may arise separately from the passenger's entitlement to compensation.


6.3 Codeshare Flights and the Operating Carrier


Codeshare arrangements may involve one airline selling transportation while another performs the flight. The Montreal Convention addresses relevant arrangements through Chapter V, which concerns carriage performed by a person other than the contracting carrier. Article 39 distinguishes the contracting carrier from the actual carrier performing the transportation.


Article 40 provides that the contracting carrier is subject to the Convention's rules for the carriage contemplated by the contract, while the actual carrier is subject to those rules for the carriage it performs. Article 41 regulates the attribution of acts and omissions between the carriers, subject to the provision's conditions and limitations.


Article 42 is particularly relevant to baggage complaints. It provides that a complaint required under the Convention has the same effect whether addressed to the contracting carrier or the actual carrier. The provision protects passengers from certain difficulties associated with identifying the correct airline within a qualifying Chapter V arrangement.


Article 45 permits a damages action against the contracting carrier, the actual carrier, or both, within the scope of Chapter V. Article 46 establishes additional jurisdictional arrangements for such proceedings, while Article 44 regulates the aggregation of recoverable damages. The existence of more than one responsible carrier does not automatically increase the applicable compensation ceiling.


Successive carriage and carriage involving contracting and actual carriers are distinct legal arrangements. A journey involving several airline names does not necessarily fall within both sets of provisions. The appropriate rules depend on the carriage contract, the transportation actually performed, and the relationship between the participating airlines.


7. National Enforcement of Montreal Convention Claims


The Montreal Convention establishes common international liability rules, but it does not create an international court responsible for deciding individual lost-baggage claims. Enforcement ordinarily occurs through claims made against airlines and proceedings before competent national courts. Administrative complaint mechanisms may also be available under the law of the relevant jurisdiction.


Domestic law remains relevant because the Convention does not regulate every procedural question. National legal systems determine matters such as the commencement of proceedings, applicable evidentiary procedures, and the enforcement of judgments, subject to the treaty's mandatory provisions. The resulting differences must be distinguished from the substantive liability standards established by the Convention.


National and regional legislation may also provide protections beyond the Convention's ordinary baggage compensation rules. Such additional rights require their own legal basis and conditions. A passenger seeking reimbursement under national consumer-protection regulations may consequently be pursuing a legally distinct remedy from damages under Article 17 or Article 19.


7.1 Jurisdiction and the Limits of Legal Proceedings


Article 33(1) establishes the jurisdictional grounds available for damages actions under the Montreal Convention. At the claimant's option, proceedings may be brought in the territory of a state party before a court connected to the carrier's domicile, principal place of business, place of business through which the contract was made, or place of destination.


These connecting factors can be significant where a ticket is purchased online or the passenger resides in a country different from the airline's place of establishment. The Convention does not establish a general entitlement to sue in the passenger's home jurisdiction merely because the passenger lives there or purchased the ticket through an internet platform.


Article 33(2) provides an additional jurisdictional ground associated with the passenger's principal and permanent residence, but it concerns damage resulting from death or bodily injury. It does not establish an equivalent additional forum for ordinary baggage claims.


The Court of Justice addressed this distinction in I.G.V. v Vueling Airlines SA, Case C-876/24, decided on September 17, 2026. The case concerned baggage lost during a domestic flight between Madrid and Barcelona. The passenger had purchased the flight online from her home and subsequently added checked baggage as a separate service at the airport.


The Court held that Regulation (EC) No 2027/97 extends the Montreal Convention's jurisdictional rules to the relevant domestic carriage by an EU carrier. It also held that purchasing a ticket online does not make the passenger's principal and permanent residence the place where the carrier has a business establishment through which the contract was made. For the contractual jurisdictional ground in Article 33(1), the relevant contract is the passenger's air-carriage contract, even where the baggage service was purchased separately (CJEU, 2026).


The judgment illustrates the importance of distinguishing physical residence, online contracting, and the carrier's relevant business establishment. These questions fall within the broader field of private international law, which addresses jurisdiction, applicable law, and the recognition and enforcement of judgments in cross-border private disputes.


Article 29 further restricts actions for damages arising from the carriage of passengers, baggage, or cargo. Such actions remain subject to the Convention's conditions and liability limits, whether founded in contract, tort, or another legal basis. Punitive, exemplary, and other non-compensatory damages are expressly excluded.


The compensation ceiling must nevertheless be distinguished from litigation costs and interest. Article 22(6) permits courts, in accordance with their own law, to award certain litigation costs, expenses, and interest in addition to the relevant liability limits. That permission is subject to an exception where the damages awarded, excluding litigation expenses, do not exceed the carrier's qualifying written settlement offer made within six months after the event causing the damage or before proceedings begin, if that is later.


7.2 EU Rules and National Implementation


Council Regulation (EC) No 2027/97, as amended by Regulation (EC) No 889/2002, incorporates Montreal Convention liability rules into the European Union's legal framework. It also extends the relevant liability regime to carriage by EU air carriers within a single Member State. This extension is important because a purely domestic journey does not necessarily satisfy the Convention's own definition of international carriage.


The distinction was confirmed in I.G.V. v Vueling Airlines, where the Court of Justice applied the jurisdictional arrangements associated with the Convention to a domestic Spanish baggage dispute through the relevant EU regulation. The judgment illustrates how regional legislation can extend the practical reach of international liability rules without altering the treaty's original territorial definition.


Baggage compensation under Regulation 2027/97 must be distinguished from the standardized remedies established by Regulation (EC) No 261/2004. The latter regulates specified circumstances involving denied boarding, cancellations, and flight delays. It does not establish a universal fixed payment of €250, €400, or €600 merely because checked baggage has been lost. Claims involving baggage damage ordinarily require assessment under the Montreal liability regime and the relevant implementing rules.


Regulation (EU) 2026/2202, adopted on September 16, 2026, introduces further amendments to European passenger-rights legislation. Published on October 2, it entered into force on October 22, 2026, but its substantive provisions apply from October 23, 2027. The distinction between entry into force and application is essential when determining which rules govern a particular incident.


The revised legislation introduces additional arrangements for baggage complaints, including standardized forms intended to facilitate the reporting of lost, delayed, or damaged baggage. Under the new provisions, qualifying complaint forms must be accepted by airlines, and their submission dates are recognized for the purposes of the applicable complaint requirements. Airlines may request further information, but that does not automatically change the date on which a qualifying complaint was submitted.


These future provisions do not replace the existing Article 31 requirements for baggage incidents occurring before their application date. The same legislative reform also addresses cabin-baggage entitlements and charges, which involve a different legal question from compensation for lost checked luggage. Those changes are examined separately in the site's analysis of EU hand luggage rules for 2027.


Outside the European Union, implementation occurs through different domestic legal arrangements. In the United Kingdom, the Carriage by Air Act 1961 forms part of the relevant legislative framework, while the Carriage by Air (Revision of Limits of Liability under the Montreal Convention) Order 2025 certified the revised limits, including the 1,519 SDR baggage ceiling. The order entered into force on February 7, 2025, following the international revision effective December 28, 2024.


Canada applies the Montreal Convention to qualifying international transportation and provides additional passenger protections under its national regulatory framework. The Canadian Transportation Agency recognizes the 1,519 SDR ceiling for relevant baggage claims and identifies separate obligations concerning baggage-fee refunds. Domestic carriage may involve different liability arrangements, including the airline's applicable tariff.


Australia recognizes the revised Montreal Convention limits through its Civil Aviation (Carriers' Liability) Act 1959 and related official measures. The United States similarly applies the Convention to qualifying international carriage while maintaining separate federal rules concerning domestic baggage liability and specified baggage-fee refunds. These arrangements reflect the relationship between international obligations and domestic law rather than the creation of a single worldwide administrative claims procedure.


The interaction between treaty obligations and national enforcement is part of the wider relationship between international law and municipal law. States may use different legal techniques to give effect to international commitments, but those techniques do not alter the obligation to comply with the treaty. For passengers, the practical consequences concern the competent court, procedural requirements, available remedies, and enforcement of any judgment obtained.


8. The Five-Year Revision of Montreal Convention Limits


Article 24 establishes a mechanism for periodically reviewing the Montreal Convention's liability limits to account for inflation. Without such a mechanism, fixed financial ceilings would gradually lose purchasing power even though the substantive rules governing carrier responsibility remained unchanged. The Convention addresses that problem through reviews conducted at five-year intervals.


ICAO serves as the Convention's depositary and administers the relevant review and notification procedures. The inflation factor is determined through the weighted average of annual changes in consumer price indices in states whose currencies comprise the SDR basket. The calculation concerns accumulated inflation since the previous revision or, for the first review, since the Convention's entry into force.


Under Article 24(2), where the relevant inflation factor exceeds 10 percent, the depositary notifies states parties of a revision. The adjustment becomes effective six months after notification unless a majority of states parties registers disapproval within three months. Where the required majority objects, the proposed revision does not take effect and the matter is referred to a meeting of states parties.


Article 24(3) also permits a special review procedure outside the ordinary cycle. It applies where at least one-third of states parties expresses the necessary desire for review and accumulated inflation exceeds 30 percent under the provision's conditions. The mechanism does not establish automatic annual increases or guarantee that every five-year review will produce a higher liability ceiling.


The December 2024 revision illustrates the operation of Article 24. ICAO announced the revised limits on October 18, 2024, with effect from December 28. The ordinary baggage ceiling increased from 1,288 to 1,519 SDRs, approximately 17.9 percent. The original Convention had established a baggage limit of 1,000 SDRs, which was subsequently revised through the treaty's inflation-adjustment procedure (ICAO, 2024).


Other liability categories were adjusted at the same time. The passenger-delay ceiling under Article 22(1) increased from 5,346 to 6,303 SDRs, while the cargo limit under Article 22(3) increased from 22 to 26 SDRs per kilogram. Each category retains its own substantive liability requirements, notwithstanding the shared mechanism for revising monetary limits.


The adjustment did not amend the legal conditions governing baggage liability under Articles 17 and 19, the written complaint requirements under Article 31, or the limitation period under Article 35. A higher ceiling increases the amount potentially recoverable where sufficient damage is established, but it does not create an automatic entitlement to the maximum award.


States parties must give effect to revised limits through their respective legal arrangements. ICAO's announcement invited states to make the necessary domestic provisions, and subsequent national measures have recognized the revised amounts. The United Kingdom's 2025 order and Australia's official notification illustrate different methods of recognizing the same international revision.


The next ordinary review will operate under Article 24's prescribed conditions rather than a predetermined annual increase. The mechanism preserves the distinction between monetary adjustment and substantive liability. It allows the Convention's financial limits to respond to inflation while retaining the common rules that determine when carriers are responsible and what passengers must establish to recover compensation.


Conclusion


Lost luggage compensation under the Montreal Convention is ordinarily subject to a limit of 1,519 SDRs per passenger for qualifying international carriage, following the revision effective December 28, 2024. The limit establishes the maximum ordinary liability rather than a guaranteed payment. The amount recoverable depends on the damage established, the legal conditions governing the carrier's responsibility, and any applicable exception to the ceiling.


The Convention's procedural requirements must be distinguished carefully. Article 17(3) permits passengers to enforce contractual rights where checked baggage remains undelivered for 21 days after its expected arrival or the carrier admits its loss. Article 31 separately requires written complaints within seven days for damaged checked baggage and within 21 days after delayed baggage becomes available. Article 35 establishes the separate two-year period for bringing legal proceedings.


The Court of Justice's baggage decisions clarify how these rules operate in practice. Espada Sánchez addresses claims involving shared baggage; Walz confirms that material and non-material damage fall within the same ceiling; SL v Vueling Airlines explains why the maximum is not an automatic award; and Finnair establishes important requirements concerning electronic written complaints. The September 2026 judgment in I.G.V. v Vueling Airlines further clarifies jurisdiction in baggage disputes involving online contracts and domestic carriage covered by EU law.


The Montreal Convention supplies a common international basis for airline liability, while national courts and legal systems determine the practical resolution of individual claims. A legally sustainable compensation demand depends on identifying the applicable liability regime and responsible carrier, establishing the compensable loss, observing the relevant complaint requirements, and bringing proceedings within the prescribed period where judicial enforcement becomes necessary.


References

Australian Government (1959) Civil Aviation (Carriers’ Liability) Act 1959, No. 2 of 1959, as amended. Canberra: Commonwealth of Australia. Available at: https://www.legislation.gov.au/C1959A00002/latest (Accessed: 1 November 2026).


Australian Government (2025) Notice under Section 9K(1)(b) of the Civil Aviation (Carriers’ Liability) Act 1959, Commonwealth Gazette, C2025G00606, 5 November. Available at: https://www.legislation.gov.au/C2025G00606 (Accessed: 1 November 2026).


Canadian Transportation Agency (2024) Notification to air carriers of upward revision of the limits of liability governed by the Montreal Convention [online]. Available at: https://otc-cta.gc.ca/eng/content/notification-air-carriers-upward-revision-limits-liability-governed-montreal-convention (Accessed: 1 November 2026).


Canadian Transportation Agency (2025) Lost, damaged or delayed baggage [online]. Available at: https://protection-passager-passenger.otc-cta.gc.ca/en/when-an-issue-happens/lost-damaged-or-delayed-baggage (Accessed: 2 November 2026).


Carriage by Air Act 1961 (UK), 9 & 10 Eliz. 2, c. 27, 22 June 1961, as amended. Available at: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/Eliz2/9-10/27/contents (Accessed: 2 November 2026).


Carriage by Air (Revision of Limits of Liability under the Montreal Convention) Order 2025 (UK), SI 2025/123, made 5 February 2025, entered into force 7 February 2025. Available at: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2025/123/made (Accessed: 2 November 2026).


Council of the European Union (1997) Council Regulation (EC) No 2027/97 of 9 October 1997 on air carrier liability in the event of accidents, Official Journal of the European Communities, L 285, 17 October, pp. 1–3, as amended. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/1997/2027/oj/eng (Accessed: 4 November 2026).


Court of Justice of the European Union (2010) Axel Walz v Clickair SA, Case C-63/09, judgment of 6 May 2010, ECLI:EU:C:2010:251, European Court Reports 2010, I-4239. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:62009CJ0063 (Accessed: 4 November 2026).


Court of Justice of the European Union (2012) Pedro Espada Sánchez and Others v Iberia Líneas Aéreas de España SA, Case C-410/11, judgment of 22 November 2012, ECLI:EU:C:2012:747. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:62011CJ0410 (Accessed: 4 November 2026).


Court of Justice of the European Union (2018) Finnair Oyj v Keskinäinen Vakuutusyhtiö Fennia, Case C-258/16, judgment of 12 April 2018, ECLI:EU:C:2018:252. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:62016CJ0258 (Accessed: 4 November 2026).


Court of Justice of the European Union (2020) SL v Vueling Airlines SA, Case C-86/19, judgment of 9 July 2020, ECLI:EU:C:2020:538. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:62019CJ0086 (Accessed: 4 November 2026).


Court of Justice of the European Union (2026) I.G.V. v Vueling Airlines SA, Case C-876/24, judgment of 17 September 2026, ECLI:EU:C:2026:768. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:62024CJ0876 (Accessed: 5 November 2026).


European Parliament and Council of the European Union (2002) Regulation (EC) No 889/2002 of 13 May 2002 amending Council Regulation (EC) No 2027/97 on air carrier liability in the event of accidents, Official Journal of the European Communities, L 140, 30 May, pp. 2–5. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2002/889/oj/eng (Accessed: 5 November 2026).


European Parliament and Council of the European Union (2004) Regulation (EC) No 261/2004 of 11 February 2004 establishing common rules on compensation and assistance to passengers in the event of denied boarding and of cancellation or long delay of flights, Official Journal of the European Union, L 46, 17 February, pp. 1–8. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng (Accessed: 5 November 2026).


European Parliament and Council of the European Union (2026) Regulation (EU) 2026/2202 of 16 September 2026 amending Regulation (EC) No 261/2004 and Council Regulation (EC) No 2027/97, Official Journal of the European Union, L, 2026/2202, 2 October. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2026/2202/oj/eng (Accessed: 6 November 2026).


International Air Transport Association (n.d.) The Montreal Convention 1999 (MC99) [online]. Available at: https://www.iata.org/en/programs/passenger/mc99 (Accessed: 6 November 2026).


International Civil Aviation Organization (2024) International air travel liability limits set to increase, enhancing customer compensation [online]. 18 October. Available at: https://www.icao.int/news/international-air-travel-liability-limits-set-increase-enhancing-customer-compensation-0 (Accessed: 10 November 2026).


International Monetary Fund (2023) What is the SDR? [online]. 7 October. Available at: https://www.imf.org/en/About/Factsheets/Sheets/2023/special-drawing-rights-sdr (Accessed: 10 November 2026).


Irish Aviation Authority (n.d.) Air Passenger Rights: Frequently Asked Questions [online]. Available at: https://www.iaa.ie/consumer-protection/air-passenger-rights/apr-faqs (Accessed: 10 November 2026).


Montreal Convention (1999) Convention for the Unification of Certain Rules for International Carriage by Air, adopted at Montreal on 28 May 1999, entered into force on 4 November 2003, 2242 UNTS 309, Registration No. 39917. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/convention/2001/539/oj/eng (Accessed: 10 November 2026).


United States Department of Transportation (2024) Final Rule: Refunds and Other Consumer Protections, 14 CFR Parts 259, 260, 262 and 399, Docket Nos. DOT-OST-2022-0089 and DOT-OST-2016-0208, RIN 2105-AF04, April. Available at: https://www.transportation.gov/airconsumer/refundsfinalruleapril2024 (Accessed: 10 November 2026).


United States Department of Transportation (n.d.) Refunds [online]. Available at: https://www.transportation.gov/individuals/aviation-consumer-protection/refunds (Accessed: 10 November 2026).

bottom of page