The Montreal Protocol: Ozone Law, Compliance and Why the Treaty Worked
Introduction
The Montreal Protocol is an international treaty that requires states to reduce and, in most cases, eliminate the production and consumption of chemicals that damage the ozone layer. Adopted on September 16, 1987, and in force since January 1, 1989, it established legally binding controls on substances such as chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs), halons, and other ozone-depleting chemicals. Its effectiveness rests on a combination of enforceable phaseout schedules, scientific assessment, financial assistance, trade controls, and procedures for addressing noncompliance.
The treaty responded to a serious atmospheric threat. Chemicals widely used in refrigeration, air conditioning, aerosols, and industrial processes were releasing chlorine and bromine into the stratosphere, where they could destroy ozone molecules. The resulting ozone depletion increased the potential for harmful ultraviolet radiation to reach Earth's surface. The discovery of severe seasonal depletion over Antarctica gave particular urgency to international negotiations.
The Montreal Protocol is widely regarded as a successful environmental agreement because controlled production and consumption have fallen substantially and the stratospheric ozone layer is showing signs of recovery. Those achievements do not mean that the ozone hole has disappeared or that compliance is complete. The treaty's legal design, its implementation record, and the scientific evidence of recovery must be considered separately to understand both its success and its remaining limits.
1. The Atmospheric Problem Behind the Treaty
Stratospheric ozone absorbs much of the Sun's biologically harmful ultraviolet radiation. Most atmospheric ozone is concentrated approximately 15 to 35 kilometers above Earth's surface, although its distribution varies with latitude, season, and atmospheric conditions. Depletion of this protective layer can increase exposure to ultraviolet-B radiation, with consequences for human health, ecosystems, and materials.
The problem differs from ground-level ozone pollution. Ozone near the Earth's surface is a harmful air pollutant, while stratospheric ozone performs a protective function. The Montreal Protocol addresses chemicals capable of damaging the stratospheric layer, rather than regulating atmospheric ozone as though it were a single pollutant with the same effects at every altitude.
International regulation became necessary because the relevant substances could circulate through the global atmosphere regardless of where they were manufactured or released. National restrictions alone could reduce emissions within a particular jurisdiction, but they could not adequately protect a shared atmospheric system while production and use continued elsewhere.
1.1 How Chlorofluorocarbons Destroy Ozone
Chlorofluorocarbons were attractive industrial chemicals because they were relatively stable, nonflammable, and useful in refrigeration, foam production, and other applications. That stability also allowed many CFC molecules to remain in the atmosphere long enough to reach the stratosphere.
At higher altitudes, ultraviolet radiation can break down these molecules and release chlorine atoms. Chlorine participates in catalytic reactions that destroy ozone, meaning that one chlorine atom can contribute to the destruction of many ozone molecules before it is removed from the relevant chemical cycle. Bromine released from halons and other compounds can be especially efficient in ozone-destroying reactions.
Antarctica presents conditions that intensify the process. Exceptionally low stratospheric temperatures permit the formation of polar stratospheric clouds, which facilitate chemical reactions involving chlorine and bromine. When sunlight returns after the polar winter, the resulting chemistry can produce rapid seasonal ozone loss within the Antarctic polar vortex.
The term ozone hole describes an area of exceptionally depleted stratospheric ozone, rather than a literal opening in the atmosphere. Its size and severity change from year to year as atmospheric temperatures, circulation, and chemical conditions vary. This variability is important when evaluating whether a particular ozone season indicates improvement or deterioration.
1.2 Chemical Persistence and the Need for Global Controls
The danger was difficult to perceive during the early commercial use of CFCs. Their chemical stability, initially valued as a safety and performance advantage, allowed them to accumulate in the atmosphere. The environmental consequences could emerge far from the factories and consumers responsible for their release.
The 1974 research of Mario Molina and F. Sherwood Rowland identified the possibility that CFCs could release chlorine in the stratosphere and damage ozone. Their work provided an important scientific basis for evaluating chemicals that had previously been treated primarily in terms of their immediate industrial properties (Molina and Rowland, 1974).
The long atmospheric lifetimes of many ozone-depleting substances also meant that eliminating new production would not produce immediate restoration. Existing chemicals could continue to affect the stratosphere for decades. A legally effective response had to prevent further accumulation while allowing time for atmospheric processes to remove substances already released.
This persistence explains the importance of ozone-depletion potential, or ODP. ODP expresses the relative capacity of a substance to deplete stratospheric ozone, using CFC-11 as the reference substance. The Protocol's system of calculated levels incorporates substance-specific factors, enabling legal controls to reflect differences in environmental harm rather than treating every kilogram of every chemical as equivalent.
2. From Scientific Warning to the 1987 Agreement
The Montreal Protocol emerged from negotiations that preceded the most widely recognized evidence of the Antarctic ozone hole. Scientific concerns about CFCs had already prompted national restrictions, public debate, and international discussions during the 1970s. Governments disagreed, however, about the strength of the evidence, the economic consequences of restricting industrial chemicals, and the level of action justified under uncertainty.
The Vienna Convention for the Protection of the Ozone Layer, adopted on March 22, 1985, established a framework for scientific cooperation, research, observation, and information exchange. It did not itself impose the detailed substance-specific production and consumption limits that later became central to the Montreal Protocol.
In May 1985, Joseph Farman, Brian Gardiner, and Jonathan Shanklin published findings documenting severe springtime ozone depletion over Antarctica. Their measurements revealed a striking atmospheric phenomenon that challenged prevailing expectations about the scale of ozone loss (Farman, Gardiner and Shanklin, 1985).
Because the Antarctic findings were published after the Vienna Convention had been adopted, they did not provide the basis for its original negotiations. They nevertheless transformed the scientific and political circumstances in which governments negotiated more demanding international controls.
This sequence illustrates a significant development in international environmental law. Governments first established a cooperative legal framework and subsequently negotiated more specific controls as scientific findings and political conditions developed. The Vienna Convention supplied an institutional foundation; the Montreal Protocol introduced measurable obligations.
The agreement reached in September 1987 initially regulated a limited group of CFCs and halons. It did not represent the final scientific understanding of ozone depletion or the final schedule of restrictions. Subsequent meetings strengthened the controls as evidence accumulated and alternative technologies became more widely available.
Edward A. Parson's historical analysis emphasizes the relationship among scientific assessment, negotiations, and technological change in the development of the ozone regime. The treaty's evolution is difficult to explain solely through the discovery of the Antarctic ozone hole or through any single diplomatic breakthrough (Parson, 2003).
3. The Montreal Protocol's Binding Controls
The Montreal Protocol converted the general objective of ozone protection into obligations concerning identified chemicals. Its annexes specify controlled substances, while the operative provisions establish restrictions on their production and consumption. These obligations are supplemented by reporting requirements, trade-related measures, and arrangements for differentiated implementation.
The treaty does not require states to demonstrate that every individual emission has caused measurable ozone depletion. It regulates production and consumption quantities calculated under agreed legal rules. This design permits compliance to be assessed against defined limits without requiring proof of environmental damage attributable to each state.
The Protocol also contains procedures through which parties can revise control measures as scientific and technical circumstances change. Its legal development must be understood through the relationship between the original treaty, subsequent amendments, adjustments, and decisions of the Meeting of the Parties.
3.1 Production, Consumption, and Phaseout Schedules
Article 1 gives production and consumption specialized meanings. Production is calculated after specified deductions, including quantities destroyed by approved technologies and quantities entirely used as feedstock in manufacturing other chemicals. Recycling and reuse do not count as new production under this definition.
Consumption is generally calculated as production plus imports minus exports, subject to the Protocol's detailed accounting rules. Consequently, a country's reported consumption is not a direct measurement of the amount of a chemical physically used by households or industry during a particular year. Nor does it represent the quantity emitted into the atmosphere.
Article 3 supplies the calculation rules, including the use of relevant weighting factors. These definitions allow parties to compare reported activity with legally prescribed limits. They also create a need for accurate national inventories and controls on transactions involving regulated substances.
The phaseout schedules vary by substance and category of party. For example, the strengthened CFC controls required non-Article 5 parties to end ordinary production and consumption of the principal Annex A CFCs by 1996, subject to the treaty's applicable qualifications and exemptions. Article 5 parties received a later principal phaseout deadline of 2010.
The subsequent regulation of hydrochlorofluorocarbons (HCFCs) demonstrates that the Protocol addresses different chemicals through different schedules. HCFCs generally have lower ozone-depletion potentials than the CFCs they replaced, but they still damage ozone. Their use was consequently restricted through a separate sequence of control measures.
The governing obligation is the applicable treaty schedule, including any authorized exemptions and special provisions. Describing the Protocol as an absolute prohibition on every use of every listed substance would obscure the distinctions on which its compliance system depends.
3.2 Amendments, Adjustments, and Treaty Participation
The Montreal Protocol was strengthened through major amendments adopted in London in 1990, Copenhagen in 1992, Montreal in 1997, and Beijing in 1999. These instruments expanded or refined the regime's substance coverage and implementation arrangements. The Kigali Amendment of 2016 later introduced controls on hydrofluorocarbons for their climate effects.
An amendment and an adjustment do not have identical legal consequences. Amendments alter the treaty under the applicable acceptance and entry-into-force procedures. Adjustments to existing control measures can take effect through the special decision-making system provided by the Protocol, without repeating the ordinary ratification process for every participating state to which the relevant adjustment applies.
The legal distinction must be understood within the wider law of treaties. States are bound by obligations that apply to them under the relevant treaty provisions and rules on consent, amendment, and entry into force. A new amendment cannot simply be treated as universally binding because the original Protocol has universal participation.
The original Montreal Protocol had 198 parties as of November 2026, according to the United Nations Treaty Collection. This exceptionally broad participation reduces the scope for regulated production and trade to shift toward jurisdictions outside the original treaty.
Universal participation does not mean identical obligations at every moment. Different phaseout schedules, amendment participation, exemptions, and special provisions remain legally significant. The regime combines a common international structure with differentiated responsibilities determined by the treaty itself.
4. Trade, Finance, and Differentiated Obligations
The Montreal Protocol regulates more than domestic chemical production. It also addresses the commercial and financial conditions that affect whether states can implement agreed restrictions. Trade measures discourage circumvention, while differentiated schedules and financial assistance respond to unequal economic and technological capacities.
These arrangements were particularly important because controlled substances were embedded in existing industrial systems. Refrigeration equipment, manufacturing processes, maintenance services, and chemical supply chains could not always be replaced immediately. A phaseout obligation could be legally clear while remaining difficult to implement without investment and technical support.
The treaty's design recognized that international cooperation would be weakened if developing countries faced the costs of replacing regulated technologies without corresponding assistance. It linked participation in common environmental objectives to defined support arrangements.
4.1 Restrictions on Trade and National Licensing
Article 4 provides for restrictions on specified trade with nonparties. Its provisions address controlled substances and, under particular conditions, products associated with them. The details depend on the substances and treaty provisions applicable to the parties concerned.
These controls created an incentive to participate in the treaty regime and limited opportunities to evade restrictions through trade with states outside it. Their effect should not be exaggerated into a claim that the Protocol imposed a universal embargo on all chemical products from nonparties.
Article 4B establishes licensing requirements for imports and exports of controlled substances. Licensing systems allow national authorities to identify and regulate cross-border movements, including transactions involving substances recovered from previous use.
Trade regulation remains dependent on domestic implementation. States must establish competent authorities, licensing procedures, customs controls, and enforcement measures under their own legal systems. The international obligation provides the framework, but national administrative capacity determines how effectively particular transactions are supervised.
Illegal trade and misclassification can undermine otherwise effective phaseout schedules. Trade records and licensing information consequently contribute to compliance assessment alongside the production and consumption data reported under Article 7.
4.2 Article 5 Countries and the Multilateral Fund
Article 5 recognizes the special situation of qualifying developing countries. Eligibility is determined by the treaty's criteria, including specified consumption thresholds and reference periods, rather than by a general political designation. For Annex A substances, the relevant provision includes a threshold of 0.3 kilograms per capita.
Qualifying parties have received longer periods for implementing certain controls. These extensions were intended to accommodate basic domestic needs while preserving the objective of eventual phaseout. They do not establish a permanent exemption from the treaty's environmental obligations.
The financial mechanism is principally governed by Article 10, with technology transfer addressed in Article 10A. The mechanism is designed to meet agreed incremental costs incurred by eligible parties in complying with the Protocol. These are qualifying additional costs associated with replacing controlled substances and implementing required changes, determined under the mechanism's rules.
The Second Meeting of the Parties adopted Decision II/8 in 1990, establishing an interim financial mechanism for a period beginning January 1, 1991. That arrangement included the Multilateral Fund. The Fund subsequently became a central institution for financing approved conversion projects, technical assistance, training, and implementation support.
Its structure differs from a general commitment to provide development assistance. The financial arrangements are tied to particular treaty obligations, qualifying costs, and agreed procedures. This connection gives assistance a defined role within the compliance system.
The arrangement is also distinct from climate-finance commitments associated with the Paris Agreement. Under the Montreal Protocol, assistance is closely integrated with substance-specific controls and the special legal position of Article 5 parties. The comparison helps explain the institutional specificity of the ozone regime without suggesting that the two agreements impose identical financial duties.
The Fund remains active. At the Thirty-Eighth Meeting of the Parties in November 2026, governments agreed on a $695 million replenishment package for 2027–2029, comprising new contributions and carried-over resources. Continued financing reflects the fact that HCFC elimination, HFC reductions, and associated implementation work remain unfinished.
5. Reporting, Review, and Noncompliance
A treaty based on quantified controls requires information about what states produce, import, export, destroy, and use in specified ways. Article 7 establishes reporting obligations that enable the Ozone Secretariat and the parties to assess performance against the applicable schedules.
Reported figures serve a legal purpose, but they are not the only source of evidence about the treaty's effects. Atmospheric measurements can reveal changes in concentrations and suggest emissions that national reporting may not fully explain. The two forms of information answer different questions and are most useful when considered together.
Noncompliance also requires careful legal treatment. A reporting discrepancy may arise from administrative problems, classification differences, measurement uncertainty, or conduct inconsistent with the treaty. The existence of a discrepancy does not itself establish every element of a legal breach.
5.1 The Implementation Committee's Cooperative Procedure
Article 8 directed the parties to approve procedures and institutional mechanisms for determining and addressing noncompliance. A permanent procedure was adopted through Decision IV/5 in 1992 and revised by Decision X/10 in 1998.
The Implementation Committee considers possible cases of noncompliance and reports to the Meeting of the Parties. Its work involves communication with the state concerned, evaluation of available information, and recommendations aimed at restoring compliance. The system is not organized as an international court deciding adversarial claims between states.
The procedure has allowed the parties to consider explanations for missed deadlines, reporting failures, and difficulties with national implementation. Agreed plans of action, monitoring, and assistance can form part of the response. The legal significance of an individual measure depends on the applicable treaty provisions and decisions.
The indicative list of measures available to the parties includes responses of varying severity. Cooperative treatment is characteristic of the regime, but it does not mean that noncompliance has no possible consequences. Continued failure to meet agreed commitments may prompt consideration of stronger measures.
This approach is distinct from the general rules of state responsibility in international law. The Protocol's institutional procedure is designed to address compliance with its own obligations. It should not be described as replacing every legal consequence that might arise under otherwise applicable international law.
The distinction also helps explain the procedure's practical appeal. Governments can acknowledge difficulties and negotiate corrective action without necessarily entering a contentious process centered on compensation, judicial findings, or reciprocal accusations.
5.2 Russian Noncompliance and Conditional Assistance
The Russian Federation provides a documented example of the Protocol's approach to serious implementation difficulties. Following the economic and industrial disruptions of the post-Soviet period, Russia faced problems meeting applicable obligations concerning ozone-depleting substances.
In Decision VIII/25, adopted in 1996, the Meeting of the Parties recorded that Russia was in a situation of noncompliance, referring to the information supplied by the government and its representatives. The decision also acknowledged progress, requested further information, and maintained scrutiny of the country's phaseout efforts.
Decision X/26, adopted in 1998, addressed Russia's commitments through a country program and a special initiative concerning the closure of ozone-depleting-substance production. It identified time-based objectives, required continued monitoring, and linked favorable treatment to progress toward compliance.
The decision also contemplated stronger measures if the specified commitments were not met. Assistance and the possibility of adverse responses were thus part of the same institutional process rather than mutually exclusive approaches.
Russia was not an Article 5 party. Its circumstances and sources of international assistance must be distinguished from the ordinary operation of the Multilateral Fund for eligible developing countries. Financial support associated with the Global Environment Facility and other arrangements formed part of the wider effort to facilitate the transition.
The example illustrates the procedural flexibility of the Montreal regime. It does not prove that assistance alone secured compliance, nor should the decisions be treated as judicial findings on state responsibility. They show how the parties used reporting, commitments, review, and conditional cooperation to address an identified failure to meet treaty requirements.
6. The Evidence of Success and Its Causes
The Montreal Protocol's effectiveness can be assessed through several different measures. One concerns whether parties complied with production and consumption limits. Another concerns changes in atmospheric concentrations of regulated chemicals. A third asks whether the ozone layer is recovering as scientific models predicted.
These measures are related but not interchangeable. A state may meet its calculated consumption obligations while emissions continue from old equipment or existing chemical stocks. Similarly, successful reductions in new production cannot immediately remove long-lived substances already circulating in the atmosphere.
The evidence supports a strong conclusion that the Protocol has substantially reduced human pressure on the ozone layer. Explaining why it achieved this result is more difficult because legal obligations operated alongside scientific developments, industrial innovation, national regulations, and changing economic incentives.
6.1 Scientific Assessment and Technological Substitution
The Protocol established recurring interaction between expert assessment and political decision-making. Scientific bodies evaluate atmospheric changes and chemical risks, while technical assessments inform parties about available substitutes, costs, and implementation difficulties.
This arrangement helped governments reconsider controls as knowledge improved. Parties could strengthen phaseout schedules in response to new evidence without renegotiating the environmental objective from the beginning. The legal system's capacity for adjustment was particularly valuable because the science and economics of ozone protection changed rapidly after 1987.
Technological substitution was another important condition. Producers and users developed or adopted alternatives for refrigeration, aerosols, foams, and industrial processes. These changes affected the economic feasibility of stricter controls, although substitutes differed in cost, performance, ozone-depletion potential, and climate effects.
The relationship was reciprocal. International restrictions encouraged investment in alternatives, while growing confidence in substitute technologies made additional controls more politically and economically feasible. Parson's account of the ozone negotiations treats scientific assessment, technical innovation, and repeated bargaining as interconnected developments (Parson, 2003).
Financial assistance reduced certain implementation barriers for Article 5 parties, and trade restrictions limited some opportunities to continue commercial activity outside the agreed framework. The noncompliance procedure supplied a means of addressing problems without automatically converting every failure into an adversarial dispute.
The available historical evidence does not assign a precise share of the treaty's success to each mechanism. The more defensible explanation is that these institutions reinforced one another under conditions in which substitutes became increasingly available and governments accepted progressively stronger restrictions.
6.2 Atmospheric Decline and Ozone Recovery
The Scientific Assessment of Ozone Depletion: 2026, prepared under the auspices of the World Meteorological Organization and the United Nations Environment Programme, reports continued declines in the atmospheric abundance of major controlled ozone-depleting substances. It also identifies clear indications of recovery in stratospheric ozone (WMO, 2026).
These findings provide evidence beyond the treaty's administrative records. Atmospheric measurements indicate whether changes in production, use, and emissions are reflected in the composition of the atmosphere. They help assess whether international controls are producing the environmental effects for which they were adopted.
The 2026 assessment projects that near-global mean total-column ozone will return to approximately 1980 values around 2040. For Antarctic total-column ozone, the corresponding return is projected during the 2060s under the specified greenhouse-gas scenario. These are modeled projections, not dates on which the ozone hole is guaranteed to disappear.
The timing remains affected by greenhouse-gas concentrations, atmospheric circulation, chemical emissions, and natural variability. A severe Antarctic ozone season can still occur during a longer period of recovery. Conversely, a relatively small ozone hole in a particular year does not independently establish that recovery is complete.
Unexpected emissions of CFC-11 demonstrated the continuing value of independent observation. Atmospheric measurements identified an increase that was inconsistent with expected trends. Subsequent scientific analyses attributed a substantial portion of the increase to eastern mainland China and found that emissions declined markedly between 2018 and 2019 (NOAA, 2021).
Those findings exposed a weakness that administrative reporting alone might not have revealed. They also showed that scientific monitoring could support investigation and corrective action. Geographical attribution of emissions, however, must be distinguished from a formal legal determination concerning the responsibility of a particular state.
The strongest evidence of success is the consistency between substantial reductions in controlled ozone-depleting substances and the observed beginnings of atmospheric recovery. That conclusion does not require assuming flawless compliance or describing the treaty's environmental objective as already achieved.
7. The Kyoto Protocol and Kigali's Climate Obligations
The Montreal Protocol and the Kyoto Protocol regulate different environmental problems, although some of the chemicals involved have consequences for both ozone depletion and climate change.
The Kyoto Protocol, adopted in 1997 under the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, established quantified greenhouse-gas commitments for specified developed-country parties. Its Annex A includes hydrofluorocarbons among the greenhouse gases covered by the climate regime.
The Montreal Protocol originally concentrated on substances that damage stratospheric ozone. Many CFCs and HCFCs also have substantial global warming effects, so their elimination can provide climate benefits. Nevertheless, the original legal purpose and control structure were directed principally toward ozone protection.
Some hydrofluorocarbons became substitutes for ozone-depleting refrigerants and other chemicals because they generally do not destroy stratospheric ozone. Many HFCs are, however, powerful greenhouse gases. Their expanding use created a climate problem associated in part with technological transitions that had reduced ozone-depleting chemicals.
The Kigali Amendment, adopted on October 15, 2016, and in force since January 1, 2019, addressed that problem by adding HFC controls to the Montreal framework. It introduced Annex F and Article 2J, with obligations to reduce calculated HFC production and consumption according to differentiated schedules.
For the principal group of non-Article 5 parties, the schedule began with a reduction in 2019. Many Article 5 parties became subject to an initial HFC consumption freeze in 2024, while a separate group has a later starting point. These differences reflect the treaty's established practice of accounting for varying implementation circumstances.
The Kigali system measures relevant HFC quantities in carbon dioxide equivalents, using global warming potentials rather than ozone-depletion potentials. That difference reflects the climate objective of the amendment and prevents the two forms of environmental harm from being treated as scientifically identical.
The 2026 scientific assessment estimates that continued compliance with the Kigali HFC phase-down could avoid up to approximately 0.4°C of additional global warming by 2100. The estimate concerns a projected benefit under the assessment's assumptions, not a temperature reduction already observed (WMO, 2026).
The comparison with the Kyoto Protocol also illustrates a difference in regulatory methods. Kyoto relied on greenhouse-gas commitments within the climate regime, while Kigali employs substance-specific controls and institutions developed through decades of ozone regulation.
The Montreal experience offers lessons for climate cooperation, particularly concerning measurable controls, periodic technical assessment, and assistance for implementation. Those lessons do not eliminate the differences between regulating a limited set of industrial chemicals and transforming economies whose energy, transport, and production systems depend extensively on fossil fuels.
8. Remaining Ozone and Compliance Risks
The recovery of the ozone layer remains dependent on continued controls and effective implementation. The treaty's success in reducing new production and consumption does not eliminate emissions from equipment, foams, stored chemicals, or industrial processes.
Scientific assessments also identify substances and activities that were not central to the original negotiations. Some affect ozone chemistry without falling under the same controls as long-lived CFCs. Others raise questions about emissions accounting, monitoring capacity, and the environmental performance of chemical substitutes.
These issues do not negate the Protocol's achievements. They show why a treaty concerned with long-lived atmospheric substances must continue operating after the principal phaseout deadlines have passed.
8.1 Remaining Ozone Depletion and Unintended Emissions
Existing stocks of ozone-depleting substances remain relevant. Refrigeration equipment, insulation foams, and other products manufactured before phaseout deadlines can retain chemicals that may be released during operation, servicing, disposal, or accidental leakage.
The treatment of feedstocks requires particular care. Under Article 1, quantities entirely used as feedstock in manufacturing other chemicals are excluded from the treaty's definition of production. That legal treatment does not establish that every stage of manufacturing, transport, or use is free from emissions.
The 2026 scientific assessment identifies concerns about emissions associated with feedstock uses and certain chemical by-products. Its findings indicate that these sources can affect atmospheric concentrations even where the relevant quantities are treated differently under production and consumption accounting.
Very short-lived chlorinated substances, including dichloromethane, also contribute to ozone depletion. Their atmospheric behavior differs from that of the long-lived chemicals around which the original control system was constructed. Scientific concern about such substances does not automatically mean that they are already subject to the same treaty restrictions.
Nitrous oxide is another source of pressure on stratospheric ozone. Its significance has increased relative to many controlled ozone-depleting chemicals as the latter have declined. Addressing these emissions raises regulatory questions beyond the original CFC phaseout model.
The ozone regime must consequently distinguish between completing existing obligations and deciding whether additional substances or activities warrant new controls. Scientific evidence can inform such decisions, but it does not itself amend the treaty or create new binding prohibitions.
8.2 HFC-23, Data Gaps, and Monitoring
HFC-23 presents a particular problem for the climate-related operation of the Protocol. It is a potent greenhouse gas that can arise as a by-product of industrial chemical production, notably the manufacture of HCFC-22. The Kigali Amendment introduced obligations relevant to its control and associated reporting.
Article 7 includes a requirement to report facility-level emissions of the relevant Annex F, Group II substance. These data are intended to improve the parties' understanding of emissions that may not be adequately represented by ordinary production and consumption figures.
The Scientific Assessment of Ozone Depletion: 2026 reports that atmospherically inferred HFC-23 emissions exceed reported emissions combined with estimates from other known sources. The discrepancy raises questions about emission pathways, measurement methods, and the completeness of available inventories.
An unexplained difference between reported and atmospherically inferred emissions is not, by itself, proof that a particular party has breached the treaty. Establishing noncompliance requires consideration of the applicable obligation, the reliability of the evidence, and the conduct attributable to the state concerned.
At the Thirty-Eighth Meeting of the Parties, held in Kigali in November 2026, governments considered the HFC-23 discrepancy and agreed on further measures to encourage information sharing and scientific assessment. The meeting did not resolve every question concerning the sources of the emissions.
The parties also considered strengthening atmospheric monitoring in regions where observational coverage remains limited. Improved monitoring can help distinguish regional emission patterns, identify unexpected trends, and test the consistency of reported data against atmospheric evidence.
Reliable observation remains essential because legal compliance and environmental performance cannot be assessed through the same information alone. A production quota may be respected while old equipment continues releasing chemicals; an emissions estimate may identify a problem without establishing its precise legal cause.
The continuing task is to maintain effective controls, improve the quality of reporting, investigate unexplained emissions, and respond to new scientific findings through the treaty's established legal procedures.
Conclusion
The Montreal Protocol worked because governments converted an atmospheric threat into measurable international obligations and repeatedly strengthened those obligations as scientific knowledge and industrial capabilities developed. Its phaseout schedules gave legal force to the objective of ozone protection, while trade controls, differentiated implementation, financial assistance, and cooperative compliance procedures supported the transition away from regulated chemicals.
The evidence of environmental success is substantial. Major controlled ozone-depleting substances have declined in the atmosphere, and scientific assessments identify signs of recovery in the ozone layer. Yet recovery remains gradual, and its projected timing depends on continued compliance, future emissions, and atmospheric conditions.
The treaty's broader significance lies in the relationship between its legal rules and the institutions needed to implement them. Its history shows that international environmental law can achieve measurable results when obligations are technically defined, participation is broad, implementation difficulties are addressed, and scientific evidence continues to inform collective decisions. The unresolved emissions and monitoring problems make clear that this remains an active regulatory system, not a completed episode in diplomatic history.
References
Farman, J.C., Gardiner, B.G. and Shanklin, J.D. (1985) ‘Large losses of total ozone in Antarctica reveal seasonal ClOₓ/NOₓ interaction’, Nature, 315(6016), pp. 207–210. https://doi.org/10.1038/315207a0
Global Environment Facility Evaluation Office (2009) GEF Impact Evaluation of the Phase-Out of Ozone-Depleting Substances in Countries with Economies in Transition. Volume Two: Country Reports. Impact Evaluation Information Document No. 18. Global Environment Facility. Available at: https://www.gefieo.org/content/dam/partners/ieo/docs/mgr/support-docs/ie-td18-ozone-depleting-substances-2010-vol2.pdf (Accessed: 18 November 2026).
Kigali Amendment to the Montreal Protocol on Substances that Deplete the Ozone Layer (2016) Adopted 15 October 2016, entered into force 1 January 2019, subject to the separate entry-into-force provisions concerning Article 4. Available at: https://ozone.unep.org/treaties/montreal-protocol/amendments/kigali-amendment-2016-amendment-montreal-protocol-agreed (Accessed: 18 November 2026).
Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (1997) Adopted 11 December 1997, entered into force 16 February 2005, 2303 UNTS 162. Available at: https://treaties.un.org/pages/showDetails.aspx?objid=0800000280021a16 (Accessed: 18 November 2026).
Molina, M.J. and Rowland, F.S. (1974) ‘Stratospheric sink for chlorofluoromethanes: chlorine atom-catalysed destruction of ozone’, Nature, 249(5460), pp. 810–812. https://doi.org/10.1038/249810a0
Montreal Protocol on Substances that Deplete the Ozone Layer (1987) Adopted 16 September 1987, entered into force 1 January 1989, 1522 UNTS 3. Available at: https://treaties.un.org/pages/showDetails.aspx?objid=080000028003f7f7 (Accessed: 18 November 2026).
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) (2021) ‘Emissions of a banned ozone-depleting gas are back on the decline’ [online]. 12 February. Available at: https://csl.noaa.gov/news/2021/303_0212.html (Accessed: 18 November 2026).
Ozone Secretariat (1990) ‘Decision II/8: Financial mechanism’, Second Meeting of the Parties to the Montreal Protocol [online]. Available at: https://ozone.unep.org/treaties/montreal-protocol/meetings/second-meeting-parties/decisions/decision-ii8-financial-mechanism (Accessed: 18 November 2026).
Ozone Secretariat (1992) ‘Decision IV/5: Non-compliance procedure’, Fourth Meeting of the Parties to the Montreal Protocol [online]. Available at: https://ozone.unep.org/treaties/montreal-protocol/meetings/fourth-meeting-parties/decisions/decision-iv5-non-compliance-procedure (Accessed: 18 November 2026).
Ozone Secretariat (1996) ‘Decision VIII/25: Compliance with the Montreal Protocol by the Russian Federation’, Eighth Meeting of the Parties to the Montreal Protocol [online]. Available at: https://ozone.unep.org/treaties/montreal-protocol/meetings/eighth-meeting-parties/decisions/decision-viii25-compliance-montreal-protocol-russian-federation (Accessed: 18 November 2026).
Ozone Secretariat (1998a) ‘Decision X/10: Review of the non-compliance procedure’, Tenth Meeting of the Parties to the Montreal Protocol [online]. Available at: https://ozone.unep.org/treaties/montreal-protocol/meetings/tenth-meeting-parties/decisions/decision-x10-review-non-compliance-procedure (Accessed: 18 November 2026).
Ozone Secretariat (1998b) ‘Decision X/26: Compliance with the Montreal Protocol by the Russian Federation’, Tenth Meeting of the Parties to the Montreal Protocol [online]. Available at: https://ozone.unep.org/treaties/montreal-protocol/meetings/tenth-meeting-parties/decisions/decision-x26-compliance-montreal-protocol-russian-federation (Accessed: 18 November 2026).
Ozone Secretariat (2026) ‘MOP38 summary’ [online]. 11 November. Available at: https://ozone.unep.org/mop38-summary (Accessed: 18 November 2026).
Ozone Secretariat (n.d.) ‘Annex A – Group I: CFCs’ [online]. Available at: https://ozone.unep.org/treaties/annex-group-i-cfcs (Accessed: 18 November 2026).
Paris Agreement (2015) Adopted 12 December 2015, entered into force 4 November 2016, 3156 UNTS 79. Available at: https://treaties.un.org/pages/showdetails.aspx?clang=_en&objid=0800000280458f37 (Accessed: 18 November 2026).
Parson, E.A. (2003) Protecting the Ozone Layer: Science and Strategy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Vienna Convention for the Protection of the Ozone Layer (1985) Adopted 22 March 1985, entered into force 22 September 1988, 1513 UNTS 293. Available at: https://treaties.un.org/pages/ViewDetails.aspx?chapter=27&clang=_en&mtdsg_no=XXVII-2&src=TREATY (Accessed: 18 November 2026).
Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties (1969) Concluded 23 May 1969, entered into force 27 January 1980, 1155 UNTS 331. Available at: https://treaties.un.org/Pages/showDetails.aspx?objid=080000028003902f (Accessed: 18 November 2026).
World Meteorological Organization (WMO) (2026) Executive Summary. Scientific Assessment of Ozone Depletion: 2026. Global Atmosphere Watch Report No. 327. Geneva: World Meteorological Organization. Available at: https://csl.noaa.gov/assessments/ozone/2026/downloads/executivesummary.pdf (Accessed: 18 November 2026).

