top of page

Five Eyes Alliance: Legal Basis, Members and Intelligence-Sharing Limits

Nov 13
34 min read

Introduction


The Five Eyes alliance is an intelligence-sharing partnership comprising five countries: Australia, Canada, New Zealand, the United Kingdom, and the United States. Its origins lie in British–American intelligence cooperation during the Second World War, formalized through the UKUSA Agreement of March 5, 1946. The partnership enables participating governments to exchange intelligence, coordinate operations, and develop technical capabilities, particularly in signals intelligence. It does not possess independent authority to conduct surveillance outside the laws governing its member states (National Security Agency, 2010; GCHQ, 2021).


Although commonly described as an alliance, Five Eyes differs from organizations established through comprehensive public treaties and permanent governing institutions. It operates through national intelligence agencies, intergovernmental arrangements, shared procedures, and longstanding relationships of trust. Its members retain sovereign control over their intelligence organizations and are not automatically entitled to every piece of information collected by their partners (Intelligence and Security Committee of Parliament, 2023).


The partnership's legal character raises questions about the relationship between international cooperation and national surveillance powers. Intelligence collected by one government may be transferred to another, but the legality of collection does not necessarily establish the legality of subsequent retention, analysis, or disclosure. Domestic legislation, international human rights obligations, and rules concerning state responsibility may restrict particular operations.


Much of the operational relationship remains classified. Declassified historical agreements, national legislation, parliamentary investigations, judicial decisions, and intelligence oversight reports nevertheless provide substantial evidence about its organization and legal limits. Those materials establish both the extensive nature of Five Eyes cooperation and the continuing responsibilities of the governments participating in it.


1. Five Eyes Members and Intelligence Institutions


Five Eyes consists of the United States, the United Kingdom, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand. These five countries cooperate across multiple intelligence disciplines, but their principal signals-intelligence organizations remain central to the partnership. They are the US National Security Agency (NSA), the United Kingdom's Government Communications Headquarters (GCHQ), Canada's Communications Security Establishment (CSE), the Australian Signals Directorate (ASD), and New Zealand's Government Communications Security Bureau (GCSB).


Signals intelligence, abbreviated SIGINT, concerns information obtained from communications and other electronic signals. The five agencies possess different technical capabilities, legal mandates, and national priorities. Their cooperation allows them to exchange intelligence and coordinate activities, but the powers exercised by each organization originate in its national legal system rather than a common Five Eyes surveillance statute (Australian Signals Directorate, 2022).


The wider partnership includes military intelligence, security services, and other governmental institutions. It does not have a publicly established supranational legislature, independent judiciary, or centralized authority empowered to override national legislation. That institutional distinction reflects the difference between interstate cooperation and an organization possessing separate international legal personality. Five Eyes operates through participating states and their agencies, without a publicly established independent legal personality comparable to that of a formal international organization.


1.1 Five Eyes, Nine Eyes and Fourteen Eyes


The expressions Nine Eyes and Fourteen Eyes are frequently used in discussions of intelligence sharing, surveillance, and digital privacy. Nine Eyes conventionally refers to the five original countries together with Denmark, France, the Netherlands, and Norway. Fourteen Eyes adds Belgium, Germany, Italy, Spain, and Sweden. These designations describe wider intelligence relationships, but neither establishes an enlargement of the original five-country membership.


The fourteen-country grouping is commonly associated with SIGINT Seniors Europe, a broader multilateral intelligence cooperation network. Public documentation concerning that network is less comprehensive than the declassified historical record of the UKUSA Agreement. The available material does not establish that every participating state operates under a single treaty conferring identical intelligence access, operational privileges, or reciprocal obligations (Privacy International, 2018).


Intelligence cooperation also occurs through bilateral arrangements and narrower partnerships. A country outside Five Eyes may exchange classified information with one or several members, participate in particular technical projects, or cooperate on counterterrorism without becoming a member. As of November 2026, the publicly established membership of Five Eyes remains Australia, Canada, New Zealand, the United Kingdom, and the United States.


2. The Historical Formation of Five Eyes


Five Eyes emerged from the intelligence requirements of the Second World War. British and American authorities had developed substantial capabilities in communications interception and cryptanalysis, the process of analyzing encrypted communications to recover information. Their wartime relationship involved exchanging technical knowledge, sharing intelligence products, and coordinating work against common adversaries.


The cooperation proved valuable because intercepted information could be incomplete or difficult to interpret without another government's expertise. Military movements, diplomatic communications, communications procedures, and cryptographic systems all required specialized analysis. Joint work allowed the participating authorities to combine information and technical knowledge that neither side could necessarily exploit as effectively in isolation (GCHQ, 2021).


The end of the war did not eliminate the demand for intelligence cooperation. British and American officials negotiated arrangements intended to preserve their communications-intelligence relationship during peacetime. The developing confrontation with the Soviet Union subsequently reinforced the value of sustained intelligence collection and cryptographic capabilities. The resulting relationship expanded to three additional Commonwealth countries and became an enduring feature of Western intelligence cooperation.


2.1 Wartime Cryptanalysis and the BRUSA Agreement


Anglo-American intelligence cooperation intensified during the early 1940s. American intelligence specialists visited Britain's Bletchley Park in 1941, contributing to a relationship centered on cryptanalysis and communications intelligence. Cooperation developed through exchanges of technical information, personnel, and intelligence material, together with procedures for protecting sensitive information (GCHQ, 2021).


Wartime arrangements concluded in 1943 provided a more organized basis for British–American cryptographic collaboration. The name BRUSA became associated with this developing relationship, although historical records and official accounts use the designation in connection with different stages of the wartime and postwar arrangements. The 1943 agreements and the 1946 postwar agreement were distinct developments, rather than a single instrument concluded on two dates.


As the war approached its conclusion, officials considered how intelligence cooperation could continue under peacetime conditions. British representatives traveled to Washington during 1945 to negotiate a durable framework. Agreement on the bilateral structure was reached that November, preparing the way for the formal instrument signed in March 1946 (GCHQ, 2021).


2.2 The 1946 Agreement and Expansion to Five Countries


The British–U.S. Communication Intelligence Agreement was signed on March 5, 1946, by Colonel Patrick Marr-Johnson, representing the London Signals Intelligence Board, and Lieutenant General Hoyt Vandenberg, representing the American State–Army–Navy Communications Intelligence Board. It established a bilateral framework for communications-intelligence cooperation. Australia, Canada, and New Zealand were not original signatories (British–U.S. Communication Intelligence Agreement, 1946).


Canada became more formally integrated during the late 1940s. Official accounts differ over the precise date of entry: the NSA identifies 1948, while GCHQ's historical chronology identifies 1949. Both accounts establish Canada's early participation, but they do not conclusively resolve every intermediate administrative or legal milestone. The discrepancy may reflect differences between arrangements for cooperation and subsequent formal recognition of participation.


Australia and New Zealand joined the developing partnership during the 1950s. The Australian Signals Directorate identifies 1956 as the year in which Australia's government formally accepted the UKUSA Agreement and its predecessor organization, the Defence Signals Branch, joined the partnership. GCHQ likewise associates 1956 with the emergence of the five-country configuration (Australian Signals Directorate, 2022; GCHQ, 2021).


The partnership subsequently adapted to Cold War intelligence requirements and later security challenges. Electronic communications, satellite systems, computing, and telecommunications transformed the technical environment in which the participating agencies operated. The five-country relationship retained its institutional importance even as the methods and subjects of intelligence collection changed.


3. The Legal Basis of the UKUSA Partnership


The legal foundation of Five Eyes must be distinguished from the authority of its individual intelligence agencies. The historical UKUSA Agreement documents a formal relationship between British and American communications-intelligence authorities. Later arrangements extended cooperation to Canada, Australia, and New Zealand. The public record, however, does not contain the complete set of instruments and operational rules governing contemporary exchanges.


This incomplete documentation limits definitive conclusions about the partnership's current legal obligations. Historical commitments concerning information exchange, dissemination, confidentiality, and third-party cooperation can be identified in the original text. The legal status and operative terms of particular later arrangements cannot always be established because relevant instruments remain classified or have not been published.


An agreement between governments can establish binding international commitments without granting national agencies unlimited powers. Intelligence collection, interception, information retention, and disclosure remain subject to applicable domestic legislation. The existence of an international arrangement does not itself establish the statutory authority required for a particular surveillance activity.


3.1 The Original Agreement's Scope and Restrictions


The declassified 1946 agreement contains twelve numbered substantive provisions. Its second paragraph confines the stated subject to communications intelligence while permitting the exchange of relevant collateral material for technical purposes. Paragraphs 3 and 4 concern the exchange of intelligence products, methods, and techniques. The activities covered include traffic collection, traffic analysis, cryptanalysis, decryption, translation, and related technical work (British–U.S. Communication Intelligence Agreement, 1946, paras. 2–4).


The original agreement contemplated extensive exchange between the principal parties, but it also recognized exceptions. Paragraph 3 allowed agreed limitations on the products exchanged, while paragraph 4 permitted certain information about methods and techniques to be withheld where special national interests required it. These provisions demonstrate that even the historical bilateral framework did not impose an unconditional obligation to disclose every intelligence product or technical capability.


Paragraph 5 regulated dealings with third parties. Paragraph 6 expressly distinguished the British Dominions from the original parties and established arrangements for cooperation involving their intelligence organizations. The latter provision is particularly significant because it confirms that the 1946 agreement was not signed by all five present-day members.


Other clauses addressed communications between intelligence organizations, dissemination, security, commercial use, and the relationship with previous agreements. Paragraph 11 provided for amendment and termination. The arrangement thus combined substantial intelligence cooperation with negotiated restrictions on how information could be handled and disclosed.


The original agreement also required secrecy concerning its existence. Historical documents released in 2010 provided a clearer account of the partnership's origins, including arrangements developed between 1940 and 1956. Their declassification did not disclose the complete contemporary legal and operational structure (National Security Agency, 2010; GCHQ, 2021).


3.2 Intergovernmental Commitments and Domestic Authority


The legal classification of an intelligence arrangement depends on its substantive character. An instrument may establish binding commitments under international law, set out administrative procedures between agencies, or record political understandings. Neither its title nor its confidential status is conclusive. An agreement need not be publicly registered or called a treaty to raise questions about legally binding interstate obligations.


The 1969 Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties provides an important framework for distinguishing treaties from other international instruments. Article 2(1)(a) defines a treaty by reference to an international agreement between states, in written form, governed by international law, irrespective of its particular designation. Article 4 limits the Convention's direct temporal application. Its provisions cannot automatically be applied retroactively to the 1946 UKUSA Agreement, although independently applicable customary rules of treaty law may remain relevant (Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, 1969, arts. 2 and 4).


The distinction is consistent with the broader law governing international treaties. A binding international agreement may create obligations between states without supplying every domestic authorization necessary for its performance. Conversely, an arrangement lacking a publicly available treaty text may still involve commitments whose legal character cannot be determined from the published record alone.


Five Eyes has no publicly established central institution empowered to issue surveillance warrants for all five countries. National constitutional arrangements, legislation, and executive powers determine how each government authorizes its agencies. An intelligence-sharing commitment cannot, by itself, displace statutory restrictions on interception, electronic intrusion, or the handling of personal information.


The participating governments also remain subject to their applicable international obligations. Where intelligence activities engage human rights protections or rules concerning assistance in internationally wrongful conduct, the existence of the partnership does not create a general exception. Its international and domestic legal dimensions must be assessed separately, according to the particular obligation and activity involved.


4. How Five Eyes Intelligence Sharing Operates


Five Eyes cooperation extends beyond the exchange of completed intelligence reports. Member agencies may share information at different stages of collection and analysis, coordinate operational requirements, develop technical capabilities, and undertake joint assessments. The degree of cooperation varies according to the agencies involved, the intelligence discipline, the sensitivity of the material, and national security priorities (Intelligence and Security Committee of Parliament, 2023).


The United Kingdom's Intelligence and Security Committee described a close relationship characterized by substantial information exchange and operational trust. That cooperation does not require every member to participate in every activity. Individual governments retain the capacity to act independently, protect nationally sensitive information, and withhold particular intelligence products.


Cooperation among the five countries also takes place beyond the original signals-intelligence arrangements. At the Five Country Ministerial meeting in Sydney on August 25–26, 2026, ministers identified shared priorities including state threats, terrorism, organized crime, and national security technology. That ministerial forum illustrates the breadth of contemporary cooperation among the same governments, although its institutional mandate and legal basis should not be equated with those of the historical UKUSA intelligence partnership (Five Country Ministerial, 2026).


4.1 Signals Intelligence, Metadata and Joint Analysis


Signals intelligence involves obtaining information from intercepted communications or other electronic signals. Communications intelligence may concern the content of messages, their technical characteristics, or information about communications systems. Metadata can identify circumstances surrounding a communication, including its timing, routing, or the identifiers associated with communicating parties, without necessarily revealing the message itself.


These categories have different technical and legal implications. Intercepted content may provide direct evidence about an individual's intentions or activities. Metadata can reveal patterns of contact, organizational relationships, movements, and communications infrastructure. The absence of message content does not make metadata incapable of identifying individuals or revealing sensitive information.


The partnership's analytical arrangements allow national agencies to compare information and develop shared assessments. Participating governments contribute different collection capabilities, language expertise, regional knowledge, and specialist analysis. British parliamentary evidence describes arrangements for dividing certain intelligence tasks and passing continuing analytical work between countries in different time zones (Intelligence and Security Committee of Parliament, 2023).


Some cooperation concerns capabilities rather than individual intelligence reports. Agencies may collaborate on technical systems, cybersecurity, analytical methods, and communications technologies. These activities intersect with the wider legal questions associated with cyber espionage under international law, particularly where intelligence activities involve unauthorized access, cross-border operations, or the interception of communications.


Access to shared capabilities does not necessarily confer unrestricted authority over all information they produce. Intelligence may be subject to classification requirements, national caveats, restrictions on further use, and statutory limits on retention or disclosure. The participating agencies must account for those conditions when incorporating foreign information into their own operations.


4.2 Originator Control and Restrictions on Disclosure


The third-party rule, also known as originator control, is an established feature of intelligence cooperation. Under this principle, an intelligence recipient generally must obtain the originating authority's consent before passing supplied information to another party. Its purpose is to protect sensitive sources and methods while preserving the originating agency's control over subsequent dissemination.


The rule becomes particularly significant when intelligence passes through several organizations. Material supplied by a foreign service may be incorporated into a national intelligence assessment or used to support another security operation. Restrictions imposed by the originating agency can limit whether the information may subsequently be transferred to additional governments or institutions.


Originator control is not equivalent to domestic legal authorization. Permission from an intelligence partner to retain information does not necessarily satisfy national retention requirements. Likewise, consent to onward disclosure cannot override statutory restrictions governing personal information or the transfer of intelligence associated with risks of torture or other serious mistreatment.


The distinction also works in the opposite direction. A national agency may have statutory authority to retain or analyze information while remaining subject to operational restrictions imposed by the originating partner. Compliance requires attention to both sets of conditions. Intelligence-sharing rules and national legislation regulate different aspects of the same activity, and neither can simply be substituted for the other.


5. Domestic Law and the Limits of Intelligence Sharing


The Five Eyes countries maintain distinct legal systems governing intelligence collection, surveillance authorization, and disclosure to foreign governments. Their agencies cooperate closely, but they do not operate under a common surveillance statute. A power available to an American intelligence agency cannot be assumed to exist in Canada or New Zealand, and authorization granted in one country does not automatically confer equivalent authority in another.


These differences become significant when information crosses national borders. Collection, receipt, analysis, retention, and onward disclosure are legally distinct activities. A government may lawfully receive foreign intelligence but face restrictions on identifying individuals mentioned in it, examining its contents, retaining the underlying data, or transferring it to another institution.


The five systems also employ different authorization and supervision procedures. Some intelligence activities require judicial approval, others depend on executive or ministerial authority, and specialized oversight institutions examine compliance. The relevant comparison concerns the powers and safeguards affecting international intelligence exchanges, rather than the assumption that all five governments apply equivalent legal protections.


5.1 United States: FISA and Executive Order 12333


United States foreign-intelligence activities operate under several legal authorities, including the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act of 1978 (FISA), Executive Order 12333, and applicable constitutional requirements. These instruments regulate different categories of intelligence activity. FISA establishes statutory procedures for specified electronic surveillance and related powers, while Executive Order 12333 governs important aspects of foreign-intelligence collection and the responsibilities of intelligence agencies.


Section 2.3 of Executive Order 12333 requires procedures governing the collection, retention, and dissemination of information concerning United States persons. These protections are important when foreign-intelligence activities encounter information about American citizens, lawful permanent residents, or other persons covered by the applicable legal definition. Receipt of information from an international partner does not independently exempt an agency from the procedures governing its subsequent handling (Executive Order 12333, 1981, as amended).


Section 702 of FISA historically permitted the targeting of non-US persons reasonably believed to be outside the United States for specified foreign-intelligence purposes. It operated through programmatic certifications approved by the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court, together with targeting, minimization, and querying procedures. It did not authorize intentionally targeting United States persons, persons known to be located inside the country, or foreign persons as a means of deliberately targeting protected persons indirectly.


The statutory position changed on June 12, 2026, when Title VII of FISA, including Section 702, was automatically repealed under the sunset provisions as extended by Public Law 119-87. Transitional provisions preserved qualifying orders, certifications, and directives until their respective expiration dates (Congressional Research Service, 2026; Public Law 119-87, 2026).


According to congressional statements reported by the Congressional Research Service, the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court approved a one-year Section 702 authorization in March 2026. The underlying classified order was not publicly available at the time of the CRS analysis, although statutory transitional provisions permit qualifying authorizations to remain effective until their expiration (Congressional Research Service, 2026).


The repeal did not eliminate every American foreign-intelligence authority. Executive Order 12333 and other applicable legal provisions remain distinct from Section 702. The legality of a particular operation depends on the authority invoked, the method of collection, the persons affected, and the restrictions governing subsequent use. Five Eyes participation does not independently supply a statutory basis for surveillance.


The Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court provides specialized judicial supervision within its statutory jurisdiction. The Department of Justice, the Office of the Director of National Intelligence, congressional committees, and agency compliance institutions perform additional oversight functions. Their respective powers differ, and none serves as a centralized international court governing Five Eyes.


5.2 United Kingdom: Interception and Overseas Disclosure


British intelligence operations are regulated through legislation including the Intelligence Services Act 1994 and the Investigatory Powers Act 2016, as amended. The former establishes important aspects of GCHQ's statutory functions, while the latter governs specified interception, equipment interference, and other investigatory powers. Different activities are subject to different authorization procedures and safeguards.


The Investigatory Powers Act distinguishes targeted interception, bulk interception, and equipment interference. It also establishes requirements concerning the examination, retention, and disclosure of material obtained under relevant warrants. These safeguards are important where intelligence gathered by British authorities may subsequently be supplied to foreign services.


Section 130 governs overseas disclosure of material obtained under targeted equipment-interference warrants. It requires arrangements ensuring that relevant safeguards apply when material or copies are transferred to overseas authorities. Section 151 establishes separate requirements concerning overseas disclosure of material obtained under bulk-interception warrants, including safeguards connected with retention, disclosure, and certain uses in foreign proceedings (Investigatory Powers Act, 2016, ss. 130 and 151).


The provisions demonstrate that permission to exchange intelligence is not unrestricted. Their requirements differ according to the warrant and the material involved. The statutory arrangements also distinguish intelligence collected by British authorities from information requested or received from foreign services under other applicable powers and procedures.


Independent supervision forms part of the British system. The Investigatory Powers Commissioner oversees specified investigatory powers and associated safeguards, while the Investigatory Powers Tribunal considers proceedings and complaints within its statutory jurisdiction. Parliamentary scrutiny is exercised through the Intelligence and Security Committee, whose 2023 report examined the operational benefits and legal risks of international intelligence partnerships.


The present framework must be distinguished from earlier surveillance arrangements. The European Court of Human Rights' judgment in Big Brother Watch and Others v. the United Kingdom examined historical regimes operating principally under the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000. Its conclusions remain important for interpreting Convention safeguards, but they were not a comprehensive judicial assessment of every provision of the later Investigatory Powers Act.


5.3 Canada: Foreign Intelligence and Privacy Protection


Canada's Communications Security Establishment Act, enacted in 2019, governs CSE's intelligence and cybersecurity functions. It distinguishes foreign intelligence, cybersecurity and information assurance, defensive cyber operations, active cyber operations, and assistance to federal partners. These functions are subject to different statutory conditions and authorization requirements.


Section 22(1) prohibits CSE activities undertaken under the specified intelligence and cyber mandates from being directed at Canadians or persons in Canada. It also requires those activities not to infringe the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. This restriction does not prohibit every incidental acquisition of information concerning a protected person during an otherwise authorized operation (Communications Security Establishment Act, 2019, s. 22).


Section 22(3) addresses a different question. Activities undertaken under CSE's foreign-intelligence mandate must not contravene another Act of Parliament or interfere with a protected reasonable expectation of privacy through specified acquisition from the global information infrastructure unless carried out under an authorization issued pursuant to Section 26(1) or 40(1). The distinction is significant: authorization under Section 22(3) does not simply eliminate the separate restriction against directing foreign-intelligence activities at Canadians.


Canada also regulates the treatment of information acquired through intelligence operations. The handling of identifying information, retention, disclosure, and assistance to domestic authorities may engage different statutory provisions. The legal treatment of information received from a foreign partner depends on the relevant mandate and the purpose for which the receiving agency uses it.


Foreign cooperation raises additional concerns where intelligence may contribute to mistreatment. Canada's Avoiding Complicity in Mistreatment by Foreign Entities Act and related ministerial directions address the disclosure, requesting, and use of information where risks of torture or other serious mistreatment arise. These protections operate alongside the legislation governing CSE's intelligence functions.


CSE is subject to independent review by the National Security and Intelligence Review Agency. The Intelligence Commissioner performs separate statutory oversight functions involving specified authorizations and determinations. Their mandates differ, but both contribute to the national accountability system within which Canada's international intelligence cooperation operates.


5.4 Australia: Foreign Cooperation and Statutory Safeguards


Australia's Intelligence Services Act 2001 establishes statutory functions and restrictions for several intelligence agencies, including the Australian Signals Directorate. The Act regulates the performance of intelligence functions and cooperation with other organizations. Its provisions distinguish the authority to undertake an agency's own activities from the authority to assist another institution.


Section 12 generally limits activities undertaken by relevant agencies to those necessary for the proper performance of their functions or otherwise authorized or required by law. Section 13 establishes arrangements for cooperation with other authorities. Under Section 13(1)(c), cooperation with specified foreign authorities ordinarily depends on approval by the responsible minister, subject to the Act's other provisions (Intelligence Services Act, 2001, ss. 12–13).


An important exception applies specifically to ASD. Section 13(4) permits cooperation with foreign authorities capable of assisting ASD in performing its function under Section 7(1)(ca), notwithstanding the general approval requirement in Section 13(1)(c). That function concerns advice, material, and assistance relating to the security and integrity of electronically processed, stored, or communicated information.


The exception is limited. It remains subject to arrangements made or directions given by the responsible minister and does not dispense with the agency's other statutory obligations. Section 13(5) also requires the Director-General of ASD to report significant cooperation undertaken under the exception to the responsible minister and the Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security after each relevant reporting year (Intelligence Services Act, 2001, ss. 7 and 13).


Other provisions regulate activities concerning Australian persons and the handling of intelligence information. Depending on the conduct involved, ministerial authorization and privacy rules may apply. The legality of acquiring information incidentally can differ from the requirements governing an operation intentionally directed at an Australian person.


Australia's Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security provides independent oversight of intelligence agencies within the office's statutory jurisdiction. The Inspector-General examines legality and propriety, investigates complaints, and undertakes inspections and inquiries. This supervision is distinct from the executive authorization of intelligence activities and from the operational controls maintained within individual agencies.


5.5 New Zealand: Warrants and Foreign-Agency Cooperation


New Zealand's Intelligence and Security Act 2017 governs its principal intelligence agencies, including GCSB and the New Zealand Security Intelligence Service. It establishes statutory functions, authorization procedures, and safeguards governing intelligence activities. The legislation also addresses cooperation with foreign governments and other entities.


Part 4 provides for intelligence warrants authorizing specified activities that would otherwise be unlawful. These can include interception, surveillance, searches, and particular activities carried out through foreign partners. Section 67 expressly encompasses requests to a foreign government or other entity to undertake activity that would otherwise be unlawful if performed by the New Zealand intelligence agency itself (Intelligence and Security Act, 2017, s. 67).


The legislation consequently recognizes that foreign requests can require domestic authorization. A New Zealand agency cannot avoid the warranting process merely by asking another government to perform an activity that the agency could not lawfully undertake without authorization. Where a warrant is available, its terms govern the specified activity; the existence of a warrant does not confer unlimited authority over unrelated conduct by a foreign service.


New Zealand's intelligence framework also requires attention to the government's intelligence priorities, applicable human rights protections, and the conditions governing international cooperation. Ministerial policy statements and agency procedures supplement the legislation. Foreign liaison arrangements cannot independently displace the statutory requirements applicable to New Zealand agencies.


The Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security provides independent oversight of GCSB and the New Zealand Security Intelligence Service. Its jurisdiction includes inquiries into legality and propriety and the examination of intelligence activities. Investigations concerning foreign-controlled systems have demonstrated that national authorities must be able to understand and supervise capabilities operated with the assistance of international partners.


6. Can Five Eyes Circumvent National Surveillance Laws?


The possibility of using foreign intelligence partners to avoid domestic surveillance restrictions is one of the most significant legal questions surrounding Five Eyes. The concern arises because the participating countries possess different collection powers and legal protections. An intelligence service might receive information from another government that it could not collect using the same methods under its own legislation.


That possibility does not establish that every transfer of foreign intelligence constitutes unlawful circumvention. Intelligence services may independently collect information within their lawful mandates and subsequently share it with partners. Receiving independently acquired intelligence differs from deliberately directing a foreign agency to conduct surveillance that the requesting service is prohibited from performing.


The distinction depends on the conduct and the applicable legal framework. A foreign request, knowledge of the intended target, direction of collection, participation in planning, and subsequent use of the information may all affect the legal assessment. The United Kingdom's Intelligence and Security Committee recorded restrictions against asking Five Eyes partners to evade national targeting requirements or undertake activities intended to circumvent applicable legal and policy obligations (Intelligence and Security Committee of Parliament, 2023, para. 214).


Legal controls also apply after collection. Information lawfully obtained by a foreign agency may remain subject to domestic restrictions when received, analyzed, retained, or disseminated by another government. Those obligations are particularly important for the protection of privacy and digital rights in cross-border surveillance. The relevant question is not simply which agency first acquired the intelligence, but what each participating authority subsequently did with it and under which legal powers.


6.1 The Understanding Against Spying on Member Citizens


Five Eyes cooperation includes a longstanding understanding concerning intelligence activities directed at other members' citizens. Canada's National Security and Intelligence Review Agency described an unwritten agreement under which members generally refrain from directing signals-intelligence activities at one another's citizens. The understanding reflects the trust underlying the relationship, but the Canadian review did not describe it as an absolute prohibition without exceptions.


The review recognized exceptional circumstances involving urgent threats. Where foreign signals-intelligence partners produce reporting derived from directly targeting Canadians, the resulting material may enter an exceptional reporting process involving Canadian authorities. The existence of that procedure demonstrates that the general understanding against such targeting has recognized exceptions (NSIRA, Review of Operational Collaboration between CSE and CSIS, 2026).


The United Kingdom's Intelligence and Security Committee recorded a related position concerning intelligence activity directed at Five Eyes partners. It also identified restrictions against requesting operations that would evade national legal requirements. These are related but distinct subjects: intelligence activity against allied governments, surveillance involving allied citizens, and deliberate attempts to bypass domestic authorization requirements.


The public record does not establish an absolute treaty-based rule prohibiting every instance of intelligence collection concerning another member's citizens. Nor does it support the opposite conclusion that such activity is generally unrestricted. Incidental acquisition, exceptional targeting, and circumvention of national law require separate legal assessment. The Canadian findings provide a concrete example of why an operational understanding among partners cannot substitute for the legal authority governing subsequent use of intelligence.


7. International Human Rights and State Responsibility


International intelligence cooperation operates within a legal order that includes human rights obligations and rules concerning responsibility for internationally wrongful conduct. Surveillance may interfere with privacy, correspondence, and other protected interests. Sharing intelligence may also raise questions about the consequences of assisting another government in conduct prohibited by international law.


Article 17 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights prohibits arbitrary or unlawful interference with privacy, family, home, and correspondence. All five Five Eyes countries are parties to the Covenant. Its application to particular intelligence activities requires consideration of the relevant jurisdictional scope, the nature of the interference, and the obligations binding the state concerned (International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, 1966, art. 17).


The United Kingdom is additionally bound by the European Convention on Human Rights. Article 8 protects private and family life, the home, and correspondence, subject to the conditions established by the Convention. The European Court of Human Rights has developed extensive jurisprudence concerning secret surveillance, authorization procedures, independent supervision, and safeguards against abuse.


International human rights law does not necessarily prohibit intelligence interception merely because it is covert or undertaken for national security purposes. The legal assessment concerns the authority for the interference, its justification, the safeguards governing the activity, and the applicable jurisdictional requirements. Questions of extraterritorial application are especially significant where intelligence is collected abroad or information concerning individuals outside a state's territory is examined by domestic authorities.


The standards developed under the European Convention should not automatically be treated as identical to the obligations of Australia, Canada, New Zealand, or the United States under their respective legal systems. The same intelligence activity may engage several overlapping legal regimes, each with its own jurisdictional conditions and supervisory institutions.


7.1 Big Brother Watch and Foreign Intelligence Requests


The European Court of Human Rights addressed foreign intelligence sharing in its Grand Chamber judgment in Big Brother Watch and Others v. the United Kingdom, delivered on May 25, 2021. The applications concerned historical British surveillance regimes involving bulk interception, communications-data acquisition, and the requesting and receipt of intercepted material from foreign intelligence services.


The Court found violations of Article 8 concerning the historical bulk-interception and communications-data regimes. The deficiencies in bulk interception included insufficiently independent authorization, the absence of adequate requirements concerning categories of selectors used to search intercepted communications, and inadequate prior authorization for selectors associated with identifiable individuals. The Court emphasized the need for safeguards throughout the interception process (ECtHR, 2021).


The Court reached a different conclusion regarding the particular foreign-intelligence receipt regime before it. By twelve votes to five, the Grand Chamber found no violation of Article 8. The majority considered that the relevant British arrangements contained sufficiently accessible rules and safeguards governing the requesting, receipt, examination, retention, and disclosure of the material concerned.


The scope of that conclusion was limited. The Grand Chamber examined the regime governing solicited intercept material received from the NSA, rather than every category of intelligence that British agencies might obtain from foreign governments. It did not determine the legality of all unsolicited intelligence, non-intercept material, or the complete range of contemporary Five Eyes exchanges (ECtHR, 2021, paras. 459–462).


The majority distinguished the safeguards applicable when intelligence was requested from those governing its subsequent treatment. It considered the restrictions against using foreign requests to circumvent domestic law and the supervision of material received from foreign services. The Court concluded that the particular regime satisfied Article 8, while recognizing the importance of adequate legal controls (ECtHR, 2021, paras. 497–514).


Five judges dissented from the conclusion concerning foreign-intelligence receipt. Their concerns included the absence of sufficiently independent authorization for certain requests and the adequacy of safeguards against interference with privacy. The disagreement concerned the degree of protection required under the Convention, rather than whether intelligence cooperation was inherently prohibited.


The Grand Chamber also examined Article 10, which protects freedom of expression, including interests associated with confidential journalistic material. It found violations concerning the historical bulk-interception and communications-data regimes, but no Article 10 violation in respect of the foreign-intelligence receipt regime. These findings illustrate why the legal assessment must distinguish the type of surveillance, the material concerned, and the safeguards applying at each stage.


The judgment does not establish that all bulk interception violates the Convention or that every foreign-intelligence exchange is lawful. The Court accepted that bulk-interception systems are not inherently incompatible with the Convention, provided sufficiently protective safeguards apply. Its reasoning supplies important legal standards for assessing intelligence cooperation, but it was not a judicial determination of the Five Eyes partnership as a whole.


7.2 International Responsibility for Unlawful Assistance


Intelligence sharing may engage the international law of state responsibility where assistance provided by one government contributes to another government's internationally wrongful conduct. The relevant inquiry differs from ordinary questions about domestic surveillance authorization. It concerns whether a state has knowingly assisted conduct that violates an international obligation and whether the conditions for responsibility are established.


Article 16 of the International Law Commission's Articles on Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts addresses aid or assistance given by one state in the commission of an internationally wrongful act by another. Its text requires knowledge of the circumstances of the wrongful act and that the act would also be internationally wrongful if committed by the assisting state (ILC, 2001, art. 16).


The Commission's commentary explains that the assistance must be given with a view to facilitating the wrongful conduct and must actually contribute to it. The commentary distinguishes knowledge of relevant circumstances from assistance that happens to be used unlawfully without the assisting state's awareness. It also states that the contribution need not be indispensable, although it must be sufficiently connected to the wrongful act (ILC, 2001, commentary to Article 16, paras. 3–6).


The interpretation of Article 16 nevertheless raises questions concerning the relationship between knowledge, purpose, and intention. The United Kingdom's Intelligence and Security Committee recorded the British government's understanding that Article 16 reflects customary international law and that responsibility requires material assistance accompanied by knowledge and intent. That position is relevant to British intelligence partnerships but should be distinguished from interpretations advanced by other states and legal scholars (Intelligence and Security Committee of Parliament, 2023, para. 102).


The ILC Articles are not themselves a treaty. Their individual provisions must be assessed according to their relationship with customary international law and other applicable obligations. The conditions governing state responsibility in international law also differ from the requirements for imposing criminal responsibility on individual officials.


Intelligence assistance could become relevant where information supports an unlawful detention, torture, or military operation prohibited by international law. The assessment depends on the primary obligation breached, the circumstances known to the assisting state, the purpose and contribution of the assistance, and whether the wrongful conduct occurred. Ordinary intelligence cooperation does not automatically satisfy those requirements.


These distinctions preserve the difference between assistance provided for a legitimate security purpose and participation in another state's internationally wrongful conduct. Five Eyes membership does not itself establish responsibility, but neither does it provide immunity where the requirements of an applicable international legal rule are satisfied.


8. Oversight, Compliance and Intelligence Secrecy


The extensive integration of intelligence activities creates challenges for national oversight. Each government retains responsibility for its own agencies, while intelligence may originate abroad, pass through shared technical systems, or be used in operations involving several jurisdictions. Supervisory institutions may possess substantial authority over domestic organizations but lack equivalent access to foreign systems and operational records.


Effective oversight depends on reliable documentation, access to relevant information, and clear allocation of authority. Legal supervision can be weakened when an agency cannot establish who authorized an activity, which organization controlled the relevant system, or how intelligence was subsequently used. Classification may protect sensitive capabilities, but it can also restrict the information available to courts, legislatures, and the public.


Official investigations in Canada and New Zealand provide concrete examples of these difficulties. Their findings concern particular agencies, practices, and historical periods rather than a determination that Five Eyes as a whole operated unlawfully. They demonstrate how compliance problems can arise within closely integrated intelligence systems, even where longstanding arrangements for cooperation already exist.


8.1 Canadian Findings on Intelligence Sharing and Retention


On March 2, 2026, Canada's National Security and Intelligence Review Agency published its Review of Operational Collaboration between the Communications Security Establishment and the Canadian Security Intelligence Service. The investigation principally examined activities between January 2016 and September 2021. It considered how two Canadian agencies with different statutory mandates cooperated in intelligence operations and information sharing.


The distinction between their legal powers was central to the investigation. CSIS may collect certain information about Canadians in the performance of its national security mandate, subject to applicable law. CSE's foreign-intelligence mandate, by contrast, is subject to a prohibition against directing its relevant activities at Canadians or persons in Canada. Cooperation between the agencies can create compliance risks when information collected or supplied under one mandate is subsequently used under another (NSIRA, 2026).


The review examined an exceptional reporting arrangement through which foreign signals-intelligence partners supplied reports derived from directly targeting Canadians. CSE acted as a conduit for the delivery of those reports to CSIS. Under a subsequent process, CSIS could disclose information back to CSE for foreign-intelligence purposes.


NSIRA found that CSE had used complete exceptional reports in circumstances that contravened the applicable restrictions on directing intelligence activities at Canadians. The agency's receipt and use of entire reports went beyond the foreign-intelligence information that CSE was authorized to exploit. NSIRA recommended that CSIS extract the relevant foreign intelligence before disclosure and that CSE cease using complete exceptional reports under its foreign-intelligence mandate (NSIRA, Review of Operational Collaboration between CSE and CSIS, 2026, Finding 14).


The review also identified problems involving lead information supplied by CSIS and controls intended to prevent subsequent targeting of protected Canadian identifiers. In one case, NSIRA found that CSE had unlawfully analyzed information concerning a Canadian device. It recommended clearer policies and stronger procedures to address the risk of reverse targeting.


These findings concern the actions of Canadian agencies and the handling of information received through foreign cooperation. They do not establish that every foreign intelligence operation underlying the reports was unlawful. Their significance lies in demonstrating that information obtained from partners may still be subject to restrictions on its subsequent use under Canadian law.


Separate findings released in September 2026 concerned CSE's retention of signals-intelligence data. The underlying review covered October 2020 through April 2024. NSIRA examined retention policies, technical systems, and information stored under CSE's foreign-intelligence authorities.


The review identified instances in which CSE retained non-Canadian information after determining that it lacked foreign-intelligence value. NSIRA concluded that these practices might not comply with conditions of the applicable ministerial authorization and could result in information being retained longer than reasonably necessary. It issued a non-compliance report concerning the potential legal breach (NSIRA, Review of CSE's Signals Intelligence Data Retention, 2026).


Other concerns involved information stored outside principal systems, continued targeting of selectors that no longer had intelligence value, and the application of retention requirements to information shared with other agencies, including Five Eyes partners. The findings demonstrate that legal compliance requires effective controls after intelligence has been collected and exchanged.


A further technical assurance review released in September 2026 examined CSE's response to requests to delete information received from international partners. NSIRA confirmed that selected information had been deleted by the time of its assessment. However, it identified weaknesses in automated deletion and records needed to determine precisely when particular material had been removed.


The review assigned a medium assurance rating to the effectiveness of the deletion process. It also recognized limitations affecting direct technical verification of the timing of deletion. These findings concerned the reliability of deletion controls rather than establishing that every relevant item remained unlawfully retained (NSIRA, Technical Assurance Review of a Specific CSE Activity, 2026).


The Canadian investigations demonstrate several distinct compliance problems. The first involved unlawful use of information about Canadians, the second raised concerns about possible unlawful retention, and the third identified weaknesses in technical deletion assurance. Treating them as separate findings preserves their legal significance without suggesting a single alliance-wide determination of misconduct.


8.2 New Zealand's Foreign-Controlled Intelligence System


On March 21, 2024, New Zealand's Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security published an investigation into GCSB's hosting of a signals-intelligence capability deployed by a foreign partner. GCSB agreed in principle to host the system in 2010, signed a formal arrangement in 2012, and supported its operation from 2013 until 2020.


The system formed part of a wider intelligence program involving a foreign agency. GCSB identified the capability during an internal audit in 2020 and referred the matter for independent investigation. The Inspector-General examined the original decision to host the capability and the adequacy of its subsequent administration (Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security, 2024).


The investigation identified serious deficiencies in ministerial awareness and institutional governance. GCSB had considered informing its responsible minister about the proposed arrangement, but the Inspector-General found no evidence that the minister was actually notified. The decision was significant because the capability could potentially support foreign military operations.


The legal conclusion requires careful distinction. The Inspector-General found that an existing ministerial authorization from 2012 was sufficiently broad to cover the capability and that the decision to host it without additional approval was lawful under the arrangements then applicable. Nevertheless, the decision was improper because GCSB failed to bring a significant intelligence arrangement to the minister's attention and thereby failed to respect and enable effective ministerial control (Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security, 2024, findings 5.4–5.7).


Separate failures affected the system's operation. GCSB lacked adequate records, did not properly scrutinize tasking requests, and had insufficient visibility over how the capability was used. Staff lacked adequate guidance and support, while senior management awareness remained negligible during much of the system's operational life.


The investigation also considered the possibility that the capability could contribute to military targeting. The Inspector-General found that geographical restrictions on GCSB collection substantially reduced this risk. Nevertheless, inadequate operational visibility meant that GCSB could not be confident that all tasking complied with government intelligence requirements and New Zealand law.


The report did not establish that the capability had been used in a particular unlawful military attack. Nor did it publicly identify the foreign agency responsible for controlling the system. The nationality of that agency and the complete operational details remained classified.


The Inspector-General distinguished the original governance failure from the continuing deficiencies in operational administration. The initial decision reflected inadequate ministerial involvement, while subsequent operation exposed weaknesses in records, supervision, and institutional awareness. Both were significant, but they concerned different responsibilities.


GCSB accepted the Inspector-General's recommendations. The investigation also recognized substantial changes in New Zealand's intelligence legislation, governance, and compliance systems since the capability began operating. These developments reduced the likelihood of similar failures recurring, although they could not eliminate the need for effective supervision of foreign-controlled systems.


The case demonstrates a particular institutional risk within international intelligence cooperation. A national agency may host or support a capability controlled by a foreign partner while lacking sufficient information to supervise its operation. Even where the original arrangement is legally authorized, inadequate executive control and operational governance can compromise accountability.


8.3 Classified Arrangements and Public Accountability


The secrecy surrounding Five Eyes has historically restricted independent examination of its operations. For decades, the UKUSA arrangements remained outside ordinary public scrutiny. The release of historical documentation in 2010 provided a clearer understanding of the partnership's origins, but important contemporary operational arrangements remain classified.


The historical ECHELON controversy illustrates the difficulties of evaluating international surveillance systems through incomplete public information. Investigations by European parliamentary institutions examined allegations concerning communications interception and capabilities attributed to cooperating intelligence agencies. These inquiries contributed to debate about privacy, commercial intelligence, and the oversight of transnational surveillance.


Those historical investigations cannot establish the precise architecture or legality of every contemporary Five Eyes capability. Intelligence technology, legislation, institutional arrangements, and oversight procedures have changed considerably. Claims concerning current operations require evidence concerning the relevant period and agencies rather than reliance on historical allegations alone.


Secrecy also complicates responsibility where operations involve several jurisdictions. Intelligence may be requested by one agency, collected by another, processed through foreign infrastructure, and subsequently incorporated into reports distributed among multiple governments. Determining whether each participant acted within its lawful authority may require records that are unavailable to the public and sometimes inaccessible to foreign oversight institutions.


National supervision partly addresses these difficulties. The United Kingdom's Intelligence and Security Committee, Canada's NSIRA, and the inspectors-general operating in Australia and New Zealand provide different forms of independent or parliamentary scrutiny. Their mandates, powers of access, procedures, and reporting obligations are not identical.


The distinctions between oversight institutions are important. A court issuing a surveillance warrant performs a different function from a parliamentary committee examining intelligence policy. An administrative review body may investigate compliance retrospectively, while a specialist tribunal may adjudicate complaints and provide remedies within its jurisdiction. None of these bodies possesses general authority to regulate all five intelligence communities as a single international institution.


The British Intelligence and Security Committee's 2023 investigation demonstrates both the operational importance of intelligence partnerships and the limits of public disclosure. Its report examined information sharing, legal safeguards, cooperation with foreign services, and the potential consequences of assistance provided to partners. Parts of the published document remained redacted to protect national security interests.


Classification may be justified where disclosure would reveal intelligence sources, technical methods, personnel, or ongoing operations. It does not itself establish that secret activities are lawful. Equally, the absence of public information cannot be treated as evidence of unlawful conduct.


The central accountability problem concerns the ability of national institutions to supervise activities conducted through an integrated international relationship. Effective legal control requires that governments understand the operations authorized in their name, that intelligence agencies maintain adequate records, and that supervisory bodies possess meaningful access to the information necessary to assess compliance.


Conclusion


Five Eyes is an enduring intelligence-sharing partnership between Australia, Canada, New Zealand, the United Kingdom, and the United States. Its historical foundation lies in the UKUSA Agreement of 1946, which developed into a broader system of cooperation involving signals intelligence, technical capabilities, analytical expertise, and national security operations. The partnership facilitates extensive collaboration while preserving the separate governmental and legal authority of its members.


Its legal limits arise from national statutes, executive authorization procedures, applicable international human rights obligations, and rules concerning responsibility for internationally wrongful conduct. Intelligence obtained from a foreign partner does not automatically become lawful to retain, analyze, or disclose. The European Court of Human Rights' judgment in Big Brother Watch and subsequent Canadian and New Zealand oversight investigations demonstrate both the existence of legal safeguards and the difficulties of enforcing them within classified intelligence relationships.


The integration of intelligence capabilities across national boundaries creates an institutional problem that cannot be resolved solely through cooperation agreements. Information may circulate among agencies operating under different legal powers, while responsibility for authorization, retention, and disclosure remains distributed among national institutions. The effectiveness of legal protection depends on each government's capacity to supervise its own agencies, including activities undertaken with foreign partners.


Important aspects of contemporary Five Eyes cooperation remain beyond independent public examination. That limitation prevents definitive conclusions about every operational arrangement. The available legal record nevertheless establishes that the partnership does not create unrestricted surveillance authority or remove the national and international obligations of its members. Intelligence cooperation may be extensive, but legal responsibility remains attached to the governments and agencies exercising the relevant powers.


References


Australian Signals Directorate (2022) 'Intelligence partnerships' [online]. Available at: https://www.asd.gov.au/about/history/asd-stories/2022-03-16-intelligence-partnerships (Accessed: 12 November 2026).


Avoiding Complicity in Mistreatment by Foreign Entities Act (2019) Statutes of Canada 2019, c. 13, s. 49.1. Available at: https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/A-18.8/ (Accessed: 12 November 2026).


British–U.S. Communication Intelligence Agreement (1946) Signed 5 March 1946. The National Archives, HW 80/4. Declassified in 2010. Available at: https://www.nsa.gov/Helpful-Links/NSA-FOIA/Declassification-Transparency-Initiatives/Historical-Releases/UKUSA/ (Accessed: 12 November 2026).


Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms (1982) Part I of the Constitution Act, 1982, Schedule B to the Canada Act 1982 (UK), c. 11. In force 17 April 1982. Available at: https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/Const/FullText.html (Accessed: 12 November 2026).


Communications Security Establishment Act (2019) Statutes of Canada 2019, c. 13, s. 76. Available at: https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/C-35.3/ (Accessed: 12 November 2026).


Congressional Research Service (2026) The Impact of FISA Section 702's Repeal. Legal Sidebar LSB11444, 22 June 2026. Washington, DC: Congressional Research Service. Available at: https://www.everycrsreport.com/reports/LSB11444.html (Accessed: 12 November 2026).


Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (1950) Adopted 4 November 1950, entered into force 3 September 1953, European Treaty Series No. 5. Available at: https://www.coe.int/en/web/conventions/full-list2?module=treaty-detail&treatynum=005 (Accessed: 12 November 2026).


European Court of Human Rights (2021) Big Brother Watch and Others v. the United Kingdom, Grand Chamber judgment, 25 May 2021, Applications Nos. 58170/13, 62322/14 and 24960/15. Available at: https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng?i=001-210077 (Accessed: 12 November 2026).


Executive Order 12333: United States Intelligence Activities (1981) Signed 4 December 1981, 46 Federal Register 59941, 8 December 1981, as amended by Executive Orders 13284, 13355 and 13470. Available at: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CPRT-111HPRT56961/pdf/CPRT-111HPRT56961.pdf (Accessed: 12 November 2026).


Five Country Ministerial (2026) Five Country Ministerial Communiqué 2026. Sydney, Australia, 26 August 2026. Published 28 August 2026. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/five-country-ministerial-communique-2026/five-country-ministerial-communique-2026 (Accessed: 12 November 2026).


Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act of 1978 (1978) Public Law 95-511, 25 October 1978, 92 Stat. 1783, as amended. Available at: https://www.intelligence.senate.gov/1978/10/25/laws-foreign-intelligence-surveillance-act-1978-originally-enacted/ (Accessed: 12 November 2026).


Government Communications Headquarters (2021) 'A brief history of the UKUSA agreement' [online]. Published 5 March 2021. Available at: https://www.gchq.gov.uk/information/brief-history-of-ukusa (Accessed: 12 November 2026).


Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security (2024) Inquiry into GCSB's Hosting of a Foreign Capability. Wellington: Office of the Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security, 21 March 2024. Available at: https://igis.govt.nz/assets/Uploads/FINAL-Inquiry-into-GCSBs-hosting-of-a-foreign-capability.pdf (Accessed: 12 November 2026).


Intelligence and Security Act 2017 (New Zealand) (2017) Public Act 2017 No. 10, received Royal Assent 28 March 2017, as amended. Available at: https://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/2017/10/en/latest/ (Accessed: 12 November 2026).


Intelligence and Security Committee of Parliament (2023) International Partnerships. HC 288, 5 December 2023. London: House of Commons. Available at: https://isc.independent.gov.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/ISC-International-Partnerships.pdf (Accessed: 12 November 2026).


Intelligence Services Act 1994 (United Kingdom) (1994) 1994 c. 13, received Royal Assent 26 May 1994, as amended. Available at: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1994/13/contents (Accessed: 12 November 2026).


Intelligence Services Act 2001 (Australia) (2001) Act No. 152 of 2001, as amended. Compilation No. 54, 27 August 2026. Available at: https://www.legislation.gov.au/C2004A00928/2026-08-27 (Accessed: 12 November 2026).


International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (1966) Adopted 16 December 1966, entered into force 23 March 1976, 999 UNTS 171. Available at: https://treaties-prod.un.org/Pages/ViewDetails.aspx?chapter=4&clang=_en&mtdsg_no=IV-4&src=TREATY (Accessed: 12 November 2026).


International Law Commission (2001) Draft Articles on Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts, with Commentaries. UN Doc. A/56/10, Chapter IV. Yearbook of the International Law Commission, 2001, Vol. II, Part Two. Available at: https://legal.un.org/ilc/texts/instruments/english/commentaries/9_6_2001.pdf (Accessed: 12 November 2026).


Investigatory Powers Act 2016 (United Kingdom) (2016) 2016 c. 25, received Royal Assent 29 November 2016, as amended. Available at: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2016/25/contents (Accessed: 12 November 2026).


National Security Agency (2010) 'Declassified UKUSA Signals Intelligence Agreement Documents Available' [online]. Press release, 24 June 2010. Available at: https://www.nsa.gov/Press-Room/Press-Releases-Statements/Press-Release-View/Article/1629812/declassified-ukusa-signals-intelligence-agreement-documents-available/ (Accessed: 12 November 2026).


National Security and Intelligence Review Agency (2026a) Review of Operational Collaboration between the Communications Security Establishment (CSE) and the Canadian Security Intelligence Service (CSIS): Report. Review No. 21-16, published 2 March 2026. Ottawa: National Security and Intelligence Review Agency. Available at: https://nsira-ossnr.gc.ca/en/reviews/find-a-review/21-16/report/ (Accessed: 12 November 2026).


National Security and Intelligence Review Agency (2026b) Communications Security Establishment's Signals Intelligence Data Retention (2023): Backgrounder. Review No. 23-14, published 3 September 2026. Ottawa: National Security and Intelligence Review Agency. Available at: https://nsira-ossnr.gc.ca/en/reviews/find-a-review/23-14/backgrounder/ (Accessed: 12 November 2026).


National Security and Intelligence Review Agency (2026c) Technical Assurance Review of a Specific Communications Security Establishment Activity: Backgrounder. Review No. 25-11, published 10 September 2026. Ottawa: National Security and Intelligence Review Agency. Available at: https://nsira-ossnr.gc.ca/en/reviews/find-a-review/25-11/backgrounder/ (Accessed: 12 November 2026).


Privacy International (2018) Secret Global Surveillance Networks: Intelligence Sharing Between Governments and the Need for Safeguards. London: Privacy International. Available at: https://privacyinternational.org/sites/default/files/2018-04/Secret%20Global%20Surveillance%20Networks%20report%20web%20%28200%29.pdf (Accessed: 12 November 2026).


Public Law 119-87 (2026) An Act to Amend the FISA Amendments Act of 2008 to Extend the Authorities of Title VII of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act of 1978, and for Other Purposes. Approved 30 April 2026, 140 Stat. 811. Available at: https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/PLAW-119publ87 (Accessed: 12 November 2026).


Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000 (United Kingdom) (2000) 2000 c. 23, received Royal Assent 28 July 2000, as amended. Available at: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2000/23/contents (Accessed: 12 November 2026).


Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties (1969) Adopted 22 May 1969, opened for signature 23 May 1969, entered into force 27 January 1980, 1155 UNTS 331. Available at: https://treaties.un.org/pages/showdetails.aspx?objid=080000028003902f (Accessed: 12 November 2026).

SUPPORT DIPLOMACY & LAW

Was this article useful?

If our analysis helped you better understand an issue or supported your research, consider making a contribution. Your support helps fund independent research and keeps our international law publications freely accessible to everyone.

bottom of page