Spheres of Influence: How Great Powers Claim Regions and Why It Matters
Introduction
Spheres of influence are geographic regions in which a powerful state seeks predominant influence over the political, economic, or security decisions of other states, often while limiting the involvement of competing powers. The concept describes a recurring feature of international relations: major powers attempt to shape the strategic orientation of surrounding countries without necessarily annexing their territories or assuming direct responsibility for their governments.
A sphere of influence can develop through military superiority, diplomatic agreements, economic dependence, political relationships, or a combination of these factors. Some arrangements are recognized by competing powers, while others operate through informal understandings or remain actively contested. Their defining characteristic is the attempt to establish a privileged position within a particular region, especially over decisions affecting foreign relations and national security.
Historical examples include the Monroe Doctrine of 1823, European imperial competition in Asia, and the division of Europe during the Cold War. Contemporary disputes involving Russia, China, and the United States demonstrate that similar geopolitical calculations continue to influence international politics. The methods employed have changed, but the desire to prevent rival powers from establishing strategic positions in sensitive regions remains recognizable.
The existence of great-power interests, however, does not establish a legal right to control other countries. Understanding spheres of influence requires distinguishing claims of regional authority from effective political control, examining the strategic interests that produce such claims, and assessing their consequences for sovereign states and international stability.
1. The Meaning of Spheres of Influence
In international relations, a sphere of influence refers to a geographic area within which one state enjoys, or seeks to establish, a predominant position over the external relationships and strategic decisions of other states. The concept ordinarily concerns an asymmetrical relationship between a major power and countries possessing fewer military, economic, or diplomatic resources.
Such influence may affect military alliances, diplomatic partnerships, access to strategic infrastructure, commercial arrangements, and relations with rival powers. A dominant state may tolerate considerable independence in ordinary domestic affairs while insisting that neighboring governments avoid security commitments it considers threatening.
The distinction between a sphere of influence and ordinary international influence is significant. States routinely seek favorable relations, commercial opportunities, and political support abroad. These activities do not necessarily establish a sphere. The stronger claim arises when a power attempts to obtain privileged influence over a defined region and prevent competitors from exercising comparable authority.
Amitai Etzioni's discussion of spheres of influence emphasizes the intermediate position of such arrangements between ordinary international relationships and more extensive forms of political subordination (Etzioni, 2015). Their characteristics vary considerably, making it difficult to apply a single definition across different historical periods.
1.1 Claims, Recognition, and Effective Control
An asserted sphere of influence does not necessarily correspond to an established geopolitical arrangement. A government may declare that a neighboring region falls within its special security interests without possessing sufficient influence to determine developments there. Other powers may reject its claim, while the states concerned pursue policies directly opposed to its preferences.
Recognition introduces another distinction. Some spheres have been established through explicit agreements between competing powers, defining areas in which each would enjoy preferential privileges. Others developed informally because rival governments accepted, or chose not to challenge, the dominant state's position.
Scholars disagree about whether recognition by other major powers is necessary before a region can properly be described as an established sphere. A restrictive definition reserves the term for situations involving effective predominance that competitors no longer actively contest. Broader definitions include attempted spheres and contested zones. Both approaches identify important geopolitical relationships, but they describe different degrees of established control.
Recognition by rival powers must also be distinguished from the consent of countries situated within the region. A territorial division negotiated between powerful states may be accepted by its signatories while facing opposition from the governments and populations whose independence it constrains. Diplomatic recognition does not automatically establish political legitimacy or legal authority.
1.2 Alliances, Regional Hegemony, and Formal Empire
A sphere of influence differs from a formal empire because the dominant power does not necessarily exercise sovereignty over the states or territories concerned. Governments may retain their institutions, international legal personality, diplomatic representation, and formal independence, even when their strategic choices are substantially constrained.
Regional hegemony is a related but broader concept. It describes the predominance of one power within a regional order and may involve military superiority, institutional leadership, or economic centrality. Such predominance can support a sphere of influence, but regional leadership does not necessarily entail a claim to exclude competing relationships or determine the foreign policies of neighboring states.
Military alliances require particular care. A powerful state may lead an alliance while its partners voluntarily accept obligations and retain meaningful authority over their decisions. Unequal military contributions and dependence on security guarantees do not alone establish coercive subordination. The relevant questions concern how decisions are made, whether members can pursue independent policies, and whether the leading power claims exclusive authority over their external relationships.
Protectorates, satellite states, and colonial territories present different degrees of dependence and control. A protectorate may involve treaty-based restrictions on external relations, while a satellite government may possess formal independence but operate under extensive political direction. Colonial administration entails a more direct exercise of governmental authority. These arrangements may share features with spheres of influence, but their institutional and legal characteristics cannot be treated as identical.
2. Why Great Powers Seek Regional Predominance
Security considerations provide one of the principal explanations for great-power spheres of influence. Governments frequently regard developments in neighboring countries as especially consequential because of geographic proximity, military access, and the potential deployment of hostile forces. A strategic partnership between a neighboring state and a distant rival may be perceived as changing the regional military balance.
Realist theories of international relations explain this behavior through the decentralized character of the international system. Because no central authority can guarantee every state's security, governments must consider their capabilities and the possible intentions of competitors. Kenneth Waltz's structural realism emphasizes the distribution of capabilities within this system, while John Mearsheimer's offensive realism gives greater attention to the incentives for powerful states to pursue regional predominance (Waltz, 1979; Mearsheimer, 2001).
Geography shapes these calculations. A buffer state may separate competing military powers, while access to ports, transport corridors, mountain passes, or maritime approaches can influence military planning. Great powers may seek friendly governments in strategically important locations without requiring territorial annexation. In other circumstances, they may regard neutrality as sufficient, provided neighboring states do not host hostile military capabilities.
Economic interests can reinforce these objectives. Access to natural resources, overseas markets, financial networks, and strategic infrastructure may encourage a state to preserve privileged relationships within a particular region. Economic dependence can also provide instruments of political influence through loans, investment, trade restrictions, or control over essential infrastructure. The existence of these relationships does not, by itself, demonstrate that a dominant power can determine another government's political decisions.
The methods used to establish predominance vary considerably. Security guarantees and economic incentives may encourage voluntary alignment, whereas diplomatic threats, support for political factions, military deployments, or direct intervention can be used to constrain another government's choices. Such methods differ substantially in their political consequences and legal implications.
Attempts to secure a region can also generate a security dilemma. Measures presented by one government as necessary for defense may appear threatening to neighboring states, prompting them to seek protection from its rivals. The resulting counteralignment can undermine the original attempt at establishing a buffer. This process forms part of the wider dynamics of regional balances of power, although it should be distinguished from deliberate territorial expansion or coercive domination.
The interests of surrounding states are rarely identical to those of the dominant power. Some governments welcome external protection against regional threats, while others seek neutrality or diversified partnerships. Their decisions affect whether a sphere develops through consent, reluctant accommodation, or continuing confrontation.
3. Imperial and Hemispheric Claims, 1823–1907
The modern diplomatic meaning of spheres of influence became particularly prominent during the nineteenth century, when imperial powers competed for territorial access, commercial privileges, and political predominance. Formal colonial annexation was only one means of extending imperial authority. Governments also negotiated preferential concessions and arrangements that limited the participation of rival powers.
These practices developed within an international order in which European states possessed substantial advantages in military capacity and overseas commerce.
Diplomatic agreements between imperial powers could determine access to territories whose governments had little influence over the negotiations. In some cases, the resulting arrangements preserved formal independence while reducing practical autonomy.
The historical record demonstrates several forms of regional dominance. The Monroe Doctrine began as a unilateral American declaration concerning European involvement in the Western Hemisphere. In China, competing powers acquired overlapping territorial and commercial privileges. The Anglo-Russian Convention of 1907 provides a different example: two powers explicitly negotiated geographic restrictions on their pursuit of concessions within an independent third state.
3.1 The Monroe Doctrine and American Primacy
President James Monroe announced the policy subsequently known as the Monroe Doctrine in his annual message to Congress on December 2, 1823. The declaration opposed further European colonization in the Americas and warned against attempts to extend European political systems into the newly independent American republics. It also expressed an intention to avoid intervention in European political affairs (Monroe, 1823).
The declaration reflected American security concerns following the independence movements in Spanish America. Washington feared renewed European intervention, particularly the possibility that European monarchies might attempt to restore colonial authority. The doctrine asserted a geographic distinction between European political affairs and those of the Americas, but it did not establish an international agreement granting the United States authority over the hemisphere.
American capabilities were initially insufficient to enforce the doctrine independently across the region. Britain's naval predominance and its commercial interests in maintaining access to newly independent American markets contributed to an international environment unfavorable to renewed Spanish colonial control. British and American interests partly converged, although the two governments did not adopt a common doctrine concerning the political organization of the hemisphere.
The doctrine's subsequent interpretation changed considerably. In 1904, President Theodore Roosevelt articulated a corollary asserting that chronic wrongdoing or political instability could, in certain circumstances, justify the exercise of international police power by the United States. Concerns over European intervention to collect sovereign debts helped shape this policy, which subsequently supported American interventions in Latin America and the Caribbean.
The contrast between 1823 and 1904 illustrates how a sphere-of-influence claim can develop. A declaration initially directed against outside intervention became associated with a stronger assertion of regional supervision. The change reflected the expansion of American power rather than the creation of an international legal entitlement over neighboring states.
3.2 Foreign Spheres of Influence in Late Qing China
China provides a prominent example of competing imperial spheres during the closing decades of the nineteenth century. Foreign powers obtained concessions involving ports, railways, mining, commercial privileges, and territorial leases through agreements concluded under conditions of substantial political and military inequality.
Russia, Germany, Britain, France, and Japan pursued different strategic and economic interests within Chinese territory. Their privileges varied considerably in legal form and geographic scope. Some arrangements involved leased territories or foreign-administered concessions, while others concerned preferential economic rights or informal political influence over particular regions.
These arrangements placed increasing pressure on the Qing government without producing a complete formal partition of China. Foreign competition could restrict Chinese administrative freedom and influence infrastructure development while leaving significant areas under Chinese government authority. The distinction between commercial advantage, territorial jurisdiction, and political predominance was frequently contested.
American Secretary of State John Hay responded to these competing privileges through the Open Door Notes of 1899–1900. The initial notes, circulated in 1899, sought equal commercial opportunities for foreign powers operating in China, particularly within existing areas of foreign influence. Washington wanted to prevent exclusive arrangements from restricting American access to Chinese markets.
In July 1900, amid the Boxer Rebellion and foreign military intervention in China, Hay issued a further circular emphasizing the preservation of China's territorial and administrative integrity. This position sought to discourage the partition of China while maintaining commercial access and existing treaty rights (U.S. Department of State, 1899–1900).
The Open Door policy illustrates a tension within imperial competition. The United States opposed exclusive commercial privileges for competitors while seeking access to markets shaped by unequal international relationships. Neither the initial notes nor the subsequent circular constituted a binding multilateral agreement establishing Chinese territorial integrity. The policy did not eliminate foreign spheres or restore full Chinese autonomy.
3.3 The Anglo-Russian Convention of 1907
The Anglo-Russian Convention of August 31, 1907, arose from the longstanding competition between the British and Russian empires in Asia. Britain regarded the security of India and its surrounding approaches as strategically important, while Russia sought to preserve its interests near its southern frontier. Persia occupied a significant geographic position within this rivalry.
The convention addressed competing interests in Persia, Afghanistan, and Tibet. Its Persian provisions established geographic restrictions on the concessions each government would seek or support. Under Articles I and II, Britain and Russia undertook reciprocal commitments not to pursue or support specified political and commercial concessions in areas associated with the other power's interests (Anglo-Russian Convention, 1907).
Article III regulated the handling of concessions in the intermediate area between the two designated regions. The agreement did not simply assign that territory to one power or prohibit all economic activity there. It established reciprocal arrangements concerning the treatment of concessions involving British and Russian subjects.
Articles IV and V addressed another important aspect of foreign influence: Persian financial obligations. Article IV concerned the allocation of specified customs and other revenues to the servicing of existing loans. Article V established arrangements for consultation between Britain and Russia if difficulties in loan payments made control over pledged revenue sources a question for consideration.
These provisions demonstrate that the convention extended beyond a geographic understanding over future commercial privileges. Financial relationships also formed part of the accommodation between the two powers, creating potential mechanisms for further involvement in Persian administration.
The agreement's legal effects require a distinction. Its obligations concerning concessions, financial arrangements, and consultations were undertaken by Britain and Russia. Persia was not a party, and the convention could not, through those bilateral commitments alone, impose treaty obligations on the Persian state.
The preamble expressly affirmed Persia's independence and territorial integrity. Nevertheless, the agreement was negotiated without Persian participation and encountered opposition among Iranian constitutionalists and nationalists. The political reaction reflected concerns that the understanding between London and St. Petersburg would constrain Persian independence during the Constitutional Revolution.
The convention reduced a source of Anglo-Russian rivalry and contributed to the diplomatic realignment preceding the First World War. Its significance as an example of spheres of influence lies in the accommodation between competing empires, achieved without the participation of the state most directly affected and accompanied by substantial consequences for its political autonomy.
4. The Cold War and the Division of Europe
The Second World War transformed the international distribution of power. Germany's defeat, the decline of European imperial influence, and the emergence of the United States and Soviet Union as rival superpowers created conditions for a new division of political and military influence.
The postwar settlement did not establish a single formal agreement dividing Europe into legally recognized American and Soviet territories. Nevertheless, military occupation, political developments, and the consolidation of competing alliances produced an increasingly recognizable geographic separation. Soviet predominance developed across much of Eastern Europe, while Western European governments established extensive security and economic relationships with the United States.
The formation of NATO in 1949 and the Warsaw Pact in 1955 institutionalized opposing military structures. Both alliances operated within the wider context of ideological rivalry and nuclear competition. Their existence helped organize the European balance of power, although the political relationships within the two blocs differed substantially in their institutions, degrees of autonomy, and reliance on coercion.
4.1 Soviet Predominance in Eastern Europe
Soviet influence in Eastern Europe rested on military power, Communist Party leadership, economic relationships, and political institutions developed after 1945. Governments associated with Moscow retained formal statehood but exercised restricted independence in matters that Soviet leaders considered essential to the security and cohesion of the socialist bloc.
The Hungarian Revolution of 1956 exposed the limits of that independence. Attempts to reform Hungary's political system and Prime Minister Imre Nagy's announcement of withdrawal from the Warsaw Pact challenged Soviet predominance. Soviet military intervention suppressed the uprising and demonstrated Moscow's willingness to use force to prevent political developments that threatened its regional position.
A comparable confrontation emerged during the Prague Spring of 1968. Under Alexander Dubček, Czechoslovakia introduced political and economic reforms intended to liberalize the socialist system. Soviet leaders feared that these changes would weaken Communist authority and encourage similar movements elsewhere in Eastern Europe. Warsaw Pact forces led by the Soviet Union invaded Czechoslovakia in August 1968.
The intervention was subsequently associated with the Brezhnev Doctrine, which asserted a political justification for intervention when developments within a socialist state threatened the interests of the wider socialist community. The doctrine became explicitly associated with Soviet policy after the Czechoslovak intervention, although its underlying assumptions had precedents in earlier Soviet conduct. It was not a generally accepted principle of international law.
Military enforcement preserved Soviet predominance for decades, but it also revealed the weakness of a regional order dependent on political repression and external force. The collapse of Communist governments across Eastern Europe in 1989 demonstrated that the continuity of a sphere could depend on the dominant state's willingness and capacity to maintain it.
4.2 American Alliances and the Limits of Bipolar Control
American influence in Western Europe developed through different political arrangements. The Marshall Plan supported postwar economic reconstruction, while NATO established collective defense commitments among participating governments. The United States provided substantial military capabilities and security guarantees, but its European allies retained independent governments and formal authority over alliance decisions.
These relationships were unequal without being institutionally identical to Soviet control in Eastern Europe. NATO's political structure depended on consultation and consensus among its members. Disagreements over military deployments, foreign policy, and alliance leadership demonstrated that American predominance did not eliminate the capacity of European governments to pursue independent policies.
The American experience in Latin America followed a different pattern. Washington supported or intervened against governments according to its perceptions of regional security and ideological competition. Its efforts to prevent Soviet influence sometimes involved covert operations, military intervention, and support for political forces aligned with American interests.
The Cuban Missile Crisis of October 1962 demonstrated how competing security interests could produce a direct confrontation between the superpowers. Soviet nuclear missile deployments in Cuba prompted an American naval quarantine and demands for their removal. The crisis ended through negotiations involving Soviet withdrawal of the missiles, American assurances concerning Cuba, and a confidential understanding concerning the subsequent withdrawal of American Jupiter missiles from Turkey.
The crisis revealed both the strategic significance of geographic proximity and the limits of unilateral regional claims. Washington regarded Soviet nuclear deployments in Cuba as an unacceptable threat, while Moscow sought to strengthen its position through a military relationship with the Cuban government. The confrontation reflected competing security calculations rather than an internationally recognized American entitlement to exclude Soviet forces from the Caribbean.
The danger of escalation also demonstrated the significance of nuclear deterrence in Cold War diplomacy. Both governments had strong incentives to avoid direct war, although deterrence did not remove the possibility of miscalculation or military confrontation.
Bipolarity never meant that every country belonged unequivocally to an American or Soviet sphere. The Non-Aligned Movement, established in 1961, sought to preserve alternatives to superpower alignment. States such as India, Yugoslavia, and Indonesia pursued different versions of strategic autonomy, while disputes within both alliances demonstrated the limits of ideological and military leadership.
5. Russia and the Contested Post-Soviet Region
The dissolution of the Soviet Union in December 1991 fundamentally altered Russia's geopolitical position. Former Soviet republics became independent states, while countries that had previously belonged to the Warsaw Pact were no longer bound by Soviet-directed military arrangements. Moscow retained substantial military capabilities but lost the institutional structures through which Soviet influence had been exercised.
Russian governments subsequently sought to preserve privileged relationships within the former Soviet region. Security concerns, economic connections, Russian-speaking communities, military facilities, and historical relationships all influenced Moscow's policies. These interests were particularly significant in countries bordering Russia or occupying strategically important positions between Russia and other European powers.
The region did not develop into a uniform Russian sphere of influence. Belarus maintained close political and security relations with Moscow, whereas Georgia and Ukraine increasingly pursued relationships with Western institutions. Several Central Asian governments sought to balance cooperation with Russia against economic and diplomatic partnerships with China, Europe, and other powers.
NATO enlargement became an important point of disagreement. Former Warsaw Pact states joined the alliance after the Cold War, followed by several former Soviet republics. At the 2008 Bucharest Summit, NATO members declared that Ukraine and Georgia would eventually become members, although neither received an immediate invitation to join (NATO, 2008, para. 23).
Russian leaders repeatedly opposed further enlargement, arguing that the expansion of Western military structures toward Russia threatened national security. Western governments maintained that membership decisions belonged to the applicant countries and existing NATO members. Under Article 10 of the North Atlantic Treaty, enlargement requires unanimous agreement among the allies; the treaty does not grant neighboring non-member states a veto.
The conflict became increasingly consequential after Russia's military intervention in Georgia in 2008. In 2014, Russia occupied and annexed Crimea following political upheaval in Ukraine and the removal of President Viktor Yanukovych. Moscow presented its actions through arguments concerning historical ties, security, and self-determination. The annexation was rejected by Ukraine and widely condemned internationally, including through UN General Assembly Resolution 68/262 affirming Ukraine's territorial integrity (UN General Assembly, 2014).
Russia's demands became more explicit in December 2021, when its Foreign Ministry published draft security agreements directed toward the United States and NATO. The proposed NATO-Russia agreement sought restrictions on the military and political arrangements available to countries in Russia's neighborhood.
Article 6 of the draft demanded a commitment from NATO members to refrain from further enlargement, including Ukraine's accession. Article 7 proposed restrictions on NATO military activities in Ukraine and other states in Eastern Europe, the South Caucasus, and Central Asia. These provisions represented negotiating demands rather than accepted international obligations (Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, 2021).
The full-scale Russian invasion of Ukraine on February 24, 2022, demonstrated the consequences of attempting to enforce regional security claims through military force. Moscow advanced several political and security justifications for its actions, including opposition to Ukraine's relationship with NATO. These arguments did not establish a legal entitlement to invade another state or acquire territory.
On March 2, 2022, the UN General Assembly adopted Resolution ES-11/1 by 141 votes in favor, five against, and 35 abstentions. The resolution deplored Russia's aggression in violation of Article 2(4) of the UN Charter and demanded the withdrawal of Russian forces from Ukraine's internationally recognized territory (UN General Assembly, 2022).
The Russian case demonstrates the distinction between an established sphere and a contested claim to one. Moscow's capacity to influence neighboring governments varies considerably, while Ukraine's resistance shows the limitations of regional predominance imposed against the will of an independent state. Military control over territory does not automatically translate into accepted political authority, diplomatic recognition, or lawful sovereignty.
The consequences extend beyond relations between Moscow and Kyiv. Russia's actions have influenced European defense planning, NATO enlargement, sanctions policies, and discussions about regional security guarantees. The conflict demonstrates how efforts to prevent a neighboring state from joining a rival strategic alignment can produce prolonged confrontation rather than the security sought by the dominant power.
6. China and the Competition for East Asian Influence
China's economic expansion and military modernization have altered the distribution of power in East Asia. Beijing possesses extensive commercial relationships with neighboring states, expanding naval capabilities, and considerable influence over regional economic development. These developments have raised questions about whether China seeks a predominant regional position comparable to historical great-power spheres of influence.
Chinese officials have frequently rejected hegemonism and presented their foreign policy through principles of sovereignty, non-interference, and peaceful cooperation. These declarations coexist with policies intended to defend China's territorial claims and shape the security environment around its borders. Evaluating Chinese regional ambitions requires distinguishing official diplomatic positions from the strategic implications of particular actions.
East Asia presents significant obstacles to exclusive predominance. Japan, South Korea, Australia, and the Philippines maintain important security relationships with the United States, while Southeast Asian governments pursue different combinations of cooperation, competition, and diplomatic balancing. These relationships limit the possibility of treating the region as a single, uncontested Chinese sphere.
The South China Sea illustrates these competing interests. China asserts sovereignty over disputed maritime features and claims maritime rights that overlap with the positions of several Southeast Asian states. Its construction and militarization of artificial islands have increased its capacity to maintain a military presence in disputed waters and influence regional maritime activity.
These disputes involve distinct questions of territorial sovereignty, maritime entitlements, navigation, and strategic competition. The 2016 award in the arbitration between the Philippines and China rejected China's claims to historic rights to resources within areas of the South China Sea insofar as those claims exceeded the maritime entitlements permitted by the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea. The tribunal did not decide sovereignty over disputed islands or delimit maritime boundaries between the parties (South China Sea Arbitration, 2016).
China rejected the tribunal's findings and maintained that the proceedings lacked a valid legal basis. The award nevertheless remains final and binding between the parties under UNCLOS Article 296 and Annex VII, Article 11. China's rejection does not remove that legal obligation, although implementation remains a separate question.
The distinction between the tribunal's actual findings and broader arguments about regional dominance is significant. The legal consequences of the South China Sea arbitration concern rights and obligations under the law of the sea rather than any general judicial determination of China's regional geopolitical position.
Taiwan presents a different problem. Beijing claims sovereignty over Taiwan and opposes official relationships or military arrangements that it considers inconsistent with the one-China principle. Taiwan's disputed international status, its separate governing institutions, and its security relationships with the United States require analysis that cannot be reduced to an ordinary dispute over a neighboring sovereign state's alliance choices.
China's economic relationships raise further questions about the nature of regional influence. Trade, investment, infrastructure development, and participation in the Belt and Road Initiative can produce substantial dependence on Chinese markets and financing. Such relationships may increase Beijing's bargaining power, but economic importance does not automatically confer exclusive political authority.
Economic influence also depends on the availability of alternative markets, the structure of investment relationships, and the capacity of governments to negotiate or resist external pressure. Commercial interdependence may create vulnerabilities for smaller countries while also imposing costs on a dominant power that attempts to use trade or investment as an instrument of coercion.
Southeast Asian states have demonstrated considerable capacity to negotiate between competing powers. Some depend heavily on trade with China while maintaining security relationships with the United States or other partners. ASEAN institutions also provide opportunities for regional cooperation that do not depend on exclusive alignment with a single external power.
China's regional position is best understood through differentiated relationships rather than a presumed sphere covering all of East Asia. In particular areas, Beijing exercises substantial influence and seeks to restrict activities it regards as threatening. Elsewhere, competing alliances, diplomatic resistance, and the independent interests of regional governments limit its ability to establish predominance.
7. American Influence After the Cold War
The end of the Cold War left the United States with an exceptional international position. Its military capabilities, economic influence, alliance networks, and leadership within major international institutions supported a degree of global predominance that had few historical equivalents.
Graham Allison (2020) argues that American policymakers sometimes treated spheres of influence as obsolete during this period because U.S. predominance had reduced the capacity of other powers to establish competing regional orders. His interpretation emphasizes the difference between rejecting spheres as a principle and exercising extensive influence in practice.
The concept nevertheless requires geographic precision. American global leadership cannot automatically be classified as a single sphere of influence encompassing every country involved in U.S.-led institutions or security arrangements. Economic globalization, voluntary alliance commitments, military deployments, and political predominance are related phenomena, but they do not necessarily establish exclusive authority over another state's external relationships.
The Western Hemisphere provides a more direct historical connection. The Monroe Doctrine and its subsequent reinterpretations established a longstanding tradition of American claims to special regional security interests. These claims varied across administrations and frequently coexisted with diplomatic commitments to sovereign equality, non-intervention, and regional cooperation.
The issue acquired renewed prominence through the 2025 U.S. National Security Strategy. The document explicitly invoked a Trump Corollary to the Monroe Doctrine and called for the restoration of American preeminence in the Western Hemisphere. It expressed an intention to prevent non-hemispheric competitors from positioning threatening military capabilities or controlling strategically important assets within the region (White House, 2025).
The significance of that policy became more concrete on January 3, 2026, when American forces conducted military strikes in Venezuela and captured Nicolás Maduro and Cilia Flores, who were subsequently transferred to the United States. President Donald Trump publicly confirmed the operation, while the administration characterized it as an effort to apprehend individuals wanted on federal criminal charges.
The operation generated substantial controversy under international law. The Venezuelan government condemned it as an act of aggression, while Washington defended its conduct through arguments involving criminal enforcement and national security. On January 5, UN Secretary-General António Guterres, in remarks delivered to the Security Council on his behalf, expressed concern that rules of international law had not been respected and warned about the precedent established by the operation (United Nations, 2026).
The legal questions cannot be resolved merely by identifying the charges against Maduro. The existence of domestic criminal proceedings does not independently authorize military force within another sovereign state's territory. The operation must be considered under the UN Charter's prohibition of force and the applicable rules concerning consent, self-defense, and Security Council authorization.
The Venezuela operation also illustrates the difference between military intervention and the establishment of a sphere of influence. The ability to capture a foreign political leader demonstrates considerable operational military capacity, but it does not by itself establish permanent political control over the country or an accepted right to direct its future government.
These developments form part of the broader debate concerning the Donroe Doctrine, particularly the renewed American emphasis on excluding external competitors and asserting strategic authority in the Western Hemisphere. They demonstrate how a long-established regional doctrine can acquire contemporary significance through both official policy and military conduct.
American alliances outside the Western Hemisphere present a different relationship. NATO's institutional structure and U.S. security partnerships in the Indo-Pacific involve commitments negotiated with sovereign governments, although these relationships operate within unequal distributions of power. Some countries welcome American predominance as protection against regional competitors, while others seek to reduce dependence on Washington.
The American experience shows that a powerful state can simultaneously oppose exclusive spheres claimed by competitors and assert regional interests of its own. This tension does not establish that all forms of American leadership are equivalent to coercive dominance. Each relationship must be assessed according to its institutions, actual restrictions on sovereign choice, and the methods through which influence is exercised.
8. Spheres of Influence and International Law
Spheres of influence describe geopolitical relationships, but the concept does not independently create legal rights over territories or governments. Contemporary international law recognizes states as sovereign legal persons regardless of differences in military strength, economic resources, or diplomatic influence.
Article 2(1) of the United Nations Charter establishes sovereign equality as a foundational principle of the Organization. Sovereign equality concerns the legal status of states, not equality in material capabilities. A small state may depend economically or militarily on a stronger neighbor without losing its international legal personality.
The legal significance of regional influence depends on the conduct through which it is established and exercised. Diplomatic cooperation, trade agreements, security partnerships, and political persuasion may be lawful even where they produce substantial asymmetries. Coercive interference, unlawful military intervention, and territorial acquisition through force raise different legal questions.
International law does not prohibit every unequal relationship, but neither does strategic superiority confer a general right to subordinate another state's sovereign decisions. The distinction is particularly important when political leaders invoke geographic proximity, historical relationships, or national security to justify restrictions on neighboring governments' independence.
8.1 Sovereignty, Non-Intervention, and the Use of Force
Article 2(4) of the UN Charter requires member states to refrain from threatening or using force against the territorial integrity or political independence of another state, or in any other manner inconsistent with the purposes of the United Nations. This rule restricts the methods through which a power may attempt to create or enforce regional predominance.
The Charter framework recognizes individual and collective self-defense under Article 51 when an armed attack occurs and permits enforcement action authorized by the Security Council under Chapter VII. A claimed regional sphere does not provide an additional exception to the prohibition of force.
The prohibition of intervention operates alongside the Charter's rules governing force. It is a principle of customary international law protecting matters that states are legally entitled to decide freely, including their political systems and foreign policies. The distinction between permissible influence and prohibited intervention depends centrally on coercion.
The International Court of Justice addressed this distinction in its 1986 judgment in Military and Paramilitary Activities in and against Nicaragua. The Court explained that prohibited intervention concerns matters within a state's sovereign freedom of decision and involves coercive interference with those choices. It identified coercion as the defining element of prohibited intervention (ICJ, 1986, para. 205).
The judgment did not establish that every attempt to influence another government violates international law. Diplomatic persuasion, economic relationships, and political criticism may affect sovereign choices without satisfying the legal requirement of coercion. The precise boundary becomes more difficult where political or economic pressure is severe but does not involve military force.
The Court found that American assistance to armed groups opposing Nicaragua's government violated the customary prohibition of intervention. Its treatment of the economic measures challenged in the proceedings was narrower: the Court did not regard those particular measures as establishing a breach of customary non-intervention.
This finding must be distinguished from the Court's conclusions concerning bilateral treaty obligations. The general trade embargo imposed by the United States on May 1, 1985, was found to violate Article XIX of the 1956 Treaty of Friendship, Commerce and Navigation between Nicaragua and the United States. The Court also found that certain American conduct deprived the treaty of its object and purpose (ICJ, 1986, paras. 276–282).
The judgment does not establish that economic measures are necessarily lawful simply because they do not violate customary non-intervention. Their legality may depend on separate treaty obligations and other applicable rules of international law.
The broader principle of non-intervention imposes limits on attempts to control another state's sovereign decisions while leaving room for ordinary international political influence. Its application must be distinguished from the separate prohibition on threats or uses of force.
The UN General Assembly's 1970 Friendly Relations Declaration provides further guidance. Resolution 2625 (XXV) affirms sovereign equality, non-intervention, and the prohibition of force, among other principles. Although the resolution is not itself a treaty, aspects of its language reflect or provide evidence of customary international law.
The legal position is particularly clear regarding territorial conquest. A state cannot acquire lawful sovereignty over another state's territory merely by occupying it through military force. The description of an operation as necessary to protect a regional sphere does not create an exception to the Charter's prohibition of force.
8.2 Alliance Choice and European Security Commitments
The ability to determine foreign relationships is an important aspect of sovereign independence. States may negotiate military partnerships, maintain neutrality, establish diplomatic relationships, and participate in international organizations, subject to their applicable legal obligations.
The Helsinki Final Act of 1975 affirmed principles including sovereign equality, territorial integrity, non-intervention, and the peaceful settlement of disputes. Its adoption within the Conference on Security and Co-operation in Europe reflected an attempt to organize relations between states possessing different political systems and security interests.
The 1999 OSCE Charter for European Security developed these commitments further. Paragraph 8 affirmed the freedom of participating states to choose or change their security arrangements, including treaties of alliance. It also recognized the right to neutrality and the equal right of participating states to security.
The same paragraph stipulated that participating states would not strengthen their security at the expense of others. It also rejected claims by any state, group of states, or organization to preeminent responsibility for maintaining peace and stability within the OSCE area or to treating any part of that area as its sphere of influence (OSCE, 1999, para. 8).
These provisions were adopted as political commitments rather than a binding treaty establishing independent legal obligations. Their significance lies in expressing principles intended to guide European security relations, including opposition to exclusive spheres of influence.
The commitments must be understood together. The recognition that states should not strengthen their security at the expense of others does not automatically establish an external veto over alliance decisions. Equally, the freedom to choose security arrangements does not mean that other states have no legitimate security interests or that competing governments are required to accept every proposed deployment without diplomatic objection.
A state may seek admission to a military alliance without possessing an unconditional right to membership. NATO, for example, requires unanimous agreement among its members before an invitation can be extended under Article 10 of the North Atlantic Treaty. The absence of guaranteed admission does not establish a general legal entitlement for outside powers to determine another state's foreign policy.
The distinction between security interests and legal authority is decisive. A government may regard developments across its borders as threatening and seek negotiated arrangements to address those concerns. Such perceptions do not independently authorize coercive intervention, territorial acquisition, or the use of force against a neighboring state.
9. Strategic Stability and the Autonomy of Smaller States
Spheres of influence have long been defended as instruments for managing rivalry between major powers. Under this interpretation, a recognized division of regional interests can clarify strategic expectations and reduce the likelihood that competitors will challenge one another in areas considered especially sensitive.
Historical examples provide some support for this argument. The Anglo-Russian Convention of 1907 reduced a source of imperial competition, while the eventual stabilization of the Cold War division of Europe contributed to patterns of military restraint. Recognition of a rival's predominant position may discourage intervention where the risks of escalation are considered unacceptable.
The argument remains contested. Graham Allison (2020) emphasizes the possible security benefits of acknowledging existing spheres, particularly where denying another power's strategic interests could increase the danger of confrontation. Other interpretations stress that recognition may strengthen coercive arrangements, discourage resistance to domination, or encourage further claims by powerful states.
The stabilizing effects of spheres cannot be assumed. Great powers may disagree over their boundaries, the extent of permissible foreign involvement, or the legitimacy of governments within the region. Attempts to expand regional predominance can provoke resistance and military countermeasures, especially where neighboring states consider their independence threatened.
The process of establishing a sphere may be particularly dangerous. A dominant state seeking to exclude competitors may resort to pressure or force, while rival powers may increase support for threatened governments. Escalation becomes more likely when competing states interpret the same territory as essential to their security.
Established spheres can also become unstable when the dominant state's capacity weakens or when subordinate governments challenge existing arrangements. The collapse of Soviet influence over Eastern Europe illustrates how political resistance, domestic developments, and declining external enforcement can transform a longstanding regional order.
The experience of smaller states introduces an additional perspective often marginalized in discussions centered on great-power accommodation. Governments situated between competing powers do not necessarily consider exclusive alignment desirable. They may seek neutrality, diversify commercial partnerships, develop independent military capabilities, or enter alliances intended to protect their political autonomy.
Such strategies involve risks. A smaller country may become dependent on external security guarantees, while efforts to balance competing powers may provoke diplomatic retaliation. Economic relationships can also constrain political choices, particularly where a government relies heavily on one partner for trade, finance, energy, or essential infrastructure.
Nevertheless, smaller states retain meaningful agency. Their domestic political institutions, historical experiences, geographic positions, and assessments of security threats influence their willingness to accept external leadership. The presence of a powerful neighbor does not predetermine their strategic preferences.
International institutions can affect these relationships by providing diplomatic forums, collective security arrangements, and legal mechanisms for addressing disputes. They do not eliminate power inequalities, but they can increase the political and legal costs of coercion and create opportunities for weaker states to coordinate their positions.
The distinction between stability among great powers and stability within a sphere is particularly significant. An arrangement accepted by competing powers may reduce the risk of direct confrontation between them while restricting the autonomy of the countries involved. Peace between dominant states does not necessarily establish that the regional arrangement is legitimate, voluntary, or beneficial to those living within it.
Conversely, not every unequal security relationship produces subordination. Some smaller states deliberately seek protection from stronger partners because they consider the alternatives more dangerous. The political consequences depend on the degree of consent, the distribution of decision-making authority, the methods used to maintain influence, and the capacity of states to reconsider their relationships.
The continuing debate over spheres of influence concerns two different assessments. One asks whether a particular distribution of regional power reduces the likelihood of international conflict. The other concerns the consequences of that distribution for sovereign independence and political choice. A convincing evaluation must consider both without assuming that strategic accommodation resolves questions of legitimacy.
Conclusion
Spheres of influence remain an important concept for understanding the relationship between geographic power, strategic interests, and international political authority. Their historical forms have varied considerably. Nineteenth-century imperial agreements, American hemispheric claims, and the Cold War division of Europe demonstrate different combinations of diplomatic recognition, military predominance, economic dependence, and restrictions on sovereign decision-making.
Contemporary competition involving Russia, China, and the United States shows that claims to privileged regional influence have not disappeared. Their practical significance depends on the ability of major powers to establish predominance, the willingness of competitors to accept or challenge their claims, and the responses of countries situated within the contested regions.
The central distinction remains between power and legal authority. A state may possess the military or economic capacity to influence neighboring governments without acquiring a legal entitlement to determine their external relationships. International law recognizes sovereign equality and restricts coercive intervention and the unlawful use of force, even where powerful states regard their security interests as especially important.
Spheres of influence can clarify geopolitical relationships and, under certain conditions, contribute to restraint between major powers. They can also encourage coercion, resistance, and prolonged confrontation. Their consequences cannot be understood solely through the calculations of dominant states. The independence, interests, and choices of smaller countries remain essential to determining whether regional predominance produces political accommodation or continuing instability.
References
Allison, G. (2020) ‘The new spheres of influence: Sharing the globe with other great powers’, Foreign Affairs, 99(2), pp. 30–40. Available at: https://www.jstor.org/stable/26892661 (Accessed: 1 November 2026).
Anglo-Russian Convention (1907) Convention between the United Kingdom and Russia relating to Persia, Afghanistan and Tibet, signed at St. Petersburg, 31 August 1907; ratifications exchanged 23 September 1907. Reproduced in Foreign Relations of the United States, 1907, Part I. Available at: https://history.state.gov/historicaldocuments/frus1907p1/d415 (Accessed: 1 November 2026).
Charter of the United Nations (1945) Signed at San Francisco, 26 June 1945; entered into force 24 October 1945, 1 UNTS XVI. Available at: https://www.un.org/en/about-us/un-charter (Accessed: 1 November 2026).
Etzioni, A. (2015) ‘Spheres of influence: A reconceptualization’, The Fletcher Forum of World Affairs, 39(2), pp. 117–132. Available at: https://www.fletcherforum.org/s/39-2_17Etzioni.pdf (Accessed: 1 November 2026).
Helsinki Final Act (1975) Final Act of the Conference on Security and Co-operation in Europe, signed at Helsinki, 1 August 1975. Available at: https://www.osce.org/helsinki-final-act (Accessed: 1 November 2026).
International Court of Justice (1986) Military and Paramilitary Activities in and against Nicaragua (Nicaragua v. United States of America), Merits, Judgment of 27 June 1986, ICJ Reports 1986, p. 14. Available at: https://api.icj-cij.org/sites/default/files/case-related/70/070-19860627-JUD-01-00-EN.pdf (Accessed: 3 November 2026).
Kazemzadeh, F. (1968) Russia and Britain in Persia, 1864–1914: A Study in Imperialism. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Mearsheimer, J.J. (2001) The Tragedy of Great Power Politics. New York: W.W. Norton & Company.
Monroe, J. (1823) Seventh Annual Message to Congress (Monroe Doctrine), 2 December 1823. National Archives of the United States [online]. Available at: https://www.archives.gov/milestone-documents/monroe-doctrine (Accessed: 3 November 2026).
North Atlantic Treaty (1949) Signed at Washington, DC, 4 April 1949; entered into force 24 August 1949, 34 UNTS 243. Available at: https://nato.int/en/about-us/official-texts-and-resources/official-texts/1949/04/04/the-north-atlantic-treaty (Accessed: 3 November 2026).
North Atlantic Treaty Organization (2008) Bucharest Summit Declaration, issued by the Heads of State and Government participating in the meeting of the North Atlantic Council, Bucharest, 3 April 2008. Available at: https://nato.int/en/about-us/official-texts-and-resources/official-texts/2008/04/03/bucharest-summit-declaration (Accessed: 3 November 2026).
Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (1999) Charter for European Security, adopted at the OSCE Istanbul Summit, 18 November 1999. Available at: https://www.osce.org/mc/17502 (Accessed: 3 November 2026).
Roosevelt, T. (1904) Fourth Annual Message to Congress (Roosevelt Corollary to the Monroe Doctrine), 6 December 1904. National Archives of the United States [online]. Available at: https://www.archives.gov/milestone-documents/roosevelt-corollary (Accessed: 3 November 2026).
Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs (2021) Agreement on Measures to Ensure the Security of the Russian Federation and Member States of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, draft agreement, 17 December 2021, unofficial English translation [online]. Available at: https://mepoforum.sk/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/Agreement-Security-RF-NATO-en.pdf (Accessed: 5 November 2026).
South China Sea Arbitration (2016) The Republic of the Philippines v. The People's Republic of China, Award of 12 July 2016, Arbitral Tribunal constituted under Annex VII to the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, PCA Case No. 2013-19. Available at: https://docs.pca-cpa.org/2016/07/PH-CN-20160712-Award.pdf (Accessed: 5 November 2026).
Treaty of Friendship, Commerce and Navigation between the United States of America and the Republic of Nicaragua (1956) Signed at Managua, 21 January 1956; entered into force 24 May 1958, 367 UNTS 3. Available at: https://treaties.un.org/Pages/showDetails.aspx?objid=0800000280139d26 (Accessed: 5 November 2026).
United Nations (2026) Secretary-General's Remarks to the Security Council – on Venezuela, delivered by Rosemary A. DiCarlo on behalf of Secretary-General António Guterres, New York, 5 January 2026 [online]. Available at: https://www.un.org/sg/en/content/sg/statements/2026-01-05/secretary-generals-remarks-the-security-council-venezuela (Accessed: 5 November 2026).
United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (1982) Concluded at Montego Bay, 10 December 1982; entered into force 16 November 1994, 1833 UNTS 3. Available at: https://treaties.un.org/pages/showdetails.aspx?objid=0800000280043ad5 (Accessed: 5 November 2026).
United Nations General Assembly (1970) Declaration on Principles of International Law concerning Friendly Relations and Co-operation among States in accordance with the Charter of the United Nations, Resolution 2625 (XXV), A/RES/2625(XXV), adopted 24 October 1970. Available at: https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/202170 (Accessed: 5 November 2026).
United Nations General Assembly (2014) Territorial Integrity of Ukraine, Resolution 68/262, A/RES/68/262, adopted 27 March 2014. Available at: https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/767883 (Accessed: 5 November 2026).
United Nations General Assembly (2022) Aggression against Ukraine, Resolution ES-11/1, A/RES/ES-11/1, adopted 2 March 2022. Available at: https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/3965290 (Accessed: 6 November 2026).
U.S. Department of State (1899) ‘Mr. Hay to Mr. Vignaud’, 6 September 1899, in Papers Relating to the Foreign Relations of the United States, 1899. Office of the Historian [online]. Available at: https://history.state.gov/historicaldocuments/frus1899/d88 (Accessed: 6 November 2026).
U.S. Department of State (1900) ‘Circular note of July 3, 1900, to the powers cooperating in China, defining the purposes and policy of the United States’, in Foreign Relations of the United States, 1901, Appendix, Affairs in China. Office of the Historian [online]. Available at: https://history.state.gov/historicaldocuments/frus1901China/d4 (Accessed: 6 November 2026).
Waltz, K.N. (1979) Theory of International Politics. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
White House (2025) National Security Strategy of the United States of America. Washington, DC: The White House, November 2025. Available at: https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2025/12/2025-National-Security-Strategy.pdf (Accessed: 6 November 2026).

