Neoliberal Institutionalism in International Relations: Keohane's Theory Explained
Introduction
Neoliberal institutionalism is a theory of international relations that explains how sovereign states can cooperate despite the absence of a central authority governing international politics. Associated particularly with Robert Keohane, the theory argues that international institutions can make cooperation more achievable by reducing uncertainty, lowering transaction costs, supplying information, and supporting reciprocal commitments. States remain concerned with their interests and security, but the institutional arrangements through which they interact can influence their decisions and the outcomes they achieve (Keohane, 1984).
The central problem is that governments may recognize the benefits of cooperation without being able to secure them through independent action. International trade provides a familiar example. Two states might benefit from reducing commercial barriers, yet each may hesitate if it cannot predict whether the other will maintain its commitments. Similar difficulties arise in arms control, environmental negotiations, and other areas requiring coordinated decisions.
Keohane's contribution emerged from a debate concerning American economic leadership and the international arrangements established after the Second World War. In After Hegemony: Cooperation and Discord in the World Political Economy (1984), he challenged the proposition that sustained cooperation necessarily depends on the continuing dominance of a hegemonic power. His argument explained why institutions created under particular political conditions might continue serving the interests of governments after those conditions change.
This approach occupies a distinctive position in international cooperation theory. It accepts several assumptions associated with realism, particularly international anarchy and the strategic behavior of states, while assigning greater explanatory importance to international institutions. Its principal concern is identifying the conditions under which rules, procedures, and repeated interactions enable governments to sustain cooperation despite conflicting interests and unequal power.
1. What Is Neoliberal Institutionalism?
Neoliberal institutionalism emerged as a prominent approach to international relations during the development of international regime theory in the late twentieth century. It examines how institutions affect cooperation among states operating in a decentralized political system. Rather than assuming that international cooperation requires shared political identities or the disappearance of strategic competition, institutionalists investigate how governments can establish arrangements that make mutually beneficial behavior more likely.
The approach draws on rational-choice analysis, economics, and political science. Governments are generally treated as strategic actors that evaluate available choices according to their interests, expectations, and the anticipated behavior of others. Institutional arrangements become relevant when they alter the information available to states, affect the costs associated with political decisions, or change expectations about future interaction.
Arthur Stein's analysis of neoliberal institutionalism places these questions within a wider intellectual tradition that examines how institutions emerge from the interests of autonomous political actors. The theory shares important assumptions with rationalist realism, including the significance of state interests and material capabilities. Its distinctive contribution lies in explaining why states may prefer institutionalized cooperation to unrestricted independent decision-making (Stein, 2008).
The terminology requires some clarification. Neoliberal institutionalism differs from economic neoliberalism, which is commonly associated with market-oriented economic policies. It is also more specific than classical liberal internationalism, whose historical arguments often concern international peace, political reform, and organized relations among states. The broader tradition of liberalism in international relations includes explanations based on domestic politics, economic interdependence, and the formation of state preferences. Keohane's institutionalism concentrates principally on how governments with identifiable interests can sustain cooperation under conditions of anarchy.
1.1 Anarchy, Rational States, and Mutual Interests
International anarchy is a foundational assumption of neoliberal institutionalist reasoning. In international relations theory, anarchy refers to the absence of a centralized political authority possessing general governmental powers over sovereign states. It does not mean the absence of legal obligations, established diplomatic practices, or international organizations. Governments can create institutions and accept binding commitments without becoming subordinate to a world government.
Anarchy nevertheless affects strategic calculations. Because no general international authority can reliably guarantee the performance of every interstate agreement, governments must consider whether their partners will honor commitments. A state may recognize substantial benefits from cooperation while fearing that another participant will exploit its willingness to comply. Uncertainty about intentions and future conduct can discourage agreements that would otherwise benefit all parties.
Keohane distinguished cooperation from harmony. Harmony exists where actors' policies already coincide, making behavioral adjustments unnecessary. Cooperation arises when governments modify their conduct in response to the actual or anticipated preferences of others. It consequently presupposes some divergence of interests and a process through which governments attempt to reconcile their policies (Keohane, 1984).
Rationality within this framework concerns strategic choice, but it need not imply perfect knowledge. Political decision-makers may operate with incomplete information, limited analytical capacities, and uncertainty about the consequences of their actions. Keohane's broader institutional analysis recognizes these limitations while using rational-choice assumptions to identify how institutions may affect political behavior.
The explanation of cooperation generally begins by treating state preferences as given for analytical purposes. It asks how governments pursue those preferences under particular institutional conditions. That is different from explaining how national interests emerge from domestic political relationships, social identities, or historical experiences. The distinction helps define both the explanatory strength and the limitations of rationalist institutionalism.
1.2 Institutions Beyond Formal Organizations
International institutions encompass more than organizations possessing headquarters, administrative personnel, and formally constituted governing bodies. In institutionalist theory, the concept includes established rules and practices that organize political interaction and shape expectations about acceptable behavior. An international regime generally concerns a particular issue area in which states develop shared principles, norms, rules, and decision-making procedures.
Stephen Krasner's influential formulation of international regimes emphasized the convergence of actors' expectations around such arrangements. His 1982 contribution to the study of regimes helped establish a conceptual framework that extended beyond traditional analyses of formal international organizations (Krasner, 1982). This broader understanding allowed scholars to examine institutionalized behavior even where governments had not established a permanent international bureaucracy.
Formal organizations represent one category of institutional arrangement. The United Nations, World Trade Organization, and International Atomic Energy Agency possess organizational structures and legally defined responsibilities. Their powers depend on their constituent instruments and other applicable rules of international law. The legal personality of an organization, however, is a different question from the institutionalist explanation of its influence on state behavior.
The distinction becomes clearer when considering the subjects of international law. An international organization may possess legal personality and exercise powers conferred upon it, while a treaty regime or informal arrangement may influence government behavior without constituting a separate legal person. Institutionalism examines both categories because formal legal personality is not a necessary condition for rules and practices to affect strategic interaction.
The Missile Technology Control Regime illustrates the broader concept. Established in 1987, it operates through political commitments and coordinated national export-control practices rather than a constitutive treaty establishing an international organization. Its structure differs from that of the IAEA, yet both arrangements can be examined for their effects on information, expectations, and cooperation.
The analytical distinction is between an institution's organizational form and the functions it performs. Formal structures may improve continuity and administration, but institutional influence can also arise through recurring consultations, shared procedures, and coordinated national policies. The existence of such arrangements does not itself demonstrate their effectiveness; that requires examining how they influence the conduct of participating governments.
2. Keohane and Cooperation After Hegemony
Robert Keohane developed his institutionalist explanation during a period of uncertainty about American economic leadership. Following the Second World War, the United States exercised exceptional influence over the international economic arrangements established among Western industrialized countries. The Bretton Woods institutions and the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade formed important components of an economic order in which American power contributed to the organization of international cooperation.
By the 1970s, changes in the international economy had prompted renewed debate about the stability of this arrangement. The economic recovery of Western Europe and Japan, monetary instability, and the oil shocks challenged earlier assumptions about American predominance. These developments raised questions about whether institutions associated with United States leadership could remain effective as the distribution of economic capabilities changed.
Hegemonic stability arguments linked the creation or maintenance of an open international economic order to the leadership of a dominant power. Such a state might possess the resources and political incentives to support cooperation, provide certain collective benefits, and encourage participation in common arrangements. Yet the relationship between hegemonic leadership and the persistence of established regimes remained a separate theoretical question.
Keohane addressed that distinction directly. Even if hegemonic leadership had facilitated the establishment of international institutions, governments might continue supporting those arrangements because they provided continuing benefits. Explaining this possibility required examining how institutions affected cooperation after their creation, rather than attributing their survival exclusively to the power of the state that had initially supported them.
2.1 From Complex Interdependence to Regime Theory
Keohane's earlier collaboration with Joseph Nye contributed to the intellectual foundations of his institutionalist approach. In Power and Interdependence (1977), the authors developed complex interdependence as an analytical model for examining international relationships in which conventional assumptions about military power and interstate security competition did not adequately explain political behavior.
Complex interdependence identifies three characteristic conditions: multiple channels of interaction between societies, the absence of a fixed hierarchy among the issues occupying governments, and a limited role for military force within the relationships being examined. These conditions do not describe every international relationship. They help explain why economic and diplomatic interactions can operate differently from military confrontations between adversarial states.
The analysis also recognizes that interdependence may create unequal political relationships. Two countries can depend on an economic exchange to different degrees, giving one greater bargaining power. Keohane and Nye distinguished sensitivity to changes within an existing relationship from vulnerability, which concerns the costs an actor faces after attempting to adjust to those changes. Economic connections could consequently create both opportunities for cooperation and sources of political influence (Keohane and Nye, 1977).
Complex interdependence and neoliberal institutionalism are related but distinct. The former concerns the characteristics of international relationships and the political consequences of interdependence. The latter seeks to explain the conditions under which institutional arrangements influence cooperation. Keohane's subsequent work increasingly concentrated on how rules, information, and repeated interaction affected the choices available to governments.
International regime theory supplied an important conceptual foundation for that development. During the early 1980s, scholars examined how principles, norms, rules, and procedures organized behavior in particular issue areas. Keohane's 1982 study of the demand for international regimes developed an interest-based explanation of why governments might prefer established institutional arrangements to repeated bargaining without common procedures.
2.2 After Hegemony and the Persistence of Cooperation
After Hegemony, published in 1984, concentrated on cooperation among advanced capitalist countries, particularly within international political economy. Keohane investigated whether international economic cooperation could persist without the continuing dominance of a hegemonic state. His analysis treated governments as self-interested actors operating in an anarchic international system while examining why they might find established regimes advantageous.
A central distinction concerns the creation and maintenance of institutions. Establishing a regime can require considerable diplomatic effort, agreement on procedures, and resolution of disputes over the distribution of benefits. A hegemonic power may facilitate this process by supplying leadership or influencing the incentives of other participants. Once the regime exists, however, states may possess independent reasons to preserve it.
Established arrangements can reduce the need to negotiate every subsequent issue from the beginning. They may preserve information, provide recognized procedures, and create expectations about how governments will respond to particular conduct. Abandoning an existing regime can involve substantial costs if governments must reconstruct arrangements that already help them address recurring political or economic problems.
Keohane's explanation draws heavily on the functions international regimes may perform. Institutions can lower transaction costs, reduce informational uncertainty, and facilitate negotiations among governments with overlapping interests. These benefits may continue even when the original distribution of international power changes (Keohane, 1984).
The argument does not establish that institutions necessarily survive hegemonic decline. Their persistence depends on whether participating governments continue to value the benefits of cooperation and whether institutional arrangements remain capable of addressing relevant obstacles. An institution may lose support if the interests of its participants diverge sufficiently or if its procedures no longer produce advantages relative to available alternatives.
Keohane's contribution was to challenge the claim that hegemonic leadership is a necessary condition for sustained international cooperation. His theory identifies reasons why existing regimes may continue shaping interstate behavior without requiring the dominant power associated with their creation to retain its former position.
3. Coordination, Collaboration, and Interstate Cooperation
International cooperation involves different kinds of strategic problems. Arthur Stein's distinction between coordination and collaboration identifies why governments may fail to achieve outcomes they collectively prefer, even when they recognize potential benefits from cooperation. The distinction also explains why different international arrangements require different institutional mechanisms (Stein, 1982).
Coordination problems arise when governments benefit from aligning their conduct but must select among possible arrangements. States may agree that compatible technical standards are preferable to incompatible national systems while disagreeing over which standard to adopt. Once a common arrangement has been established and participants expect others to follow it, continued coordination may become self-enforcing because unilateral departures would undermine the benefits available to the departing state.
Collaboration problems involve stronger incentives for defection. Governments may recognize that mutual compliance would produce a preferable collective outcome while calculating that an individual departure could yield an immediate advantage. The prisoner's dilemma illustrates this possibility: individually rational choices can produce an outcome less favorable to the participants than mutual cooperation.
The institutional requirements differ. Coordination may depend primarily on communication, agreement about common procedures, and the selection of a shared arrangement. Collaboration may require monitoring and mechanisms that make continued compliance more attractive than opportunistic behavior. These differences help explain why some international institutions operate largely through conventions and consultation, while others establish more extensive reporting, verification, or dispute settlement procedures.
The number of participating states also affects cooperation. Bilateral arrangements may allow governments to identify their partners' conduct relatively easily. Larger groups can encounter greater difficulties in negotiating common rules, determining responsibility for noncompliance, and organizing collective responses. Each participant may also have incentives to benefit from contributions made by others without bearing an equivalent share of the costs.
The effect of additional participants is not uniformly negative. Wider membership may increase the benefits available from cooperation, broaden opportunities for reciprocal exchange, or make common technical standards more useful. Yet the institutional arrangements needed to organize many governments can be more demanding than those required for a limited bilateral relationship. Kenneth Oye identified the number of players, the structure of incentives, and expectations of future interaction as significant conditions affecting cooperation under anarchy (Oye, 1985).
Repeated interaction introduces another consideration. Governments expecting to negotiate with the same partners over an extended period may value the future consequences of their present decisions. The prospect of continued benefits can discourage opportunistic conduct, particularly when participants can identify violations and respond. These incentives depend on political expectations and do not automatically arise merely because governments belong to the same organization.
The distinction between coordination and collaboration demonstrates why institutionalism cannot be reduced to the proposition that international organizations promote cooperation. Different strategic problems create different demands for rules, information, monitoring, and enforcement. Understanding those demands is necessary before assessing whether a particular institution contributes to a cooperative outcome.
4. How International Institutions Facilitate Cooperation
Neoliberal institutionalism explains institutional influence through changes in the circumstances under which governments make decisions. States may recognize common interests yet encounter uncertainty, bargaining costs, and incentives that discourage compliance. Institutions can modify these conditions by organizing information, establishing procedures, and connecting present choices to future interactions.
The theory does not require international institutions to possess governmental authority over sovereign states. Some organizations exercise powers delegated through treaties, while other arrangements operate through agreed procedures and continuing political commitments. In either case, their influence may arise from the consequences of institutional participation for the choices available to governments.
Keohane's functional explanation concerns the advantages that established institutions may offer compared with decentralized bargaining without comparable arrangements. These advantages can help explain why states create or preserve international regimes. Whether an institution actually changes behavior, however, is a separate empirical question. Its intended functions must be distinguished from its demonstrated political effects (Keohane, 1984).
4.1 Information, Transparency, and Monitoring
Uncertainty about other governments' conduct is a persistent obstacle to cooperation. A state may support an agreement's objectives while doubting whether its partners intend to honor their commitments. It may also lack the information necessary to distinguish deliberate noncompliance from administrative delays, technical difficulties, or disagreements over interpretation.
Institutions can reduce these problems by establishing procedures for collecting and exchanging information. Reporting requirements, regular consultations, technical assessments, and verification arrangements may provide governments with information that would otherwise be difficult or costly to obtain. Common procedures can also clarify which information participants are expected to disclose and how their conduct will be evaluated.
Monitoring becomes particularly significant when governments condition their future behavior on the compliance of other participants. Reciprocity requires some ability to identify conduct that departs from an agreed arrangement. Without reliable information, states may respond to suspected violations that have not occurred or fail to recognize conduct that undermines their interests.
Information can also influence bargaining before an agreement is concluded. Governments may be more willing to accept commitments when they have reliable information about the capabilities, policies, and anticipated conduct of prospective partners. Regular institutional interaction can improve that information, although its usefulness depends on accuracy, access, and the willingness of participants to communicate.
Transparency remains subject to important limitations. States may provide incomplete information, conceal activities, or disagree about the significance of institutional findings. Monitoring arrangements also differ in authority and technical capacity. The institutionalist proposition is that improved information can alter strategic calculations, not that verification necessarily eliminates deception or political disagreement.
4.2 Transaction Costs and Institutional Procedures
International negotiations require governments to identify potential partners, exchange proposals, assess commitments, and establish procedures for implementation. These activities impose transaction costs even when participating states possess compatible interests. The difficulties become greater when negotiations involve numerous governments, technically complicated obligations, or repeated decisions over extended periods.
Keohane drew on transaction-cost reasoning to explain why governments might prefer established regimes to negotiating each new issue without common procedures. Institutions can provide continuing diplomatic forums, accumulated information, and recognized methods of reaching agreements. Once these arrangements exist, governments may find subsequent cooperation less costly because they no longer need to construct the procedural foundations of negotiation from the beginning (Keohane, 1984).
Institutional continuity can be particularly useful in relationships involving recurring decisions. Governments may negotiate successive commitments within a familiar setting, rely on established administrative practices, and draw upon accumulated technical knowledge. Such advantages can persist across changes in political leadership or the distribution of international power.
These mechanisms also help explain why institutional maintenance may be easier than institutional creation. Establishing common procedures can require substantial initial investment and political bargaining. Preserving arrangements that already perform useful functions may be less costly than replacing them, even where governments remain dissatisfied with particular rules.
Lower transaction costs do not establish that an institution is necessarily efficient. Complex procedures can become expensive, resistant to reform, or vulnerable to obstruction. Rules originally intended to facilitate cooperation may impose substantial costs when circumstances change. The relevant assessment concerns whether the institution provides advantages over realistic alternatives, rather than whether institutionalization is inherently preferable to less formal arrangements.
4.3 Reciprocity, Future Interaction, and Issue Linkage
Expectations about future interaction can alter the incentives facing governments. A state that obtains an immediate advantage by violating an agreement may encounter reciprocal restrictions, reduced confidence, or the loss of subsequent cooperative opportunities. The significance of these consequences depends on how much the government values future benefits compared with the gains available from defection.
Robert Axelrod and Robert Keohane examined these dynamics in their 1985 study of cooperation under anarchy. Their analysis emphasized the mutuality of interests, the shadow of the future, and the number of participants. It also showed that the effectiveness of reciprocal strategies depends on the institutional circumstances in which governments interact (Axelrod and Keohane, 1985).
Institutions can make reciprocity more predictable by providing information about compliance and established opportunities for response. Regular consultations allow governments to address perceived violations and communicate the consequences of their decisions. Repeated interaction may also influence reputation, although reputational effects depend on whether other participants regard previous conduct as relevant to future commitments.
Issue linkage introduces another possibility. Governments may connect negotiations concerning different policy areas when concessions in one area can alter the benefits available in another. An agreement that would be difficult to reach through isolated negotiations may become possible when participants consider a broader range of reciprocal commitments.
Such linkages can also complicate cooperation. Governments may use concessions in one area to exert pressure in another, while disagreements over unrelated policies may obstruct otherwise achievable agreements. States with different bargaining capabilities may obtain unequal advantages from linked negotiations.
Reciprocity is equally capable of producing conflict when expectations are unfavorable. Retaliatory responses may encourage compliance in some circumstances but generate cycles of noncooperation in others. Institutional arrangements influence these outcomes by affecting information, available responses, and expectations about future interaction. Their contribution depends on the particular strategic relationship rather than the mere repetition of diplomatic contact.
5. Neoliberal Institutionalism Examples
The explanatory value of neoliberal institutionalism becomes clearer when its mechanisms are examined in established international arrangements. International trade and nuclear safeguards provide contrasting examples of governments attempting to organize cooperation under conditions of uncertainty and conflicting interests. Their institutional structures differ, as do the incentives that encourage participation.
Trade arrangements are particularly relevant to Keohane's original work because international political economy was the principal setting for his analysis. Nuclear safeguards illustrate how institutionalist reasoning can also be applied to cooperation involving national security concerns. The comparison demonstrates that information, monitoring, and recurring interaction can perform different functions across policy areas.
Institutional participation is not itself proof that an institution caused cooperation. States may establish organizations because they already possess strong incentives to work together. The analytical question is whether particular institutional arrangements alter bargaining behavior, improve the credibility of commitments, or make continued cooperation more attractive than it would otherwise be.
5.1 Trade Cooperation under GATT and the WTO
The General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade was concluded in 1947 and applied provisionally from January 1, 1948, under the Protocol of Provisional Application. It established a framework for international trade relations built around principles such as nondiscrimination and negotiated tariff concessions. Successive negotiating rounds expanded the commitments undertaken by participating governments.
The GATT system provides a historically relevant example of the international economic arrangements considered in Keohane's institutionalist analysis. Its development occurred alongside changes in the relative economic influence of the United States, Western Europe, and Japan. The continuation of negotiations through established arrangements is consistent with the proposition that governments may retain interests in cooperation even when the distribution of international power changes.
GATT provided an institutional setting for negotiations, the exchange of concessions, and the administration of trade commitments. Governments could rely on established procedures rather than constructing an entirely new framework for every commercial disagreement. Reciprocal tariff concessions and continuing negotiations created opportunities to connect immediate policy decisions with expectations about future trade relations.
The World Trade Organization was established by the Marrakesh Agreement Establishing the World Trade Organization, which entered into force on January 1, 1995. Its legal framework includes the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade 1994, which incorporates provisions of GATT 1947 while remaining a legally distinct instrument. Article II:4 of the WTO Agreement expressly distinguishes GATT 1994 from GATT 1947.
The WTO also established a more formalized dispute settlement system through the Understanding on Rules and Procedures Governing the Settlement of Disputes. Members can request consultations and, where the applicable requirements are satisfied, pursue panel proceedings concerning alleged violations of covered agreements. These procedures give governments a common legal framework for presenting and evaluating trade disputes.
The binding character of WTO obligations derives from the applicable agreements and international law, not from neoliberal institutionalist theory. Institutionalism addresses a different question: how the existence of these obligations and procedures may influence bargaining, expectations, and compliance. Legal enforceability and political incentives can interact without being equivalent.
The WTO's dispute settlement difficulties illustrate the limits of institutional cooperation. Since December 2019, the Appellate Body has been unable to hear new appeals because it has lacked the members required to function. The final sitting member's term expired on November 30, 2020. These vacancies have impaired the appellate stage of the system, although consultations, panel proceedings, and other dispute settlement activities have continued.
Some members responded through the Multi-Party Interim Appeal Arbitration Arrangement, established in April 2020. The MPIA uses arbitration under Article 25 of the Dispute Settlement Understanding to provide an alternative appellate mechanism among participating members. Its operation demonstrates how governments may attempt to preserve selected functions of institutional cooperation when established procedures become unavailable.
The arrangement also illustrates the limits of such adaptation. The MPIA does not automatically apply to every WTO member, and its existence does not resolve the disagreements surrounding Appellate Body appointments. It provides an alternative for participating governments while leaving the broader institutional dispute unsettled.
More recent negotiations over digital trade offer another illustration of the distinction between agreement and implementation. The WTO Agreement on Electronic Commerce emerged from plurilateral negotiations, and participating members adopted interim arrangements in March 2026 to facilitate its entry into force while pursuing its incorporation into the WTO legal framework. Its obligations do not automatically apply to every WTO member. Under Article 29.2, the agreement enters into force for accepting members on the 30th day following the deposit of the 45th instrument of acceptance. For a member accepting it thereafter, entry into force occurs on the 30th day following the deposit of that member's instrument.
These developments show that governments may pursue institutional cooperation through different legal arrangements while disagreeing over participation, obligations, and decision-making procedures. They also demonstrate why the existence of negotiated rules should not be confused with universal acceptance or effective implementation.
The GATT and WTO experience supports several propositions associated with neoliberal institutionalism. Established procedures can organize negotiations, reduce some informational difficulties, and provide mechanisms for handling recurring disputes. Yet the persistence of these arrangements cannot be attributed exclusively to institutional effects. Economic interdependence, domestic commercial interests, and the influence of powerful states remain essential elements of the explanation.
5.2 Nuclear Safeguards and the IAEA
Nuclear safeguards provide an example of institutional cooperation involving security interests and verification. The International Atomic Energy Agency was established in 1957, before the adoption of the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons in 1968. The NPT entered into force on March 5, 1970, and subsequently became a principal legal foundation for the Agency's safeguards responsibilities.
Article III of the NPT requires non-nuclear-weapon states parties to accept safeguards under agreements negotiated and concluded with the IAEA. These arrangements serve the treaty's specified verification purpose concerning the fulfillment of nonproliferation obligations and the prevention of diversion of nuclear energy from peaceful uses to nuclear weapons or other nuclear explosive devices.
Comprehensive safeguards agreements establish legally binding responsibilities concerning nuclear material, declarations, information, and verification. Their application depends on the terms of the relevant agreement and the Agency's applicable safeguards procedures. The legal rights of inspectors and the duties of participating governments cannot be inferred solely from the general objective of preventing nuclear proliferation.
The IAEA's verification system has also developed through additional protocols. The Model Additional Protocol, approved by the Agency's Board of Governors in 1997, was designed to strengthen safeguards by providing additional information and access measures. An additional protocol is a separate legal instrument associated with an underlying safeguards agreement; its provisions do not automatically bind every state possessing a comprehensive safeguards agreement.
The distinction is significant for institutionalist analysis. Verification arrangements may reduce uncertainty about nuclear material and activities by establishing reporting obligations, inspection procedures, and independent technical assessments. Governments may regard information produced through an agreed institutional mechanism as more credible than assurances supplied exclusively through bilateral diplomatic exchanges.
Institutional cooperation nevertheless depends on the legal and practical conditions under which verification occurs. Inspectors require authority and access within the applicable safeguards framework. Information may remain incomplete, and disagreements concerning declarations or inspections can prevent the Agency from reaching particular safeguards conclusions.
Iran's comprehensive safeguards agreement provides a concrete illustration of the legal foundation of verification. Published as IAEA document INFCIRC/214, the agreement entered into force on May 15, 1974. It establishes safeguards responsibilities in connection with Iran's participation in the NPT.
Questions concerning IAEA inspections and safeguards obligations in Iran demonstrate the importance of distinguishing an institution's verification mandate from broader diplomatic and security disputes. The Agency's legal authority depends on its Statute, the applicable safeguards agreement, and any other relevant arrangements. An assessment concerning safeguards compliance is not automatically a determination that a state has manufactured nuclear weapons.
The institutionalist explanation concerns why governments may accept and maintain such arrangements. Independent verification can contribute to confidence in particular commitments, reduce uncertainty, and supply information relevant to diplomatic decisions. These functions do not guarantee cooperation or eliminate the strategic interests that make nuclear negotiations difficult.
The nuclear safeguards example consequently illustrates a limited but significant institutional contribution. Monitoring can influence interstate relations even where security concerns remain substantial. Its effectiveness depends on legal authority, technical capabilities, access to relevant information, and the willingness of governments to cooperate within the established framework.
6. Neoliberal Institutionalism vs Neorealism
The debate between neoliberal institutionalism and neorealism concerns the significance of international institutions for the behavior of sovereign states. Both approaches recognize that international politics lacks a centralized government capable of reliably enforcing agreements among states. They also acknowledge the importance of strategic interests, material capabilities, and the distribution of power.
Kenneth Waltz's structural realism explains major patterns of international politics through the anarchic organization of the international system and the distribution of capabilities among states. Because governments must remain concerned with their security, they assess how changes in the capabilities of other states may affect their relative positions (Waltz, 1979).
The wider tradition of realism in international relations encompasses different explanations of power, national interests, and international security. Structural realism emphasizes systemic constraints, while other realist approaches give greater attention to domestic politics, leadership, or human motivations. These distinctions are relevant when comparing particular realist arguments with Keohane's institutionalism.
Neoliberal institutionalists accept the importance of anarchy but question whether it sufficiently explains the limits of cooperation. Governments may operate without a superior political authority while establishing institutions that influence their expectations and choices. The resulting disagreement concerns the degree to which institutions affect political outcomes independently of the interests and capabilities of participating states.
6.1 Absolute Gains, Relative Gains, and State Interests
One of the principal differences between neoliberal institutionalism and neorealism concerns how governments evaluate the benefits of cooperation. Absolute gains refer to improvements in an actor's position, irrespective of the gains obtained by others. A government primarily concerned with absolute gains may support an agreement that improves its welfare even when another participating state benefits more.
Relative gains concern the distribution of advantages among participants. A government may receive substantial benefits from cooperation while hesitating if a rival obtains a considerably greater advantage. Such concerns become particularly significant when economic resources can contribute to military capabilities, technological development, or future bargaining power.
Joseph Grieco developed an influential realist criticism of neoliberal institutionalism in his 1988 article Anarchy and the Limits of Cooperation. He argued that the institutionalist emphasis on common interests and absolute gains underestimated the positional concerns created by international anarchy. States may resist cooperation when they believe that unequal benefits could weaken their relative security or bargaining position (Grieco, 1988).
The importance of relative gains depends on political circumstances. Unequal economic benefits may be more acceptable between governments with stable security relationships than between military adversaries. The prospects for cooperation also depend on whether an agreement affects strategically important resources and whether states have alternatives for protecting their interests.
Relative-gains concerns do not necessarily eliminate cooperation. Governments may negotiate arrangements that moderate distributive disadvantages, provide reciprocal assurances, or distribute benefits across several issues. Institutions can supply information about these arrangements and establish procedures through which participants address disagreements.
Keohane and Lisa Martin argued that realist objections concerning relative gains did not establish the general ineffectiveness of institutions. Their 1995 response emphasized the need to examine the conditions under which institutions influence state behavior, including circumstances involving distributive concerns (Keohane and Martin, 1995).
Neither approach can be accurately characterized as exclusively concerned with one category of gains. Governments may consider both their individual benefits and the consequences of improving another state's relative position. The theoretical disagreement concerns the weight assigned to these considerations and the extent to which institutional arrangements can modify the resulting incentives.
6.2 Do Institutions Change Outcomes or Reflect State Power?
A more fundamental disagreement concerns whether international institutions independently influence state behavior. Realist critics argue that institutions reflect the interests and power of the governments that establish them. If states cooperate because their strategic preferences already coincide, institutional participation may accompany cooperation without making a substantial independent contribution.
John Mearsheimer developed a prominent version of this criticism in The False Promise of International Institutions, published in International Security in the winter 1994–1995 issue. He questioned the capacity of institutionalist theories to explain international security outcomes and challenged claims that institutions could substantially overcome the constraints imposed by power politics (Mearsheimer, 1994/1995).
Mearsheimer's criticism concentrated particularly on the relationship between institutions and international security. It should not be interpreted as demonstrating that every international arrangement is ineffective or that states cannot cooperate. The issue is whether institutions substantially change state behavior compared with the outcomes that would emerge from the underlying distribution of interests and capabilities.
Keohane and Martin responded in The Promise of Institutionalist Theory (1995). They argued that institutions can reflect state interests while still exercising independent effects. An arrangement may originate because governments recognize opportunities for cooperation, yet its established rules and procedures can subsequently influence negotiations, expectations, and compliance.
This argument requires a distinction between institutional origins and institutional consequences. Governments may establish an organization because their interests are compatible. Once created, its procedures may provide information, reduce the costs of future negotiations, or affect responses to potential violations. The institutionalist claim concerns these effects, not the proposition that organizations operate independently of political power.
The empirical question remains demanding. If governments would have cooperated under comparable conditions without an institution, its independent contribution may be limited. If institutional procedures change bargaining behavior or allow agreements that would otherwise be difficult to reach, institutional influence becomes more persuasive.
The debate cannot be resolved by counting international organizations or identifying isolated institutional failures. The relevant evidence concerns specific causal mechanisms and the decisions they affect. Institutionalism is strongest when it explains how identifiable rules and procedures alter the strategic environment confronting governments, rather than assuming that institutional survival demonstrates effectiveness.
7. Limits of Keohane's Institutional Explanation
Neoliberal institutionalism offers a conditional explanation of cooperation rather than a general theory of institutional success. Its principal mechanisms operate where governments possess sufficiently compatible interests to make cooperation desirable but encounter difficulties in negotiating or maintaining agreements. Institutions may reduce these difficulties without eliminating the political disagreements that produce them.
The effectiveness of institutional arrangements also depends on changing circumstances. A government may initially support cooperation because it anticipates substantial future benefits, only to reconsider its commitments when economic conditions, security concerns, or domestic political priorities change. Established procedures can make cooperation less costly and more predictable, but they cannot ensure that governments will continue to regard participation as advantageous.
The theory faces additional difficulties when institutions are shaped by substantial inequalities of power or when their effects cannot be separated from the interests that produced them. These limitations concern both the political operation of institutions and the methods used to evaluate their influence. Their significance varies across issue areas and relationships among states.
7.1 Power, Bargaining, and Unequal Institutional Benefits
International institutions are frequently established through negotiations among governments possessing unequal economic resources, military capabilities, and diplomatic influence. States may recognize common benefits from cooperation while disagreeing over membership conditions, decision-making procedures, or the distribution of costs. Institutional design can reflect these differences in bargaining power.
Powerful governments may influence the rules under which cooperation operates and the opportunities available to other participants. Less influential states may accept institutional arrangements because participation offers advantages over exclusion, even when the resulting terms do not correspond to their preferred outcomes.
Stephen Krasner examined this relationship in Global Communications and National Power: Life on the Pareto Frontier (1991). His analysis of international communications regimes emphasized distributional conflicts and the influence of national power. Governments may agree that some form of coordination is desirable while disagreeing over which cooperative outcome should be selected.
The distinction between achieving a mutually advantageous outcome and determining how its benefits are distributed is central to institutional politics. Several arrangements may improve the position of participating states, yet some will favor particular governments more than others. Bargaining power can influence which arrangement emerges from negotiations.
Arthur Stein similarly emphasized that cooperation need not occur among actors possessing equal bargaining capabilities. Institutional arrangements can arise from self-interested decisions while incorporating considerable inequalities of power. The existence of voluntary agreement does not mean that participants faced equivalent alternatives or exercised comparable influence over the terms of cooperation (Stein, 2008).
These considerations qualify functional explanations of international institutions. An arrangement may reduce transaction costs, improve information, and support continuing cooperation while reproducing unequal political relationships. Institutional efficiency and distributive equity are different questions.
The relationship between cooperation and power is consequently more complicated than an opposition between institutions and state interests. Institutions can organize cooperation among unequal states while reflecting the bargaining conditions under which they were created. Their political consequences depend partly on who controls relevant decisions, which rules can be revised, and how the benefits and burdens of cooperation are distributed.
7.2 Causal Evidence and Competing Explanations
A persistent methodological difficulty concerns whether international institutions cause cooperation or whether governments already inclined toward cooperation are more likely to establish institutions. Institutional endogeneity arises because the creation, design, and membership of institutions are themselves influenced by the interests and political conditions that scholars seek to explain.
Consider a group of states that establishes a regulatory organization and subsequently maintains extensive cooperation. One possible explanation is that the organization improves information and reduces the costs of reaching agreements. Another is that the governments already possess sufficiently compatible interests to cooperate without elaborate institutional arrangements.
The observed association between institutional participation and cooperation does not establish which explanation is stronger. Evaluating the institutional contribution requires attention to the decisions governments made, the alternatives available to them, and the mechanisms through which particular rules or procedures may have affected their behavior.
Evidence may concern changes in negotiations after new procedures were introduced, the effects of monitoring on compliance decisions, or differences between arrangements addressing comparable problems. Such comparisons can strengthen causal explanations, although identifying the outcome that would have occurred without an institution remains difficult.
Rationalist institutionalism also places limits on the questions it can answer. It generally examines how actors pursue interests treated as given within a particular analysis. Domestic political coalitions, economic constituencies, electoral changes, and bureaucratic interests may nevertheless influence the preferences governments bring to international negotiations.
The distinction between rational strategic behavior and bounded rationality is relevant here. Strategic models explain how actors choose among alternatives given their preferences and expectations. Bounded rationality concerns limitations on information, attention, and decision-making capacities. Neither concept, by itself, supplies a complete explanation of how political identities or national objectives are formed.
Constructivist scholarship raises a related but distinct question. Alexander Wendt argued that international anarchy does not necessarily produce a single pattern of competitive behavior. States' identities and interests can be shaped through social interaction, shared understandings, and established practices (Wendt, 1992).
This approach differs from explanations that concentrate primarily on how institutions affect strategies pursued by actors whose preferences are relatively stable. Constructivist analysis may investigate how institutional relationships contribute to the formation or transformation of those preferences. The two approaches can address different aspects of the same international relationship, but they do not rely on identical assumptions.
Keohane recognized the significance of alternative approaches in International Institutions: Two Approaches (1988). He distinguished rationalistic explanations from reflective approaches emphasizing the historical and social contexts of institutional practices. His discussion also called attention to the need for empirical research capable of evaluating competing institutional explanations.
Neoliberal institutionalism retains particular explanatory value where governments possess identifiable interests but encounter obstacles involving coordination, bargaining, information, or compliance. It is less complete when the principal question concerns the formation of interests, the development of political identities, or changes in the social meaning of international rules.
The theory's usefulness depends on matching its analytical mechanisms to the circumstances being examined. Institutions may influence interstate cooperation without explaining every element of state behavior. Establishing that influence requires evidence concerning how particular arrangements affect political decisions, rather than relying on the assumption that institutionalized relations are necessarily more cooperative.
Conclusion
Neoliberal institutionalism explains how cooperation can develop and persist among sovereign states operating without a central international government. Robert Keohane's principal contribution was to identify why international regimes could continue serving state interests after the decline of hegemonic leadership associated with their establishment. His analysis showed how information, transaction costs, reciprocity, and institutional continuity could influence the strategic choices of governments.
The theory distinguishes the existence of shared interests from the ability to realize their benefits. Coordination and collaboration problems create different obstacles to agreement, and institutional arrangements may address those obstacles through different mechanisms. Their effectiveness depends on the preferences of participating governments, the structure of their interactions, and the political circumstances surrounding their commitments.
Institutions remain subject to the distribution of international power and the interests of the states that sustain them. They may organize cooperation while preserving unequal bargaining relationships, and their existence does not automatically demonstrate an independent effect on political outcomes. The relevant question is whether identifiable institutional arrangements change the choices governments would otherwise make.
Keohane's enduring contribution is a conditional explanation of cooperation under anarchy. States need not abandon their sovereignty or strategic interests to benefit from international institutions. Cooperation can persist when established arrangements provide sufficient advantages to justify continued participation, even as international power relationships change.
References
Agreement on Electronic Commerce (2026) Adopted at Yaoundé on 28 March 2026. WTO document WT/MIN(26)/42.
Axelrod, R. and Keohane, R.O. (1985) ‘Achieving cooperation under anarchy: Strategies and institutions’, World Politics, 38(1), pp. 226–254.
General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade 1947 (1947) Geneva, 30 October 1947. Provisionally applied from 1 January 1948.
General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade 1994 (1994) Annex 1A to the Marrakesh Agreement Establishing the World Trade Organization, 15 April 1994. Entered into force on 1 January 1995.
Grieco, J.M. (1988) ‘Anarchy and the limits of cooperation: A realist critique of the newest liberal institutionalism’, International Organization, 42(3), pp. 485–507.
International Atomic Energy Agency (1974) The Text of the Agreement Between Iran and the Agency for the Application of Safeguards in Connection with the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons. INFCIRC/214, 13 December 1974.
International Atomic Energy Agency (1997) Model Protocol Additional to the Agreement(s) Between State(s) and the International Atomic Energy Agency for the Application of Safeguards. INFCIRC/540 (Corrected). Vienna: International Atomic Energy Agency.
Keohane, R.O. (1982) ‘The demand for international regimes’, International Organization, 36(2), pp. 325–355.
Keohane, R.O. (1984) After Hegemony: Cooperation and Discord in the World Political Economy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Keohane, R.O. (1988) ‘International institutions: Two approaches’, International Studies Quarterly, 32(4), pp. 379–396.
Keohane, R.O. and Martin, L.L. (1995) ‘The promise of institutionalist theory’, International Security, 20(1), pp. 39–51.
Keohane, R.O. and Nye, J.S. (1977) Power and Interdependence: World Politics in Transition. Boston, MA: Little, Brown.
Krasner, S.D. (1982) ‘Structural causes and regime consequences: Regimes as intervening variables’, International Organization, 36(2), pp. 185–205.
Krasner, S.D. (1991) ‘Global communications and national power: Life on the Pareto frontier’, World Politics, 43(3), pp. 336–366.
Marrakesh Agreement Establishing the World Trade Organization (1994) Marrakesh, 15 April 1994. Entered into force on 1 January 1995.
Mearsheimer, J.J. (1994–1995) ‘The false promise of international institutions’, International Security, 19(3), pp. 5–49.
Oye, K.A. (1985) ‘Explaining cooperation under anarchy: Hypotheses and strategies’, World Politics, 38(1), pp. 1–24.
Protocol of Provisional Application of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (1947) Geneva, 30 October 1947. Provisionally effective from 1 January 1948. United Nations Treaty Series, 55, p. 187.
Secretariat of State for Economic Affairs (n.d.) The Missile Technology Control Regime [online]. Available at: https://www.seco.admin.ch/en/missile-technology-control-regime (Accessed: 11 November 2026).
Statute of the International Atomic Energy Agency (1956) Approved on 23 October 1956. Entered into force on 29 July 1957.
Stein, A.A. (1982) ‘Coordination and collaboration: Regimes in an anarchic world’, International Organization, 36(2), pp. 299–324.
Stein, A.A. (2008) ‘Neoliberal institutionalism’, in Reus-Smit, C. and Snidal, D. (eds.) The Oxford Handbook of International Relations. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 201–221.
Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons (1968) Opened for signature on 1 July 1968. Entered into force on 5 March 1970. United Nations Treaty Series, 729, p. 161.
Understanding on Rules and Procedures Governing the Settlement of Disputes (1994) Annex 2 to the Marrakesh Agreement Establishing the World Trade Organization, 15 April 1994. Entered into force on 1 January 1995.
Waltz, K.N. (1979) Theory of International Politics. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
Wendt, A. (1992) ‘Anarchy is what states make of it: The social construction of power politics’, International Organization, 46(2), pp. 391–425.
World Trade Organization (2026) How to accept the Agreement on Electronic Commerce [online]. Available at: https://www.wto.org/english/tratop_e/ecom_e/how_to_accept_agreement_e.htm (Accessed: 11 November 2026).
World Trade Organization (n.d.) Alternative Dispute Resolution Procedures [online]. Available at: https://www.wto.org/english/tratop_e/dispu_e/mpia_e.htm (Accessed: 11 November 2026).
World Trade Organization (n.d.) Dispute settlement activity — some figures [online]. Available at: https://www.wto.org/english/tratop_e/dispu_e/dispustats_e.htm (Accessed: 11 November 2026).

