Deep Sea Mining and International Law: Who Controls the Ocean Floor?
Introduction
Deep sea mining is the extraction of mineral deposits from the deep ocean floor, where polymetallic nodules, metal-rich crusts, and mineral deposits associated with hydrothermal vents contain commercially valuable resources. Whether these minerals can legally be extracted depends primarily on where they are located. Coastal states exercise sovereign rights over mineral resources on their continental shelves, while mining beyond national jurisdiction is governed by a separate international legal regime established under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS).
The distinction is central to understanding who controls the ocean floor. The seabed beyond national jurisdiction, legally known as the Area, and its mineral resources are designated the common heritage of humankind. Under UNCLOS, the International Seabed Authority (ISA) organizes and controls mineral-related activities in the Area on behalf of humanity as a whole. It is not a system in which any state or mining company can simply claim ownership of an unoccupied part of the seabed.
The legality of commercial extraction remains a pressing question. Although the ISA has authorized mineral exploration through contracts, it has not approved commercial exploitation, and negotiations over the regulations governing that activity remain unfinished. Meanwhile, the United States, which is not a party to UNCLOS, maintains a domestic licensing framework for mining beyond national jurisdiction. Norway has pursued a separate policy concerning mineral resources on its own continental shelf.
These developments expose several legal questions: the distinction between exploration and exploitation, the powers of international institutions, the responsibilities of sponsoring states, and the environmental obligations that apply before and during mineral extraction. They also show why the legality of deep sea mining cannot be answered without identifying the location of the proposed activity and the legal authority under which it would proceed.
1. What Is Deep Sea Mining?
Deep sea mining involves recovering mineral resources from the seabed at considerable ocean depths. The deposits attracting the greatest commercial interest occur in environments that are technically difficult to access and often poorly understood. Proposed operations generally involve remotely operated collection equipment, specialized vessels, and systems for transporting recovered material to the surface.
The term covers several kinds of mineral extraction, but most current international attention concerns polymetallic nodules lying on abyssal plains. These deposits contain metals used in industrial manufacturing, electrical equipment, batteries, and other technologies. Their economic appeal has encouraged exploration programs, environmental surveys, and the development of equipment intended for eventual commercial recovery.
Exploration, testing, and commercial extraction must nevertheless be distinguished. Mapping mineral deposits, collecting samples, and conducting authorized equipment trials do not necessarily amount to commercial mining. The distinction is particularly significant under international law because the ISA has established regulations for exploration while continuing to negotiate the framework governing commercial exploitation.
1.1 Polymetallic Nodules and Other Seabed Minerals
Polymetallic nodules are mineral formations found on the sediment surface of some deep-ocean plains. They contain varying concentrations of manganese, nickel, copper, and cobalt. The Clarion-Clipperton Zone in the Pacific Ocean has attracted considerable attention because of its extensive nodule deposits and the number of exploration activities conducted there.
Other proposed mining targets include polymetallic sulfides associated with hydrothermal systems and cobalt-rich ferromanganese crusts found on underwater elevations such as seamounts. These deposits differ in their geological formation, distribution, physical characteristics, and potential methods of extraction. Their environmental implications also differ because the habitats in which they occur are not interchangeable.
The mining method therefore influences the nature of the disturbance. Collecting nodules can remove hard surfaces used by seabed organisms and disturb underlying sediments. Mining sulfide deposits or crusts may affect other specialized environments. These differences are relevant to environmental impact assessments and regulatory decisions, even where the same general principles of marine environmental protection apply.
2. Who Controls Minerals on the Ocean Floor?
International law does not treat the entire ocean floor as a single legal space. Rights over seabed minerals depend on the maritime zone concerned, the extent of coastal-state entitlements, and whether a deposit lies within or beyond national jurisdiction. Ocean depth alone does not determine which legal regime applies.
UNCLOS establishes the principal geographical and legal distinctions. A coastal state has sovereign rights over the natural resources of its continental shelf, including relevant mineral deposits. Beyond the limits of national jurisdiction, the Area falls under the international regime established by Part XI of the Convention and the 1994 Agreement relating to the Implementation of Part XI.
The distinction between the water column and the seabed is equally important. An area of water may be part of the high seas while the seabed beneath it remains subject to a coastal state's continental-shelf rights. Conversely, a seabed area beyond the outer limits of national continental shelves belongs to the Area. These divisions are explained more broadly in the law of the sea framework.
2.1 Coastal-State Rights Over the Continental Shelf
Article 77 of UNCLOS provides that a coastal state exercises sovereign rights over its continental shelf for the purpose of exploring and exploiting natural resources. Those rights are exclusive: another state or private operator cannot lawfully undertake resource exploitation on that shelf without the coastal state's consent.
These rights exist by virtue of the coastal state's entitlement to the continental shelf. They do not depend on occupation or an express declaration of ownership. The International Court of Justice recognized the inherent character of continental-shelf rights in the North Sea Continental Shelf cases of 1969, a principle reflected in Article 77 of UNCLOS.
The continental shelf may extend beyond 200 nautical miles where the applicable geological and legal criteria are satisfied. Article 76 regulates the establishment of its outer limits, including the role of the Commission on the Limits of the Continental Shelf. Consequently, an area beyond a state's exclusive economic zone is not necessarily part of the international seabed Area.
Control over shelf minerals is not unlimited territorial sovereignty. The coastal state's rights relate to the seabed and subsoil, while the legal status of the waters above is governed separately. The relationship between these rights and the exclusive economic zone is especially relevant where mineral activities occur within 200 nautical miles of the coast.
2.2 The Area and the Common Heritage of Humankind
Article 136 of UNCLOS declares that the Area and its resources are the common heritage of humankind. Article 137 prohibits claims or exercises of sovereignty or sovereign rights over any part of the Area or its resources. It also prevents states and private persons from appropriating those resources outside the arrangements established by the Convention.
The common-heritage principle has a specific legal consequence: rights over the mineral resources of the Area are vested in humankind as a whole, on whose behalf the ISA acts. Mineral activities are therefore subject to an international system of organization, authorization, and control rather than unilateral acquisition of seabed territory.
The principle emerged before UNCLOS. United Nations General Assembly Resolution 2749 (XXV), adopted in 1970, declared the seabed beyond national jurisdiction and its resources to be the common heritage of humankind. The resolution was not itself a treaty. The subsequent Convention and its 1994 Implementing Agreement established the detailed treaty framework governing activities in the Area.
The system also has a distributive purpose. Article 140 requires activities in the Area to be carried out for the benefit of humankind as a whole, with particular consideration for developing states. This does not mean that every country receives physical possession of minerals or an immediate share of mining profits. It establishes the legal basis for collective administration and equitable economic arrangements.
3. Who Authorizes Mining in the International Seabed?
Under the UNCLOS regime, the International Seabed Authority is responsible for organizing and controlling mineral-related activities in the Area. Established under the Convention, the ISA operates through institutions with distinct regulatory, administrative, technical, and decision-making functions. Its mandate concerns the international seabed, not mineral extraction on every continental shelf.
An operator cannot obtain the same legal position merely by identifying a mineral deposit or conducting research. Exploration and exploitation involve formal procedures, approved plans of work, and contracts within the ISA system. The applicable requirements differ according to the proposed activity and the stage of mineral development.
The Authority's functions are closely connected to the wider legal rules governing international waters and maritime jurisdiction. However, the Area is not synonymous with the high seas. The ISA's mineral jurisdiction concerns the seabed and subsoil beyond national jurisdiction, whereas activities in the waters above remain subject to the relevant law of the sea provisions.
3.1 The ISA Council and Regulatory Decision-Making
The ISA Council performs a central role in the regulation of mineral activities. Its responsibilities include considering plans of work, overseeing compliance, and developing regulatory measures within the framework of UNCLOS and the 1994 Agreement. The Legal and Technical Commission provides specialized assessments and recommendations that inform the Council's decisions.
The ISA has adopted regulations governing exploration for principal categories of seabed minerals. Commercial exploitation requires additional arrangements addressing operational requirements, environmental standards, inspection, financial terms, and compliance. These elements form part of the wider collection of instruments commonly described as the Mining Code.
During its 31st session in 2026, the ISA continued negotiations on exploitation regulations without completing their adoption. The Council requested further work on outstanding issues and preparations for consideration during the 32nd session. Environmental thresholds, regulatory implementation, and financial benefit sharing remained among the subjects requiring further institutional consideration.
The unfinished regulations do not eliminate the legal rules already established by UNCLOS. The Authority's mandate, the common-heritage principle, environmental obligations, and existing exploration arrangements continue to operate. Nevertheless, the absence of a completed exploitation framework creates significant legal and administrative difficulties for proposals seeking to move from exploration to commercial extraction.
3.2 Sponsoring States and Mining Contractors
Private companies cannot ordinarily participate in ISA-regulated mineral activities independently of the Convention's sponsorship arrangements. Article 153 permits activities to be undertaken by eligible entities in association with a sponsoring state, subject to approved plans of work and the other requirements of the international regime.
Sponsorship connects the contractor's activities to the international responsibilities of a state party. The sponsoring state must establish and maintain appropriate legal and administrative measures to secure compliance with applicable obligations. Its role is not satisfied simply by issuing a sponsorship certificate and leaving the contractor to operate without effective supervision.
The contractual relationship also imposes obligations on the ISA. Contractors holding exploration contracts have rights under the relevant legal instruments and contractual terms, although these rights do not amount to unconditional authorization for commercial mining. Regulatory decisions must be taken within the powers and procedures established by the Convention.
These questions became the subject of proceedings before the Seabed Disputes Chamber of the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea in 2026. In Nauru Ocean Resources Inc. v. International Seabed Authority and Tonga Offshore Mining Ltd. v. International Seabed Authority, the contractors challenged aspects of an ISA inquiry concerning possible noncompliance with exploration-contract obligations.
On July 18, 2026, the Chamber prescribed provisional measures requiring the Authority to observe the applicable legal framework, including due process, and requiring cooperation to prevent aggravation of the disputes. In the Nauru proceedings, it also addressed procedural fairness in the consideration of the contractor's exploration-contract extension.
Those orders did not decide whether the contractors had breached their obligations, determine the merits of the disputes, or authorize commercial extraction. They nonetheless demonstrate that ISA decisions concerning contractors are subject to legal scrutiny and that the Authority's regulatory discretion must be exercised within the limits established by UNCLOS.
3.3 The Distribution of Economic Benefits
The financial distribution of seabed-mining benefits is one of the distinctive features of the international regime. Article 140 of UNCLOS requires equitable sharing of financial and other economic benefits derived from activities in the Area through appropriate mechanisms. The obligation reflects the understanding that the international seabed's mineral wealth cannot be treated exclusively as a national or private asset.
Designing such arrangements involves difficult questions concerning royalties, payment structures, administrative costs, and the allocation of benefits among states. Developing countries and landlocked states have particular interests in ensuring that the common-heritage principle produces meaningful economic consequences rather than remaining a declaration without practical effect.
As of 2026, the ISA had not authorized commercial mineral extraction, and a system distributing proceeds from such production was not operational. This should not be confused with the Authority's existing institutional income or financial arrangements associated with exploration. The ISA continued examining possible mechanisms for distributing future exploitation benefits, including proposals involving a Common Heritage Fund.
4. Is Commercial Deep Sea Mining Legal?
Deep sea mining is not categorically prohibited by international law. UNCLOS establishes a system under which mineral exploration and exploitation may be undertaken, subject to the applicable legal requirements. The existence of that system, however, does not mean that commercial extraction is presently authorized wherever a company identifies a deposit.
Within national jurisdiction, the relevant coastal state may regulate mineral exploitation on its continental shelf, subject to its international obligations. In the Area, the UNCLOS regime places mineral activities under ISA organization and control. For states outside the Convention, the international legal implications of unilateral authorization raise separate and contested questions.
The distinction between authorization and actual operations is essential. An exploration contract permits activities within its agreed terms; it does not automatically entitle the contractor to begin commercial production. Likewise, an application for exploitation is not itself a license, and regulatory consideration does not establish that all environmental or operational requirements have been satisfied.
As of November 2026, no commercial exploitation project had been approved under the ISA framework. Exploration and authorized testing have continued, but the regulations intended to govern commercial extraction remain under negotiation. The legal position is consequently more precise than either a general prohibition or an unrestricted permission to mine.
4.1 Nauru's Two-Year Notice and the Mining Code
A major difficulty arose from the procedure contained in section 1, paragraph 15, of the Annex to the 1994 Agreement relating to the Implementation of Part XI of UNCLOS. Under that provision, a qualifying state may request the completion of exploitation regulations within two years when its national intends to seek approval of a plan of work for exploitation.
Nauru invoked the procedure in 2021, with the notification taking effect on July 9 of that year. The two-year period expired on July 9, 2023, before the ISA Council had completed the exploitation regulations. This intensified disagreement over how applications should be handled in the absence of a comprehensive regulatory framework.
Paragraph 15(c) provides for the consideration and provisional approval of a pending plan of work by reference to the Convention and applicable regulatory principles when the prescribed period has expired without completed rules. The provision therefore has legal consequences for the Council's consideration of applications. It does not, however, itself issue an exploitation contract or authorize a company to begin mining automatically.
In Decision ISBA/28/C/25 of July 21, 2023, the ISA Council addressed the application of the provision and the steps to be taken if an exploitation plan were submitted before the regulations were completed. The decision reflected the need to reconcile the treaty procedure with the Council's responsibilities under the wider legal regime, including environmental protection.
The resulting question remains significant: how can an application be evaluated when important operational, environmental, and financial requirements are still being developed? The answer cannot rest solely on the expiration of a deadline. It requires interpretation of the 1994 Agreement alongside UNCLOS, the Council's applicable decisions, and the legal safeguards governing activities in the Area.
5. Environmental Protection and Responsibility for Harm
Deep-seabed mineral extraction poses environmental questions that are central to its legal regulation. Mining equipment can disturb sediments, remove mineral formations that provide habitat, and generate sediment plumes. Possible effects also depend on the location, technology, duration, and scale of operations.
Article 145 of UNCLOS requires measures to ensure effective protection of the marine environment from harmful effects arising from activities in the Area. This obligation informs the ISA's regulatory responsibilities and the development of environmental requirements. It is supported by wider duties concerning the protection and preservation of the marine environment under Part XII of the Convention.
The legal framework does not require proof that every possible environmental effect is already understood before protective obligations become relevant. Instead, scientific uncertainty must be addressed through the applicable standards of care, environmental assessment, monitoring, and regulatory decision-making. The relationship between prevention, precaution, and state responsibility is also central to international environmental law.
5.1 Scientific Uncertainty and Environmental Assessments
Deep-ocean ecosystems present particular difficulties for environmental assessment. Many species remain insufficiently studied, ecological processes may operate over long periods, and physical disturbances can persist after equipment has left the seabed. Baseline surveys are therefore important for distinguishing mining-related effects from natural environmental variation.
A study by Jones and colleagues, published in Nature in 2025, examined a seabed area affected by experimental mining in 1979. The researchers found that physical traces remained decades later and that biological recovery varied among groups of organisms. The findings support concern about long-term disturbance without establishing that every ecological effect is necessarily irreversible.
Research on a more recent industrial-scale equipment trial has supplied additional evidence. Stewart and colleagues, writing in Nature Ecology & Evolution, reported reductions of 37% in macrofaunal density and 32% in species richness directly within the tracks examined after a mining trial. The results concern the investigated locations and sampling period; they cannot independently establish the full consequences of sustained commercial production across a wider region.
Scientific uncertainty also concerns impacts beyond the directly disturbed seabed. Sediment plumes may affect organisms outside collection tracks, while the consequences of noise, light, and repeated operations require evaluation according to the relevant conditions. Findings from one type of mineral deposit or mining method cannot automatically be transferred to another.
Environmental impact assessments must therefore examine the particular proposed activity and its reasonably foreseeable effects. Under the ISA regime, that includes the collection of baseline information, assessment of environmental risks, and consideration of measures to avoid, reduce, or control harm. Monitoring becomes especially important where ecological changes may emerge after the initial disturbance.
Calls for a precautionary pause or moratorium reflect concern that the available knowledge may be inadequate for responsible commercial authorization. Such positions have been advanced by governments and other participants in ocean governance, but they are not equivalent to a universally binding prohibition on deep sea mining. Their legal significance must be distinguished from the treaty obligations already in force.
5.2 Sponsoring-State Duties, Liability, and Compensation
The Seabed Disputes Chamber clarified important aspects of sponsoring-state responsibility in its 2011 advisory opinion, Responsibilities and Obligations of States Sponsoring Persons and Entities with Respect to Activities in the Area. The opinion distinguishes the state's obligation to seek compliance by a sponsored contractor from obligations that the state must perform directly.
The obligation to ensure contractor compliance is one of due diligence rather than an absolute guarantee of results. Sponsoring states must take appropriate measures within their legal systems and exercise the supervision required by the applicable circumstances. The standard is demanding, but the mere occurrence of damage does not establish that a state failed to meet it.
The Chamber also identified direct obligations concerning cooperation with the ISA, precautionary measures, best environmental practices, environmental impact assessment, and other requirements arising under the relevant instruments. These obligations operate independently of whether the contractor itself ultimately complies with every contractual duty.
Liability must be analyzed separately from the existence of a regulatory obligation. The advisory opinion explains that a sponsoring state's liability for damage is linked to its own failure to fulfill its responsibilities. A causal connection between that failure and the damage must be established; it cannot simply be presumed from the contractor's conduct.
This distinction leaves important practical questions concerning compensation. Environmental damage in remote marine environments may be difficult to measure, attribute, and remedy. The availability of effective claims, the responsibility of contractors, and the adequacy of financial arrangements consequently remain significant issues in the development of the exploitation regime.
The 2011 advisory opinion provides authoritative legal guidance, but it is not a judgment assigning liability for a particular mining incident. It also does not resolve every future question of environmental loss. The distinction between treaty-based obligations, contractor liability, and the broader rules of customary international law remains relevant where claims extend beyond the specific mechanisms established by UNCLOS.
6. The United States and Seabed Mining Outside the ISA System
The United States occupies a distinctive position in seabed-mining governance. It participated in the development of the modern law of the sea but has not become a party to UNCLOS. Consequently, it does not participate in the ISA system as a state party, although its position does not remove every possible international-law obligation concerning ocean activities.
U.S. legislation establishes a domestic process for authorizing certain seabed mineral activities beyond national jurisdiction. The Deep Seabed Hard Mineral Resources Act of 1980 provides for exploration licenses and commercial recovery permits administered by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA).
The relationship between this domestic system and the UNCLOS regime is contested. A permit may provide authority under U.S. law while leaving unresolved whether the authorized activity is compatible with international rules asserted by other states. The distinction has become more important as U.S. regulatory proceedings have advanced toward potential commercial recovery.
6.1 The 2025 Executive Order and NOAA Licensing
On April 24, 2025, the U.S. president issued Executive Order 14285, Unleashing America's Offshore Critical Minerals and Resources. The order directed federal authorities to advance seabed mineral exploration and commercial recovery within the powers provided by existing U.S. law. It did not itself grant a mining permit or amend the United States' treaty status under UNCLOS.
NOAA subsequently revised its implementing regulations. A final rule issued on January 21, 2026, introduced a consolidated process through which eligible applicants could seek an exploration license and commercial recovery permit together. The governing legislation and regulations continue to distinguish these authorizations and impose separate requirements before they may be issued.
The statutory category of hard mineral resources is narrower than deep sea mining as a whole. Under the Deep Seabed Hard Mineral Resources Act, NOAA's licensing framework concerns polymetallic nodules containing specified metals. It does not extend to polymetallic sulfides or cobalt-rich crusts, which are distinct categories of seabed mineral deposits.
As of November 2026, NOAA listed two existing exploration licenses, USA-1 and USA-4, held by Lockheed Martin. It listed no issued commercial recovery permits. Several newer applications were undergoing review, including applications submitted by The Metals Company USA and other prospective exploration operators.
The regulatory position of The Metals Company USA illustrates why application stages must be distinguished. NOAA certified the company's USA-B exploration application on May 26, 2026, an intermediate determination that did not itself issue an exploration license. NOAA also determined that a separate consolidated application satisfied the applicable information requirements, allowing that application to proceed through further review.
In a November 2026 filing with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, The Metals Company reported that NOAA expected to communicate its certification decision on the consolidated application by mid-December 2026. That anticipated timetable was not a legal deadline or an indication that a final commercial recovery permit had been granted.
Environmental review remains a separate and material component of the process. Even after certification, NOAA must undertake the required assessment and determine whether the requested authorization should be issued and on what conditions. Domestic legal challenges have also arisen concerning aspects of the U.S. permitting process, demonstrating that federal approval decisions may be contested within the United States independently of the international-law objections.
6.2 Unilateral Permits and International Legal Objections
The central international-law disagreement concerns whether a state outside UNCLOS may authorize mineral exploitation in the Area without participating in the ISA system. The United States maintains a domestic legal framework that permits such authorizations, subject to statutory conditions and the international obligations it recognizes as applicable.
UNCLOS states parties are bound by the treaty's provisions concerning the Area and the ISA. The legal position of nonparties requires additional analysis. A treaty does not ordinarily impose obligations on a nonparty merely because other states have accepted it, but certain rules reflected in a treaty may also exist under customary international law.
The customary status and precise reach of seabed-mining principles are consequently important. The prohibition on territorial appropriation, the common-heritage concept, and the ISA's exclusive regulatory role under the treaty system must be examined according to their respective legal bases. They should not be treated as identical propositions with automatically identical effects on every state.
Supporters of unilateral licensing emphasize the United States' nonparty status and its domestic authorization system. Opponents argue that commercial extraction outside the ISA framework would undermine collective administration of the Area and the common-heritage regime. These positions represent conflicting interpretations of applicable international law, not the outcome of a definitive judicial ruling resolving the dispute.
In 2026, the ISA Assembly considered the possibility of seeking an advisory opinion from the Seabed Disputes Chamber concerning activities in the Area undertaken outside the UNCLOS framework. The matter remained under discussion. The consideration of such a request did not itself constitute a judicial determination of the legality of U.S. licensing.
The practical consequence is a potential divergence between domestic authorization and international acceptance. A company might receive permission from U.S. authorities while facing objections from states that regard ISA authorization as indispensable. That uncertainty concerns the legal basis of the activity itself, not merely its commercial prospects.
7. Norway's Seabed Mining Policy and National Jurisdiction
Norway presents a different legal situation because its seabed-mining initiative concerns mineral resources on the Norwegian continental shelf. Those resources fall within an area where Norway exercises sovereign rights under the law of the sea. The ISA's system for the Area does not replace the coastal state's authority over its own continental-shelf minerals.
Norway's domestic framework is based on the Seabed Minerals Act of March 22, 2019, which entered into force later that year. The legislation provides the basis for regulating mineral activities on the continental shelf. It operates alongside Norway's obligations under UNCLOS and other applicable international environmental agreements.
In January 2024, the Norwegian Parliament supported the government's proposal to open an area of the continental shelf for seabed mineral activities. The government formally opened the relevant area in the Norwegian Sea and Greenland Sea on April 12, 2024. Opening an area, however, was a preliminary regulatory decision rather than permission for immediate commercial extraction.
Norway subsequently prepared a proposed first licensing round, but the political position changed. Following parliamentary negotiations concerning the 2026 state budget, the government confirmed in December 2025 that it would not announce the first licensing round during the current parliamentary term. As of November 2026, that position remained in place.
The postponement should not be described as a permanent statutory prohibition on seabed mining. Nor does the earlier decision to open an area establish that extraction has been approved. Norway's system involves successive decisions concerning access, exploration, environmental assessment, and any eventual development of mineral resources.
Although Norway exercises coastal-state rights over the relevant minerals, those rights remain subject to international environmental obligations. Under UNCLOS, states must protect and preserve the marine environment and regulate activities under their jurisdiction in accordance with applicable legal standards. National control does not eliminate the duty to evaluate potentially harmful consequences.
The Norwegian example demonstrates that the principal legal question changes with geography. Within the continental shelf, the immediate authorization decision belongs to the coastal state, subject to international law. In the Area, the UNCLOS regime assigns a central role to the ISA. Political disagreement over the desirability of mining may arise in either setting, but the legal source of authority is not the same.
Conclusion
Control of the ocean floor is divided by international law rather than determined by technological capability or the discovery of valuable minerals. Coastal states exercise sovereign rights over mineral resources on their continental shelves. Beyond national jurisdiction, UNCLOS establishes the Area as the common heritage of humankind and assigns the International Seabed Authority responsibility for organizing and controlling mineral activities under its treaty regime.
Commercial deep sea mining is legally contemplated by UNCLOS, but that does not make extraction automatically permissible. The ISA has authorized exploration without approving commercial exploitation, and the regulations governing that activity remained unfinished in November 2026. Environmental duties, sponsoring-state responsibilities, and the procedural rights of contractors continue to apply within the existing framework.
The contrasting approaches of the United States and Norway illustrate the limits of any single answer to whether deep sea mining is legal. Norway's decisions concern resources within national jurisdiction, while unilateral U.S. licensing beyond national jurisdiction raises contested international-law questions. Ultimately, lawful extraction depends on the location of the minerals, the authority issuing permission, the obligations applicable to the operator and responsible states, and compliance with the environmental protections governing the activity.
References
Agreement relating to the Implementation of Part XI of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea of 10 December 1982 (1994) Adopted 28 July 1994, entered into force 28 July 1996, 1836 UNTS 3. Available at: https://treaties.un.org/Pages/showDetails.aspx?objid=0800000280045372 (Accessed: 16 November 2026).
Deep Seabed Hard Mineral Resources Act (1980) Public Law 96-283, 28 June 1980, 94 Stat. 553, codified at 30 U.S.C. §§ 1401–1473. Available at: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/STATUTE-94/pdf/STATUTE-94-Pg553.pdf (Accessed: 16 November 2026).
Executive Order 14285 (2025) Unleashing America’s Offshore Critical Minerals and Resources, 24 April 2025, 90 Federal Register 17735, 29 April 2025. Available at: https://www.govinfo.gov/link/fr/90/17735 (Accessed: 16 November 2026).
International Court of Justice (1969) North Sea Continental Shelf (Federal Republic of Germany/Denmark; Federal Republic of Germany/Netherlands), Judgment, 20 February 1969, ICJ Reports 1969, p. 3. Available at: https://www.refworld.org/jurisprudence/caselaw/icj/1969/88828 (Accessed: 16 November 2026).
International Seabed Authority (2023) Decision of the Council of the International Seabed Authority relating to the understanding and application of section 1, paragraph 15, of the annex to the Agreement relating to the Implementation of Part XI of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, ISBA/28/C/25, 21 July 2023. Available at: https://isa.org.jm/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/Session_selected_decisions_28_EN.pdf (Accessed: 16 November 2026).
International Seabed Authority (2026a) From the 31st to the 32nd Session: Advancing the Mining Code and Strengthening the Common Heritage of Humankind [online]. 19 September 2026. Available at: https://isa.org.jm/news/from-the-31st-to-the-32nd-session-advancing-the-mining-code-and-strengthening-the-common-heritage-of-humankind/ (Accessed: 16 November 2026).
International Seabed Authority (2026b) Q&A on the ISA [online]. Updated 1 July 2026. Available at: https://isa.org.jm/faq-for-media/ (Accessed: 16 November 2026).
International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea, Seabed Disputes Chamber (2011) Responsibilities and Obligations of States Sponsoring Persons and Entities with Respect to Activities in the Area, Advisory Opinion, 1 February 2011, Case No. 17, ITLOS Reports 2011, p. 10. Available at: https://www.itlos.org/fileadmin/itlos/documents/cases/case_no_17/17_adv_op_010211_en.pdf (Accessed: 16 November 2026).
International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea, Seabed Disputes Chamber (2026a) Case Concerning an Inquiry by the International Seabed Authority (Nauru Ocean Resources Inc. v. International Seabed Authority), Order on Provisional Measures, 18 July 2026, Case No. 34. Available at: https://www.itlos.org/fileadmin/itlos/documents/cases/34/Provisional_Measures/Order_180726/C34_Order_18.07.2026_orig.pdf (Accessed: 16 November 2026).
International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea, Seabed Disputes Chamber (2026b) Case Concerning an Inquiry by the International Seabed Authority (Tonga Offshore Mining Ltd. v. International Seabed Authority), Order on Provisional Measures, 18 July 2026, Case No. 35. Available at: https://www.itlos.org/fileadmin/itlos/documents/cases/35/Provisional_Measures/Order_180726/C35_Order_18.07.2026_orig.pdf (Accessed: 16 November 2026).
Jones, D.O.B., Arias, M.B., Van Audenhaege, L. et al. (2025) ‘Long-term impact and biological recovery in a deep-sea mining track’, Nature, 642, pp. 112–118. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-025-08921-3 (Accessed: 16 November 2026).
Lov om mineralvirksomhet på kontinentalsokkelen (havbunnsmineralloven) (2019) Norwegian Seabed Minerals Act, Act No. 7 of 22 March 2019, entered into force 1 July 2019. Available at: https://lovdata.no/lov/2019-03-22-7 (Accessed: 16 November 2026).
Ministry of Energy, Norway (2024) Public Consultation of the First Licensing Round for Seabed Minerals [online]. 26 June 2024, updated 18 December 2025. Available at: https://www.regjeringen.no/en/whats-new/public-consultation-of-the-first-licensing-round-for-seabed-minerals/id3047008/ (Accessed: 16 November 2026).
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (2026a) Deep Seabed Hard Minerals Mining [online]. Updated 16 October 2026. Available at: https://oceanservice.noaa.gov/deep-seabed-mineral-resources/deep-seabed-mining/ (Accessed: 16 November 2026).
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (2026b) ‘Deep Seabed Mining: Revisions to Regulations for Exploration License and Commercial Recovery Permit Applications’, Final Rule, 21 January 2026, 91 Federal Register 2642–2677, 15 CFR Parts 970 and 971. Available at: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2026-01-21/html/2026-01044.htm (Accessed: 16 November 2026).
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (2026c) NOAA Advances Review of First-Ever Deep Seabed Mining Commercial Recovery Application [online]. 19 August 2026. Available at: https://www.noaa.gov/news-release/noaa-advances-review-of-first-ever-deep-seabed-mining-commercial-recovery-application (Accessed: 16 November 2026).
Stewart, E.C.D., Wiklund, H., Neal, L. et al. (2026) ‘Impacts of an industrial deep-sea mining trial on macrofaunal biodiversity’, Nature Ecology & Evolution, 10, pp. 318–329. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41559-025-02911-4 (Accessed: 16 November 2026).
The Metals Company Inc. (2026a) Current Report on Form 8-K, 9 November 2026. United States Securities and Exchange Commission. Available at: https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1798562/000110465926124241/tm2629328d1_8k.htm (Accessed: 16 November 2026).
The Metals Company Inc. (2026b) Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q for the Quarter Ended 30 September 2026. United States Securities and Exchange Commission. Available at: https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1798562/000162828026073463/tmc-20260930.htm (Accessed: 16 November 2026).
United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (1982) Adopted at Montego Bay, 10 December 1982, entered into force 16 November 1994, 1833 UNTS 3. Available at: https://treaties.un.org/pages/showdetails.aspx?objid=0800000280043ad5 (Accessed: 16 November 2026).
United Nations General Assembly (1970) Declaration of Principles Governing the Sea-Bed and the Ocean Floor, and the Subsoil Thereof, beyond the Limits of National Jurisdiction, Resolution 2749 (XXV), A/RES/2749(XXV), 17 December 1970. Available at: https://mandates.un.org/mandate/A/RES/2749%28XXV%29 (Accessed: 16 November 2026).

