top of page

Middle East Airspace Closures: Who Decides and What Passengers Are Owed

1 day ago
31 min read

Introduction


When a flight alert states that Middle Eastern airspace is closed, the explanation may refer to several different legal and operational situations. A notice reading "airspace closed" may indicate a government-imposed prohibition, a regional aviation safety warning, or an airline's decision to suspend operations because of security risks. Each situation can interrupt international travel, but the authority behind it and the consequences for passengers are different.


As of November 10, 2026, the European Union Aviation Safety Agency (EASA) has six active conflict-zone bulletins concerning Iran, Iraq, Lebanon, Jordan, Saudi Arabia, and parts of the Persian Gulf and Gulf of Oman. These advisories remain valid until November 16 unless reviewed earlier. They do not establish that every affected country has formally closed its airspace or that commercial flights will resume when the bulletins expire (EASA, 2026, CZIB-2026-04-R2 to CZIB-2026-09-R1).


Passengers affected by flight cancellations may retain substantial legal protections. Under Regulation (EC) No. 261/2004, commonly known as EU261, eligible travelers generally have rights to reimbursement or rerouting and applicable assistance during disruption. Armed conflict and genuine aviation security threats may relieve airlines from paying additional standardized compensation, but the exception does not ordinarily remove their separate obligations to passengers.


The legal position rests on two connected systems. International aviation law determines who may control access to airspace and how civil aviation risks are managed. Passenger-protection legislation establishes the financial and practical remedies available when those decisions prevent a scheduled journey from taking place.


1. Where Do Middle East Airspace Warnings Apply?


The Middle East is not subject to a single international airspace closure. EASA's current warnings distinguish between regions where it recommends avoiding operations, areas where avoidance advice applies only to particular corridors, and airspace where operators are advised to exercise heightened caution. These recommendations must be distinguished from legally binding restrictions imposed by national authorities.


The affected areas are generally identified through Flight Information Regions, commonly abbreviated as FIRs. These are defined areas within which flight information and alerting services are provided. Their boundaries do not necessarily correspond to national borders, and responsibility for providing air traffic services does not itself establish sovereignty over the entire region.


The principal dangers arise from military activity capable of affecting civilian aviation. Ballistic missiles, drones, air-defense systems, and military aircraft may create risks of misidentification, unintended engagement, or damage from falling debris. Civil aircraft may encounter these hazards during overflight, approach, departure, or ground operations.


EASA's advisories concern aviation safety rather than the legal status of every national airspace restriction. An affected airport may remain operational while surrounding routes are avoided. Similarly, a commercial airline may cancel flights to a destination that remains legally accessible because the airline considers the available route unsafe.


1.1 Iran, Iraq, and Lebanon


EASA's current bulletins for Iran and Iraq recommend that affected operators avoid the Tehran and Baghdad Flight Information Regions at every altitude. The recommendations reflect the hazards associated with regional hostilities, including missile operations, air-defense activity, and the possibility of civilian aircraft encountering military threats without sufficient warning (EASA, 2026, CZIB-2026-04-R2 and CZIB-2026-05-R2).


The recommendations apply to operators governed by the relevant European aviation rules and qualifying third-country operators conducting flights under EASA authorization. They do not themselves establish that the Iranian or Iraqi governments have prohibited every international civilian overflight. Any binding national restrictions must be assessed separately through the competent aviation authorities and their official aeronautical information.


Lebanon is subject to a similarly extensive avoidance recommendation, but with a significant qualification. EASA recognizes a limited exception for qualifying arrivals at and departures from Beirut International Airport using approaches and departures over the sea. These operations depend on updated risk assessments and continuous monitoring of the security situation (EASA, 2026, CZIB-2026-06-R2).


The distinction affects passengers traveling beyond the immediate conflict area. A flight may be canceled because its planned route crosses dangerous Iranian or Iraqi airspace even though its destination is elsewhere. Commercial disruption may also result from economic restrictions rather than safety prohibitions, as illustrated by the separate legal questions concerning Iranian airline sanctions and international flight permissions.


1.2 Jordan, Saudi Arabia, and the Gulf States


Jordan illustrates why a regional aviation warning cannot be treated as a permanent prohibition. On October 14, 2026, EASA revised Conflict Zone Information Bulletin CZIB-2026-08-R3 following an improvement in the assessed security situation. The revised bulletin no longer recommends avoiding the entire Amman Flight Information Region.


EASA reported that no kinetic military activity affecting Jordanian airspace had been identified between September 9 and the October 14 revision. It nevertheless warned that renewed hostilities could produce a rapid deterioration. Operators were advised to maintain risk assessments, contingency planning, and close monitoring of official instructions (EASA, 2026, CZIB-2026-08-R3).


Saudi Arabia presents a different situation. EASA's October 9 revision of its Saudi advisory recommends avoiding two specifically defined portions of the Jeddah Flight Information Region at every altitude while exercising caution elsewhere. The warning identifies risks arising from missile and drone operations, air-defense activity, and the possible misidentification of civilian aircraft (EASA, 2026, CZIB-2026-09-R1).


The security threat also extends to aviation infrastructure. Saudi Arabia's General Authority of Civil Aviation reported that King Khalid International Airport in Riyadh was targeted by another attack on October 11, 2026, resulting in injuries and prompting further assessments of airport facilities. The incidents form part of the wider security context examined in the analysis of the Riyadh airport attacks and the protection of civilian airports.


In the Persian Gulf, EASA differentiates between specified maritime airspace and routes over land. Its recommendations concern particular portions of the Bahrain, Kuwait, Doha, Emirates, and Muscat Flight Information Regions, including areas over the Persian Gulf and Gulf of Oman. Limited exceptions apply to necessary airport arrivals and departures, while operations elsewhere require continued caution and risk assessment (EASA, 2026, CZIB-2026-07R3).


These geographical distinctions explain why major Gulf aviation hubs can continue operating during regional security warnings. An airport may remain accessible even when a nearby maritime corridor is unsuitable for ordinary overflight. Airlines serving the same destination may use different routes or reach different operational decisions under the safety requirements governing their services.


1.3 Syria, Yemen, and Israel


Additional EASA conflict-zone bulletins remain active for Syria and Yemen, independently of the six advisories scheduled to expire on November 16. Syria's bulletin, revised on October 1, 2026, is valid until November 30 unless reviewed earlier. It recommends avoiding operations at every altitude in a specified western portion of the Damascus Flight Information Region and below flight level 260 elsewhere in that region (EASA, 2026, CZIB-2017-03R20).


Yemen's advisory remains valid until April 30, 2027, unless revised earlier. EASA recommends avoiding operations throughout the Sana'a Flight Information Region, except for specified maritime routes east of route B400, where heightened caution is advised. The bulletin identifies persistent military activity and the availability of weapons capable of threatening civilian aircraft (EASA, 2026, CZIB-2017-07R20).


Israel is covered by a separate EASA Information Note concerning the Tel Aviv Flight Information Region. The publicly available advisory summary, valid until November 16, advises operators to consider the relevant risks in their assessments and routing decisions. Information Notes generally address airspace assessed as presenting medium risk, whereas Conflict Zone Information Bulletins primarily concern areas identified as high risk (EASA, 2026, Conflict Zones Information Notes).


The regional position cannot be reduced to a single expiration date or a uniform prohibition. Operators must assess the applicable geographical boundaries, altitudes, current recommendations, and national restrictions. A warning affecting an FIR does not automatically establish that every civilian flight within that region is legally prohibited.


2. When Will Flights Resume?


November 16, 2026, is the current validity deadline for six EASA Middle East conflict-zone bulletins. It is not a date on which governments have collectively agreed to reopen their airspace or airlines have committed to restore normal schedules. EASA may extend, revise, or withdraw its recommendations following further assessments of regional security conditions.


The expiration of an advisory also differs from the withdrawal of a national airspace prohibition. Governments communicate binding restrictions through their aviation authorities and official aeronautical information systems. Such measures may remain in force independently of EASA's recommendations, while airlines must also observe applicable instructions from their own national regulators.


Changes in military activity can alter the operational assessment before a bulletin expires. A reduction in missile launches may diminish immediate risks without removing concerns about air-defense activity, unstable military coordination, or renewed hostilities. Conversely, improved security conditions may justify allowing carefully controlled operations in areas previously subject to broad avoidance recommendations.


The restoration of legal access does not necessarily produce an immediate return to normal schedules. Aircraft and crews may have been repositioned, connecting flights disrupted, and alternative routes subjected to additional demand. An airline may also continue suspending a service because it has not yet established that the available route satisfies its operational safety requirements.


For passengers, the decisive information concerns the status of their particular flight. Neither the expiration of an EASA bulletin nor the reopening of an airport guarantees that a scheduled departure will take place. Where the airline cancels a covered flight, the passenger's legal remedies arise from the applicable passenger-protection rules rather than from the announced duration of the regional warning.


3. Refunds and Rerouting Under EU261


Regulation (EC) No. 261/2004 establishes minimum rights when covered flights are canceled, substantially delayed, or affected by involuntary denied boarding. Its protections do not depend entirely on whether the airline caused the disruption. A carrier that cancels a service because of military activity may be exempt from standardized compensation while remaining responsible for reimbursement, alternative transportation, and applicable assistance (Regulation 261/2004, arts. 5, 8 and 9).


These remedies serve different purposes. Reimbursement returns the qualifying cost of transportation that has not been provided. Rerouting enables the passenger to complete the intended journey, while the duty of care addresses immediate needs during disruption. Standardized compensation provides a separate monetary remedy when its statutory conditions are satisfied.


The law applicable in November 2026 must also be distinguished from forthcoming European reforms. Regulation (EU) 2026/2202, adopted on September 16 and published on October 2, introduces amendments to the passenger-rights framework.

Although it entered into force in October 2026, Article 3 postpones application of its substantive provisions until October 23, 2027. Cancellations occurring in November 2026 remain governed by the existing EU261 rules and applicable Court of Justice jurisprudence.


3.1 Which Flights Qualify for EU261 Protection?


Article 3 establishes two principal geographical grounds for protection. Passengers departing from airports within the regulation's territorial scope are generally covered regardless of the operating airline's nationality. Passengers departing from third countries and arriving at covered airports are generally protected when the operating carrier is a qualifying EU carrier, subject to the regulation's conditions concerning benefits, compensation, and assistance already received in the third country.


Consider a flight from Dublin to Dubai. Because it departs from an EU airport, it falls within EU261's geographical scope whether operated by an Irish airline or a qualifying non-EU carrier. On the return journey, Dubai to Dublin, the operating carrier becomes decisive. A qualifying EU carrier can bring the inbound flight within the regulation, while an ordinary service operated by a UAE carrier does not qualify merely because it arrives in Ireland.


Connecting journeys require additional analysis. Where flights form part of a single reservation, Court of Justice jurisprudence recognizes circumstances in which the itinerary must be assessed by reference to the final destination rather than treating each segment as an independent journey. Separate bookings do not necessarily receive equivalent protection.


The operating airline, departure airport, destination, and contractual arrangements must be considered together. These distinctions also arise during disruptions unrelated to armed conflict, as illustrated by the Brussels Airport strike and EU261 passenger compensation. The regulatory protection available to passengers remains separate from the question of whether the particular event qualifies as an extraordinary circumstance.


3.2 Refunds, Alternative Flights, and Passenger Choice


Article 8 gives passengers affected by a covered cancellation a choice between reimbursement and alternative transportation. Reimbursement generally covers the full ticket price for the portions of the journey not undertaken, together with any completed portions that no longer serve a purpose in relation to the original travel plan. Where relevant, the airline must also provide transportation back to the initial departure point at the earliest opportunity.


The regulation requires reimbursement within seven days through the payment methods specified in Article 7(3), including cash and electronic bank transfer. Travel vouchers or other services may be substituted only with the passenger's signed agreement. The airline cannot automatically discharge its reimbursement obligation by offering a credit that the passenger has not validly accepted.


The Court of Justice clarified the consent requirement in Cobult v TAP Air Portugal (Case C-76/23), decided on March 21, 2024. The Court held that submitting an online form may satisfy the statutory requirement for the passenger's signed agreement, even without a handwritten or digital signature, provided that the passenger makes an effective and informed choice. The airline must supply clear and complete information about the available reimbursement methods and cannot use an unfair procedure to make monetary reimbursement more difficult to obtain.


Passengers who still wish to travel may instead choose rerouting to their final destination under comparable transport conditions at the earliest opportunity. A further option permits rerouting at a later date convenient to the passenger, subject to the availability of seats. These are alternatives within Article 8, not cumulative entitlements to both a full refund and replacement transportation for the same canceled journey.


During widespread conflict-related disruption, rerouting may involve connections through airports outside the affected area. The legal requirement concerns suitable alternative transportation rather than reproduction of the original flight path. Different carriers, connecting services, and available departure times may become relevant when determining whether the airline has fulfilled its obligation.


The Court of Justice has recognized that an airline cannot necessarily satisfy its obligations by offering only its next available service where a reasonable earlier alternative exists. Independent replacement travel may also create a reimbursement claim when the carrier fails to offer appropriate rerouting. Recovery depends on the circumstances, including the alternatives available, the carrier's response, and whether the expenditure was reasonable.


A qualification applies to package travel. Article 8(2) limits the separate right to airline-ticket reimbursement where that entitlement arises under the applicable package-travel regime. In HQ and Others v Aegean Airlines (Case C-163/18), the Court held that passengers entitled to reimbursement from their package organizer under the package-travel legislation then applicable could not recover the same ticket price from the airline under EU261, even where the organizer was financially incapable of paying.


Although that judgment concerned the former Package Travel Directive, the distinction between reimbursement rights arising under package-travel legislation and those arising directly against the operating carrier remains relevant. Passengers who purchased qualifying packages must identify the responsible party and applicable reimbursement provisions rather than assume that every ticket refund is payable directly by the airline.


3.3 Delayed Flights and Missed Connections


A delayed flight is not legally identical to a cancellation. Article 6 establishes departure-delay thresholds for assistance according to flight distance. The relevant periods are two hours for flights of 1,500 kilometers or less, three hours for specified intermediate-distance flights, and four hours for the remaining longer-distance category.


A departure delay of at least five hours can trigger the reimbursement option under Article 8(1)(a). A passenger whose journey no longer serves its original purpose may be entitled to the applicable refund and, where relevant, transportation back to the initial departure point. This remedy is distinct from compensation for arriving late.


Although the original regulation does not expressly establish standardized compensation for every arrival delay, the Court of Justice developed that entitlement through its interpretation of Articles 5, 6, and 7. In Sturgeon and Others (Joined Cases C-402/07 and C-432/07), subsequently confirmed in Nelson and Others (Joined Cases C-581/10 and C-629/10), the Court recognized compensation for qualifying delays of three hours or more at the final destination, subject to the extraordinary-circumstances defense.


Middle Eastern rerouting may produce missed connections even where the first flight operates. For a journey booked under a single reservation, the delay at the final destination can be decisive under the applicable EU261 rules. A missed connection involving separately purchased tickets presents different contractual and jurisdictional questions.


Neither a longer flight path nor the existence of a missed connection independently establishes compensation. The passenger must satisfy the relevant conditions concerning the journey, arrival delay, operating carrier, and applicable legal regime. The airline may also invoke an extraordinary-circumstances defense where the statutory requirements are established.


4. Accommodation, Meals, and Other Passenger Assistance


Article 9 of Regulation 261/2004 requires airlines to provide specified forms of care during qualifying disruption. Depending on the circumstances, passengers must receive meals and refreshments proportionate to the waiting period, communication facilities, and hotel accommodation where an overnight or additional stay becomes necessary. Transportation between the airport and the accommodation must also be provided.


The obligation is particularly significant when conflict-related restrictions prevent passengers from departing for several days. Accommodation and food expenses may exceed the original ticket price, especially at major international transit hubs. The regulation nevertheless treats care as a separate obligation addressing immediate needs rather than as part of the standardized compensation award.


The duration of the duty depends partly on the passenger's choice under Article 8. A passenger waiting for rerouting at the earliest opportunity may continue to require accommodation and other assistance. By contrast, the European Commission's 2024 Interpretative Guidelines explain that the right to continuing care ends when the passenger chooses reimbursement or agrees to rerouting at a later date for personal convenience.


The Court of Justice addressed prolonged disruption in McDonagh v Ryanair (Case C-12/11), decided on January 31, 2013. The proceedings arose after the eruption of Iceland's Eyjafjallajökull volcano in 2010 caused extensive European airspace closures. The passenger was unable to travel and sought reimbursement for expenses incurred while awaiting alternative transportation.


The Court held that extraordinary circumstances do not eliminate the duty of care. It also concluded that EU261 contains no general temporal or monetary limitation on the obligation to provide the assistance specified in Article 9. The exceptional duration and character of the volcanic disruption did not justify treating passengers as having lost their statutory protections.


The judgment does not establish an unrestricted entitlement to every expense a passenger chooses to incur. Where an airline fails to provide required assistance, reimbursement of independently incurred costs is assessed according to what was necessary, appropriate, and reasonable in the circumstances. Hotel receipts, meal expenses, and evidence that assistance was requested may be relevant.


Passengers affected by armed conflict occupy a comparable legal position where EU261 applies. Security conditions may prevent an airline from operating a flight, but they do not automatically excuse the provision of necessary meals or accommodation. The airline's logistical difficulties must be distinguished from the continuing existence of its statutory obligations.


5. When Is Financial Compensation Payable?


Regulation 261/2004 provides standardized financial compensation in qualifying cases of canceled flights and sufficiently long arrival delays. Article 7 establishes three principal amounts: €250 for flights of 1,500 kilometers or less; €400 for intra-EU flights exceeding 1,500 kilometers and other flights between 1,500 and 3,500 kilometers; and €600 for the remaining longer-distance flights. Distance is calculated using the great-circle method.


Cancellation does not automatically create an entitlement to these amounts. Article 5 excludes compensation in specified circumstances involving sufficiently early notice or alternative transportation satisfying statutory departure and arrival limits. Article 7(2) also permits a reduction of 50 percent in certain rerouting situations.


The most significant question during conflict-related aviation disruption is whether extraordinary circumstances caused the cancellation or delay and whether reasonable measures could have avoided its consequences. An airline may owe reimbursement while owing no standardized compensation. Equally, the existence of regional hostilities does not establish that every cancellation during the affected period qualifies for exemption.


5.1 Armed Conflict as an Extraordinary Circumstance


Article 5(3) exempts an operating carrier from standardized compensation where it proves that the cancellation resulted from extraordinary circumstances that could not have been avoided even if all reasonable measures had been taken. Recital 14 identifies political instability, security risks, incompatible meteorological conditions, and certain other events as circumstances that may satisfy the relevant conditions.


The Court of Justice clarified the governing interpretation in Wallentin-Hermann v Alitalia (Case C-549/07), decided in December 2008. An event must, by its nature or origin, fall outside the normal exercise of the airline's activity and be beyond its actual control. These requirements are cumulative, and the carrier must also establish that the consequences could not have been avoided through reasonable measures.


Military hostilities and credible threats to civilian aircraft can satisfy the extraordinary-circumstances standard. A binding national prohibition preventing an airline from using a necessary route may provide strong evidence of a qualifying external event. The legal conclusion nevertheless depends on the particular flight and the alternatives reasonably available.


An EASA Conflict Zone Information Bulletin may support the airline's account of the security environment. Its evidentiary significance depends on its geographical coverage, operational recommendations, validity at the relevant time, and relationship to the flight concerned. A warning concerning one portion of the Persian Gulf cannot, without further explanation, establish why a service operating elsewhere was canceled.


Some decisions involve both safety and commercial considerations. Rerouting may increase fuel consumption, crew requirements, and operating costs. Those consequences may be relevant to the reasonable-measures assessment, but ordinary commercial inconvenience does not automatically transform an operational decision into an extraordinary circumstance.


5.2 Air Traffic Restrictions and the 2026 Court Judgment


On October 8, 2026, the Court of Justice delivered its judgment in D (Air Traffic Management Decision) (Case C-108/26 RX). The case concerned a passenger traveling from Izmir to Warsaw whose flight arrived more than three hours late. The aircraft had previously been delayed by an air traffic management decision associated with adverse weather conditions in Hungary and Romania. A technical fault discovered during the subsequent operation also contributed to the delay.


The legal question concerned whether an air traffic management decision should automatically be treated as an extraordinary circumstance because it originated outside the airline's authority. The General Court had adopted an interpretation giving decisive significance to the external nature of the decision. The Court of Justice reviewed that approach because of its implications for the unity and consistency of EU law.


The Court of Justice rejected automatic classification. It held that the reason underlying the air traffic management decision must be examined individually to establish whether the event falls outside the normal exercise of the carrier's activities and beyond its actual control. The mere fact that an air traffic authority issued the decision does not establish the statutory exemption (CJEU, 2026, Case C-108/26 RX, para. 62).


The judgment also addressed delays caused by more than one event. Where a qualifying arrival delay results partly from extraordinary circumstances and partly from ordinary operational problems, the period attributable to the extraordinary event must be deducted from the total arrival delay when determining whether compensation is payable. This follows the approach previously established in Pešková and Peška (Case C-315/15).


An event may qualify as an extraordinary circumstance even when it independently causes less than three hours of delay. Its legal significance depends on the conditions governing that classification and its established contribution to the total disruption. The carrier cannot automatically attribute the entire delay to an external event when other causes also contributed (CJEU, 2026, Case C-108/26 RX, paras. 63–66).


The judgment arose from weather-related traffic restrictions and a technical problem rather than armed conflict. Its reasoning nevertheless informs the assessment of security-related airspace measures. A military threat may justify a restriction, but the airline must still establish how that restriction affected the particular flight and whether the statutory conditions for exemption were satisfied.


5.3 Causation, Reasonable Measures, and Airline Liability


The extraordinary-circumstances defense requires more than identifying an external event. The airline must establish a causal connection between that event and the cancellation or qualifying delay. A disruption affecting an earlier flight may be relevant where the same aircraft was scheduled to operate a later service, but the relationship must be demonstrated.


In LE v Transportes Aéreos Portugueses (Case C-74/19), the Court of Justice examined a delay following the diversion of an aircraft because of an unruly passenger. The Court accepted that extraordinary circumstances affecting an earlier flight could, under specified conditions, be invoked in relation to a subsequent flight operated by the same aircraft. A direct causal connection remained necessary.


The judgment also addressed reasonable rerouting measures. An airline seeking exemption from compensation cannot ordinarily rely solely on offering its next available service where an earlier suitable connection operated by another carrier was available. Direct and indirect alternatives, including services outside the airline's alliance, may need to be considered.


This obligation has limits. Airlines are not required to make intolerable sacrifices in light of their operational capacities. During armed conflict, a route that appears commercially available may present unacceptable security risks or require permissions that cannot reasonably be obtained.


In contested cases, the airline must substantiate the obstacle that prevented the flight or reasonable alternative transportation. Relevant evidence may include national restrictions, security warnings, operational records, available connections, and the measures taken in response to changing circumstances. A general assertion that the Middle East was unsafe does not establish the statutory defense for every itinerary.


6. Who Has the Legal Authority to Close Airspace?


The authority to restrict access to national airspace belongs principally to the state exercising sovereignty over the territory concerned. Governments may establish prohibited areas, impose emergency flight restrictions, or deny access for reasons of military necessity and public safety. These powers operate within the international legal framework governing civil aviation.


National aviation regulators exercise a different function when supervising airlines subject to their jurisdiction. They may impose binding operational restrictions on those carriers, including prohibitions on entering particular foreign airspace. Such measures regulate the conduct of the operators concerned without transferring territorial authority over the affected airspace.


Commercial airlines remain responsible for determining whether their operations can be conducted safely under applicable law. An airline may suspend a service even where the destination government continues permitting international flights. The resulting cancellation may resemble one caused by a national prohibition, although the legal basis for the decision differs.


6.1 Articles 1 and 9 of the Chicago Convention


The Convention on International Civil Aviation, signed at Chicago on December 7, 1944, establishes the principal treaty framework for international civil aviation. Article 1 recognizes each contracting state's complete and exclusive sovereignty over the airspace above its territory. Article 2 defines territory for the Convention's purposes by reference to land areas and adjacent territorial waters under the relevant state's authority.


Article 6 provides that scheduled international air services may not operate over or into another contracting state's territory without special permission or other authorization. Permission to conduct international services consequently depends on the relevant state, subject to applicable aviation agreements and the conditions attached to the authorization.


Article 9 addresses prohibited areas more directly. Paragraph (a) permits contracting states, for military necessity or public safety, to restrict or prohibit foreign aircraft from flying over designated areas of their territory. The provision imposes conditions concerning nondiscrimination and the reasonable extent and location of such areas. Paragraph (b) permits temporary restrictions during exceptional circumstances, emergencies, or in the interest of public safety, subject to its own requirements.


The treaty's rules address the authority of states to regulate access to their territorial airspace. They also distinguish general restrictions on foreign aviation from emergency measures responding to immediate security conditions. Article 9 includes provisions concerning the communication of prohibited areas and the treatment of aircraft entering them.


An airspace closure adopted for public safety reasons does not determine whether the underlying military operations comply with international law. The legality of armed force must be assessed under the separate rules governing the use of force and, where applicable, international humanitarian law. Aviation restrictions and the legality of hostilities are related but distinct questions.


6.2 War, National Emergencies, and Article 89


Article 89 of the Chicago Convention addresses war and national emergencies. It provides that, in time of war, the Convention does not affect the freedom of action of contracting states concerned, whether as belligerents or neutrals. The same principle applies to a contracting state that declares a national emergency and notifies the ICAO Council (Chicago Convention, 1944, art. 89).


The provision recognizes that exceptional security conditions may require measures beyond those normally associated with international commercial aviation. A state involved in hostilities may need to restrict access to airspace through which military aircraft, missiles, or defensive systems operate. Neutral states may also face risks created by military activity near their territory.


Article 89 does not establish that all airspace within an armed conflict automatically becomes closed. Nor does it determine the legality of military operations under the United Nations Charter or international humanitarian law. Those obligations require separate assessment and cannot be resolved solely by reference to the Chicago Convention's emergency provisions.


6.3 Flight Information Regions and Official Restrictions


A Flight Information Region is an area established for the provision of flight information and alerting services. Its boundaries do not necessarily coincide with national borders. Some FIRs extend over international waters, where responsibility for providing air traffic services does not confer territorial sovereignty.


This distinction is particularly relevant in the Persian Gulf, where flight information responsibilities extend across maritime areas used by international aviation. A recommendation concerning an FIR does not necessarily mean that the state providing its air traffic services possesses sovereign authority over every part of that region. A comparable distinction arises in the treatment of military aviation and airspace jurisdiction over the North Sea.


States communicate operational restrictions through established aeronautical information systems, including Notices to Airmen or Air Missions, commonly called NOTAMs, and aeronautical information publications. These instruments provide information about restrictions, hazards, and operational requirements. Their legal significance depends on the competent authority issuing the measure and the underlying applicable rules.


An airline may consequently receive several types of information concerning the same airspace. A national prohibition may legally prevent entry, an EASA bulletin may recommend avoiding operations, and air traffic services may communicate temporary hazards. These documents can concern the same operational risk without having identical legal effects.


7. EASA, ICAO, and Airline Safety Decisions


International aviation safety depends on cooperation among states, aviation regulators, international institutions, air navigation service providers, and commercial operators. No single institution possesses unrestricted authority over all international flight operations. Governments exercise sovereignty over national airspace, while international and regional organizations develop common standards, communicate risks, and support operational coordination.


Conflict-zone operations present particular difficulties because civilian aviation authorities may not possess complete information about military activity. A government may know the locations of its own defensive systems without controlling the activities of opposing forces. Airlines operating across several jurisdictions must assess risks that may change rapidly and involve information unavailable through ordinary aeronautical channels.


The resulting safety system depends on multiple assessments rather than a single worldwide declaration that a route is safe or unsafe. These assessments may differ because institutions possess different information, exercise different legal powers, and supervise different operators. Differences in their recommendations do not necessarily establish that any authority has disregarded aviation safety.


7.1 The Legal Nature of EASA Conflict Zone Bulletins


EASA operates within the European aviation safety regulatory framework established principally by Regulation (EU) 2018/1139. Article 88 expressly addresses the agency's responsibilities concerning risks to civil aviation arising from conflict zones, including the issuance of EU-level recommendations and the sharing of relevant information. Operational responsibilities are also governed by applicable implementing legislation, including Commission Regulation (EU) No. 965/2012.


A Conflict Zone Information Bulletin identifies significant aviation security risks and communicates recommendations intended to support operational decision-making. EASA prepares these recommendations through consultation and coordination involving Member States and the European Commission. Common European risk assessments are supported by the Integrated EU Aviation Security Risk Assessment Group.


The agency does not acquire territorial jurisdiction over Iran, Iraq, Lebanon, or any other foreign state merely because it recommends avoiding their airspace. Its recommendations are distinct from national restrictions imposed by sovereign authorities. Binding instructions issued by competent national regulators must also be distinguished from the advisory wording of an EASA bulletin.


The legal significance of a bulletin nevertheless extends beyond its nonbinding character. Airlines operate under regulatory systems requiring appropriate safety management, operational risk assessment, and compliance with applicable aviation requirements. A recommendation identifying severe conflict-related hazards is relevant when evaluating whether an operator has adequately assessed the risks of a proposed flight.


The distinction also affects passenger claims. A bulletin may provide persuasive evidence concerning regional security conditions, but it does not automatically prove that every cancellation was unavoidable. Conversely, airlines need not wait for EASA to issue an advisory before suspending an operation that their own assessment establishes would expose passengers and crews to unacceptable risks.


7.2 ICAO Conflict-Zone Guidance After MH17


The destruction of Malaysia Airlines Flight MH17 on July 17, 2014, exposed serious risks associated with commercial aviation near armed conflict. The aircraft was flying over eastern Ukraine when it was brought down, killing all 298 people aboard. The disaster intensified international scrutiny of the information available to states and airlines concerning military threats to commercial aircraft.


The incident demonstrated that conflict-related risks are not confined to aircraft taking off or landing near military operations. Weapons capable of reaching high altitudes can threaten international overflights even where the relevant corridor ordinarily carries commercial traffic. The danger includes the possibility that military personnel may misidentify civilian aircraft.


ICAO subsequently developed more detailed conflict-zone risk assessment guidance. Its Risk Assessment Manual for Civil Aircraft Operations Over or Near Conflict Zones, Doc 10084, reached its third edition in 2023. The manual addresses deliberate attacks and unintended consequences of military operations, including risks associated with surface-to-air missiles, ballistic missiles, air-to-air attacks, and other weapons capable of threatening civil aviation (ICAO, 2023).


The guidance examines the responsibilities of states managing airspace, states overseeing operators, air navigation service providers, and airlines themselves. It addresses the identification and communication of threats, assessment of operational vulnerabilities, and measures for restricting or restoring airspace operations. Its function is to improve risk management rather than establish ICAO as an authority empowered to close every dangerous airspace.


The protection of civilian aircraft is also reflected in Article 3 bis of the Chicago Convention. The provision was introduced by the Protocol adopted on May 10, 1984, which entered into force on October 1, 1998. It requires states to refrain from using weapons against civil aircraft in flight and to avoid endangering occupants or aircraft safety during interception, while preserving the United Nations Charter's framework and the other qualifications contained in the provision.


Article 3 bis was not part of the Convention's original 1944 text. Its development reflected earlier incidents involving the use of force against civilian aircraft, and its significance extends to subsequent questions of state responsibility and lawful interception. These issues are examined in the separate analysis of the Raúl Castro indictment and the international law governing attacks on civilian aircraft.


ICAO's conflict-zone guidance provides an international reference for identifying and managing aviation hazards, but it cannot eliminate uncertainty during military operations. States remain responsible for exercising their legal powers, while operators must evaluate the risks affecting their planned routes. The central lesson from MH17 is that the absence of a formal airspace closure cannot safely be treated as proof that a commercial flight faces no unacceptable military danger.


8. Passenger Rights Outside EU261


European passenger-protection legislation does not govern every journey affected by Middle Eastern airspace restrictions. Flights outside EU261's geographical and carrier-based scope may instead be governed by national consumer-protection rules, international carriage conventions, and contractual obligations. A passenger's nationality does not independently establish eligibility under EU261.


The United Kingdom maintains a separate passenger-rights framework following its withdrawal from the European Union. The UK Civil Aviation Authority identifies coverage for flights departing from UK airports, flights arriving in the United Kingdom on UK or EU carriers, and flights arriving in the EU on UK carriers. The regime also addresses reimbursement, alternative transportation, assistance, and compensation, although its geographical scope and monetary rules must be assessed independently of EU261 (UK Civil Aviation Authority, Cancellations).


United States aviation consumer-protection rules establish another system. The Department of Transportation's refund requirements apply to qualifying flights to, from, or within the United States. Passengers are generally entitled to refunds when airlines cancel or significantly change covered flights and passengers do not accept the alternative arrangements offered. The rules do not create a general European-style entitlement to fixed compensation merely because a service was canceled (US Department of Transportation, Refunds).


International carriage may additionally engage the Montreal Convention of 1999. Article 19 establishes carrier liability for damage occasioned by delay in the carriage of passengers, baggage, or cargo. It also provides a defense where the carrier establishes that it and its servants and agents took all measures reasonably required to avoid the damage, or that taking such measures was impossible (Montreal Convention, 1999, art. 19).


This treaty regime differs from EU261's standardized compensation system. A Montreal Convention claim concerns legally recoverable damage associated with delay and is subject to the Convention's conditions, defenses, and applicable liability limits. Cancellation alone does not automatically establish liability under Article 19. Article 35 also establishes a two-year period for bringing qualifying damages actions, subject to the treaty's provisions.


A separate question arises where passengers decide not to travel. If an airline continues operating the booked service, a passenger's voluntary cancellation does not automatically trigger the reimbursement rights associated with an airline-initiated cancellation under Article 5 of EU261. The financial consequences may depend on the fare conditions, applicable consumer legislation, or travel insurance.


Package travel can produce a different result. Article 12(2) of Directive (EU) 2015/2302 permits qualifying travelers to terminate a package contract without a termination fee where unavoidable and extraordinary circumstances at the destination or its immediate vicinity significantly affect performance of the package or transportation to the destination. Serious security problems, including warfare, may satisfy these conditions.


The Court of Justice addressed the provision in M. D. v Tez Tour (Case C-299/22), decided on February 29, 2024. The Court recognized that circumstances may significantly affect a package where they create serious safety risks, even when performance is not physically impossible. An official recommendation against travel is not an indispensable condition, and relevant individual circumstances may inform an objectively grounded assessment.


The judgment also established an important temporal limitation. Circumstances already known or reasonably foreseeable when the package was booked cannot ordinarily justify termination without a fee under Article 12(2) merely because the traveler later wishes to avoid them. Significant subsequent changes may, however, create a new situation satisfying the provision. The assessment must consider the circumstances existing when the contract is terminated.


Directive (EU) 2026/1024 subsequently amended the package-travel framework. Although it entered into force in May 2026, Member States are required to apply the new implementing measures from March 29, 2029. The rights governing package cancellations in November 2026 must consequently be assessed under the currently applicable rules rather than the future amended regime.


A passenger who independently purchased a nonrefundable airline ticket may accordingly face different conditions from someone who booked a qualifying package. The distinction becomes particularly significant when commercial flights continue operating but security conditions at the destination have deteriorated. The contractual arrangement and governing legal regime determine which rights can be invoked.


9. Establishing and Enforcing a Passenger Claim


The outcome of a passenger claim depends on the circumstances of the individual journey. A booking confirmation identifies the itinerary, ticket arrangements, and operating carrier. The cancellation notice may establish when the passenger was informed and what reason was given for the disruption. These details determine whether EU261 applies and which remedies may be available.


The reason stated in an airline's notification is relevant but not necessarily conclusive. A reference to extraordinary circumstances must be assessed against the events affecting the particular flight. Where standardized compensation is disputed, the carrier bears the burden of establishing the conditions required for exemption under Article 5(3).


Refund and rerouting disputes may raise different evidentiary questions. A reimbursement claim requires identification of the qualifying cancellation, applicable ticket arrangements, and relevant statutory rights. A rerouting dispute may require consideration of the alternatives offered, their timing, and whether the passenger had access to suitable transportation under comparable conditions.


Where an airline has failed to provide required assistance, documentary evidence may establish the expenses incurred. Hotel receipts, meal costs, transportation expenses, and records of communications with the airline can support a claim for reimbursement of necessary and reasonable expenditure. The evidence must relate to the period and circumstances in which the statutory duty of care applied.


Claims should ordinarily begin with the operating carrier. Passengers may identify the applicable legal entitlement, explain the circumstances of the flight, and specify whether they seek reimbursement, rerouting-related expenditure, care costs, or standardized compensation. A ticket-refund claim does not ordinarily require proof of airline negligence. A contested compensation claim involving extraordinary circumstances presents additional questions of causation and reasonable measures.


If the airline rejects or fails to resolve the claim, further procedures may be available through competent national enforcement authorities, alternative dispute-resolution mechanisms, or courts. The appropriate route depends on the jurisdiction, the type of claim, and the legal powers of the body concerned. National enforcement authorities do not all possess identical powers to determine individual monetary disputes or compel payment.


Limitation periods also require attention. EU261 does not establish a single uniform period applicable to judicial compensation proceedings throughout the European Union. In Cuadrench Moré v KLM (Case C-139/11), the Court of Justice held that relevant limitation periods are determined by applicable national rules. Montreal Convention claims operate under their separate treaty provisions.


The same regional aviation emergency may consequently produce several legally distinct claims. One passenger may seek reimbursement for a canceled flight, another may require accommodation while awaiting rerouting, and a third may dispute the airline's refusal to pay standardized compensation. Each claim must be assessed under the legal regime governing the particular journey and remedy.


Conclusion


Middle Eastern airspace restrictions arise from the interaction of sovereign authority, international aviation safety rules, and commercial airline decisions. Under the Chicago Convention, states possess legal powers to regulate and restrict access to their territorial airspace, including during military emergencies. EASA may identify serious conflict-zone risks and recommend avoiding specified routes, but its bulletins do not themselves constitute sovereign closures of foreign airspace.


The current expiration date of November 16, 2026, does not establish when normal Middle Eastern flight operations will resume. The six relevant EASA bulletins may be extended or revised, while other regional advisories remain subject to different validity periods. National restrictions, continuing military threats, and airline safety assessments may prevent services from operating even after a particular warning has been relaxed.


For passengers, the legal consequences are more specific than a general assertion that cancellations caused by war are beyond an airline's control. Where EU261 applies, qualifying cancellations ordinarily preserve rights to reimbursement or rerouting and applicable care. Genuine extraordinary circumstances may exclude standardized compensation, but the carrier must establish the relevant statutory conditions, including causation and the requirement concerning reasonable measures.


The decisive questions concern the legal regime governing the particular flight, the actual cause of its disruption, and the remedies available under that regime. Airspace may be restricted for compelling public safety reasons without extinguishing the obligations owed to passengers whose journeys have been interrupted.


References


Convention on International Civil Aviation (1944) signed at Chicago, 7 December 1944; entered into force 4 April 1947. ICAO Doc 7300. Available at: https://www.icao.int/publications/documents/7300_orig.pdf


Convention for the Unification of Certain Rules for International Carriage by Air (1999) adopted at Montreal, 28 May 1999; entered into force 4 November 2003. Official Journal of the European Communities, L 194, 18 July 2001, pp. 39–49. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/convention/2001/539/oj


Court of Justice of the European Union (2008) Friederike Wallentin-Hermann v Alitalia – Linee Aeree Italiane SpA, Case C-549/07, judgment of 22 December 2008, ECLI:EU:C:2008:771. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:62007CJ0549


Court of Justice of the European Union (2009) Christopher Sturgeon and Others v Condor Flugdienst GmbH and Stefan Böck and Cornelia Lepuschitz v Air France SA, Joined Cases C-402/07 and C-432/07, judgment of 19 November 2009, ECLI:EU:C:2009:716. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=ecli:ECLI:EU:C:2009:716


Court of Justice of the European Union (2012) Joan Cuadrench Moré v Koninklijke Luchtvaart Maatschappij NV, Case C-139/11, judgment of 22 November 2012, ECLI:EU:C:2012:741. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:62011CJ0139


Court of Justice of the European Union (2012) Emeka Nelson and Others v Deutsche Lufthansa AG and TUI Travel plc and Others v Civil Aviation Authority, Joined Cases C-581/10 and C-629/10, judgment of 23 October 2012, ECLI:EU:C:2012:657. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:62010CJ0581


Court of Justice of the European Union (2013) Denise McDonagh v Ryanair Ltd, Case C-12/11, judgment of 31 January 2013, ECLI:EU:C:2013:43. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:62011CJ0012


Court of Justice of the European Union (2017) Marcela Pešková and Jiří Peška v Travel Service a.s., Case C-315/15, judgment of 4 May 2017, ECLI:EU:C:2017:342. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:62015CJ0315


Court of Justice of the European Union (2019) HQ and Others v Aegean Airlines SA, Case C-163/18, judgment of 10 July 2019, ECLI:EU:C:2019:585. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:62018CJ0163


Court of Justice of the European Union (2020) LE v Transportes Aéreos Portugueses SA, Case C-74/19, judgment of 11 June 2020, ECLI:EU:C:2020:460. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:62019CJ0074


Court of Justice of the European Union (2024) Cobult UG v TAP Air Portugal SA, Case C-76/23, judgment of 21 March 2024, ECLI:EU:C:2024:253. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:62023CJ0076


Court of Justice of the European Union (2024) M. D. v UAB ‘Tez Tour’, Case C-299/22, judgment of 29 February 2024, ECLI:EU:C:2024:181. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/CASE/?uri=CELEX:62022CJ0299


Court of Justice of the European Union (2026) D (Air Traffic Management Decision), Case C-108/26 RX, judgment of 8 October 2026, ECLI:EU:C:2026:838. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:62026CJ0108


Commission Regulation (EU) No 965/2012 (2012) of 5 October 2012 laying down technical requirements and administrative procedures related to air operations. Official Journal of the European Union, L 296, 25 October 2012, pp. 1–148. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/ALL/?uri=CELEX:32012R0965


Directive (EU) 2015/2302 (2015) of the European Parliament and of the Council of 25 November 2015 on package travel and linked travel arrangements. Official Journal of the European Union, L 326, 11 December 2015, pp. 1–33. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/ALL/?uri=CELEX:32015L2302


Directive (EU) 2026/1024 (2026) of the European Parliament and of the Council of 29 April 2026 amending Directive (EU) 2015/2302 to make the protection of travellers more effective and to simplify and clarify certain aspects of that Directive. Official Journal of the European Union, L, 2026/1024, 8 May 2026. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/dir/2026/1024/oj/eng


European Commission (2024) Interpretative Guidelines on Regulation (EC) No 261/2004 of the European Parliament and of the Council establishing common rules on compensation and assistance to passengers in the event of denied boarding and of cancellation or long delay of flights and on Council Regulation (EC) No 2027/97 on air carrier liability in the event of accidents. Commission Notice C/2024/5687. Official Journal of the European Union, C, 25 September 2024. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:52024XC05687


European Union Aviation Safety Agency (2026) Airspace of Iran: Conflict Zone Information Bulletin CZIB-2026-04-R2 [online]. Revised 30 September 2026. Available at: https://www.easa.europa.eu/en/domains/air-operations/czibs/czib-2026-04-r2 (Accessed: 10 November 2026).


European Union Aviation Safety Agency (2026) Airspace of Iraq: Conflict Zone Information Bulletin CZIB-2026-05-R2 [online]. Revised 30 September 2026. Available at: https://www.easa.europa.eu/en/domains/air-operations/czibs/czib-2026-05-r2 (Accessed: 10 November 2026).


European Union Aviation Safety Agency (2026) Airspace of Jordan: Conflict Zone Information Bulletin CZIB-2026-08-R3 [online]. Revised 14 October 2026. Available at: https://www.easa.europa.eu/en/domains/air-operations/czibs/czib-2026-08-r3 (Accessed: 10 November 2026).


European Union Aviation Safety Agency (2026) Airspace of Lebanon: Conflict Zone Information Bulletin CZIB-2026-06-R2 [online]. Revised 30 September 2026. Available at: https://www.easa.europa.eu/en/domains/air-operations/czibs/czib-2026-06-r2 (Accessed: 10 November 2026).


European Union Aviation Safety Agency (2026) Airspace of Saudi Arabia: Conflict Zone Information Bulletin CZIB-2026-09-R1 [online]. Revised 9 October 2026. Available at: https://www.easa.europa.eu/en/domains/air-operations/czibs/czib-2026-09-r1 (Accessed: 10 November 2026).


European Union Aviation Safety Agency (2026) Airspace of Syria: Conflict Zone Information Bulletin CZIB-2017-03R20 [online]. Revised 1 October 2026. Available at: https://www.easa.europa.eu/en/domains/air-operations/czibs/czib-2017-03r20 (Accessed: 10 November 2026).


European Union Aviation Safety Agency (2026) Airspace of the Persian Gulf and Gulf of Oman: Conflict Zone Information Bulletin CZIB-2026-07R3 [online]. Revised 30 September 2026. Available at: https://www.easa.europa.eu/en/domains/air-operations/czibs/czib-2026-07r3 (Accessed: 10 November 2026).


European Union Aviation Safety Agency (2026) Airspace of Yemen – Sana’a Flight Information Region: Conflict Zone Information Bulletin CZIB-2017-07R20 [online]. Revised 30 September 2026. Available at: https://www.easa.europa.eu/en/domains/air-operations/czibs/czib-2017-07r20 (Accessed: 10 November 2026).


European Union Aviation Safety Agency (2026) Conflict Zones Information Notes [online]. Available at: https://www.easa.europa.eu/en/domains/air-operations/czibs/information (Accessed: 10 November 2026).


European Union Aviation Safety Agency (n.d.) Information on Conflict Zones [online]. Available at: https://www.easa.europa.eu/en/domains/air-operations/information-on-conflict-zones (Accessed: 10 November 2026).


International Civil Aviation Organization (2023) Risk Assessment Manual for Civil Aircraft Operations Over or Near Conflict Zones. 3rd edn. Doc 10084. Montreal: International Civil Aviation Organization. Available at: https://www.icao.int/Security/SFP/Documents/Doc.10084.Third%20edition.pdf


Protocol Relating to an Amendment to the Convention on International Civil Aviation (Article 3 bis) (1984) signed at Montreal, 10 May 1984; entered into force 1 October 1998. ICAO Doc 9436. Available at: https://www.icao.int/secretariat/legal/Administrative%20Packages/3bis_en.pdf


Regulation (EC) No 261/2004 (2004) of the European Parliament and of the Council of 11 February 2004 establishing common rules on compensation and assistance to passengers in the event of denied boarding and of cancellation or long delay of flights. Official Journal of the European Union, L 46, 17 February 2004, pp. 1–8. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng


Regulation (EU) 2018/1139 (2018) of the European Parliament and of the Council of 4 July 2018 on common rules in the field of civil aviation and establishing a European Union Aviation Safety Agency. Official Journal of the European Union, L 212, 22 August 2018, pp. 1–122. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2018/1139/oj/eng


Regulation (EU) 2026/2202 (2026) of the European Parliament and of the Council of 16 September 2026 amending Regulation (EC) No 261/2004 and Council Regulation (EC) No 2027/97. Official Journal of the European Union, L, 2026/2202, 2 October 2026. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:32026R2202


Saudi Press Agency (2026) GACA: Attack Targets King Khalid International Airport in Riyadh [online]. 11 October. Available at: https://www.spa.gov.sa/en/N2698686 (Accessed: 10 November 2026).


UK Civil Aviation Authority (n.d.) Cancellations [online]. Available at: https://www.caa.co.uk/air-passengers/travel-problems-and-rights/flight-delays-and-cancellations/cancellations/ (Accessed: 10 November 2026).


United States Department of Transportation (n.d.) Refunds [online]. Available at: https://www.transportation.gov/individuals/aviation-consumer-protection/refunds (Accessed: 10 November 2026).

bottom of page